Meniere’s Burnout

Meniere's

Does Meniere’s disease burn out? That is a hard question to answer. Chronic illness by definition is long-term, and Meniere’s disease is a chronic illness. The hearing in the affected ear will degrade with time, as will the severity of the vertigo produced by it. The cochlea eventually becomes so damaged that there just isn’t anything else to destroy that can cause the violent vertigo that announces the start of this disease/syndrome. That has been my experience and the experience of thousands of other Meniere’s sufferers.

If you are on this path with me, eventually you will face the question of whether the ear is worth preserving any longer. When the ear produces more noise that useful sound. When the vertigo is so persistent that it interrupts any kind of meaningful life. That is when you artificially burn out the affected ear, either with surgery or with a chemical injection (usually gentamicin) That will get you the lasting relief that you crave, if the procedure is successful.

2024/07/dead-ear-doldrums

The teaser above spells it out, I had cochlear implant (CI) surgery in December 2024 (I wanted to have it done before the zombie apocalypse struck on January 20th) I had a labyrinthectomy at the same time, which makes sense because they generally are the same procedure. Drill out the labyrinth, insert the CI. Sometimes the CI instead goes into the mastoid region of the skull, which is where mine went. A labyrinthectomy will end the vertigo in more than 99% of the cases where the patient is experiencing vertigo stemming from that vestibular system.

There are (as there always is) the rare instances where the vertigo is made worse by this surgery. That would probably be because the vertigo was misdiagnosed as stemming from that vestibular mechanism, or the surgeon did not do enough to kill the balance mechanism in that ear. My surgeon filled the drilled-out area with gentamycin to eliminate this possibility. I’m almost feeling normal again a month later and I expect to improve beyond my old normal level now that the miscreant labyrinth has been removed.

It is a rather drastic and permanent cure, but it fits the definition of burnout. There is nothing left to burn if there is no balance system left to be affected by the excessive endolymphatic fluid pressure that is characteristic of Meniere’s disease. I had suffered for forty years from intermittent symptoms in that ear. When it stopped producing useful sound, when it started giving me mild vertigo for weeks on end, I had it unplugged. What else is an ear good for, really?

There are other, less drastic surgeries, too. A nerve section can halt the vertigo in the ear while leaving the hearing, for example. That was less than I wanted to do, so I didn’t even consider it. It is a long, hard struggle to recover from these surgeries, so I can imagine that most sufferers won’t want to go through this. Still, they are effective in most cases, and if someone is experiencing constant vertigo and their doctors are certain that the inner ear is the culprit, I can’t express strongly enough the relief that person will get from getting this surgery if their results are anything like mine.

Can Meniere’s heal itself though? Meniere’s being a chronic illness essentially rules this possibility out. You can moderate symptoms with treatments. You can learn the triggers for your symptoms and try to avoid them. You will go without symptoms, sometimes for years, convinced you’ve stopped your symptoms entirely.

However, if you really have a chronic illness, then the underlying cause of your symptoms is still there and you will still be susceptible to a reoccurrence of your symptoms. The real question is, “do I have a chronic illness?” and not “Does Meniere’s go away?”

You may not have a chronic illness. Most people with vestibular problems probably don’t, they just aren’t told this by their doctors when they are diagnosed. In most of the English-speaking world, they aren’t told this because, in most of the English speaking world they don’t separate Meniere’s and cochlear/endolymphatic hydrops as a diagnosis.

Meniere’s has a precursor affliction which is either known as cochlear hydrops or endolymphatic hydrops, depending on which specialist you are talking to at the time. Endolymph makes up the majority of the fluid in the inner ear, and it fills the entire cochlear region of the ear, making the two descriptions/diagnoses essentially identical for the purpose of discussion. I will be referring to cochlear/endolymphatic hydrops as simply hydrops from this point forward in the article.

In several countries in the world (namely Japan and Germany) they treat Meniere’s and cochlear hydrops as separate things. The reason I know this is a thing is because a German sufferer once asked me whether performing the Valsalva maneuver several times a day was risking his hearing. This activity was prescribed to him by a German doctor, and the proof of this was backed up on the German Wikipedia page for cochlear hydrops.

During that journey into the way other countries approach the subject of vestibular issues I ran across a statistic that showed that between 10-25% of people who have hydrops will go on to develop Meniere’s disease. The fact that a solid 75% of the people who showed initial symptoms of hydrops went on to not have long-term vestibular problems is a ray of sunshine for anyone suffering from these symptoms. You just might not have a chronic illness. Your odds are quite good.

If you have hydrops, it can just stop, especially if you have identified and properly addressed your triggers. If you have Meniere’s it’s chronic and it eventually burns out, possibly taking your hearing and balance with it. Currently the only way to tell if you will develop Meniere’s in the future is to time travel into the future at the usual rate of 1 sec/sec. In other words, time is the key. Time spent suffering.

Hydrops is by definition periodic. I probably had hydrops for twenty of the forty-one years I spent dealing with these symptoms. There were long segments of time, six months or so, where I was convinced I didn’t have a problem at all. Then I would be exposed to an environmental allergen again, and the symptoms would re-emerge and ruin my life for a few months.

If you haven’t yet had any permanent hearing loss (in the lower hearing ranges) then you probably don’t have Meniere’s yet. There is hope that your inner ears can recover, given time. If you do have permanent hearing loss that doesn’t respond to treatment, and you have the associated vertigo that comes with inner ear damage? I’m sorry, but you probably have Meniere’s disease.

The fact that one of these diagnoses is idiopathic (Meniere’s disease) and the other one can be, It’s hard to say what could be the mechanism for any of it. The fact of the matter is that hydrops only becomes Meniere’s disease when it gets bad enough to cause the symptoms that make up Meniere’s.

If it doesn’t get that bad then it stops for some reason. It may be some kind of plateau, or it may be that the causative behaviors or environmental influences have ceased. Generally, there’s no way to say why any one person stops having symptoms and why that other person ends up developing Meniere’s disease. There are too many variables at play.

However, burnout implies, or even bluntly states, that there is a “fire” consuming something, and it runs out of that thing that it’s burning on. So achieving burnout in this case would be a complete destruction of the balance and hearing systems of the affected ear, or at least damaging the system to the point where there’s no more damage that can be done to it.

I’m pretty sure that I hit burnout on the left ear. I can’t imagine it getting any worse than it was. I clung desperately to the belief that I would be able to preserve the hearing in that ear somehow. Hung on to that idea for 20 years. I can say for certain now that I hung on to it for too long.

I’m hoping that the right ear will end up not being the same; that the instigation of symptoms in that ear (being a hospice caregiver for my mother) was so uniquely traumatic and stressful that I will never have that kind of reaction again.

Maybe if I outlive my children or the wife I’ll be proven wrong. Maybe I’ll get lucky and die first. I have no idea. I just know that I can’t imagine something short of that being as much of a stress on my systems.

The right ear has behaved since 2019 when I was diagnosed with bilateral Meniere’s disease. Maybe it’ll end up being more like hydrops than my experience with the left ear’s Meniere’s disease has been. It’s something to hope for.

reddit – Featured image: pixels.com/stefan-rotter h/t to EkkoMusic, sH4d0w1ng and Neil Canham for asking the hard questions. Without you guys life would suck.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top