The name of the thread caught my eye first Potentially useful supplement for inflammation and the first warning light clicks on in my head for the use of the word supplement in the misspelled title (No capitalization of important words! Misspelled title!) It sounded pretty click-baity in my head. Sounded like someone trying to sell something to the sufferers on r/Meniere’s again.
Then I read the body of the OP and saw the name of the supplement, Phytoprofen, and the second warning light in my head goes on. A name that is specifically crafted to piggyback on the name of ibuprofen in the readers mind. The Fakespot Reviews Analysis bot is very informative. Thank you to the r/Meniere’s mods for incorporating this into the group.
There are suspect comments and recommendations related to this product, that’s why it gets a low grade by the bot. It seems like they’ve been building their reputation by paying people to leave positive reviews. That’s what that means. It’s about par for the course for every single supplement manufacturer out there. I don’t trust any of them.
Not so many kudos go to the price history bot who’s name confused me for a bit before I realized that it was not promoting the sale of the supplement on Amazon but was actually just giving me the price history, which was useful information to have.
It is, in fact, more expensive now than it’s ever been. Thanks again to the mods for putting these bots to work. It might be a good idea to change the username of the bot if you can. The heart symbol and the name itself do not imply that this is a bot or that it might, in fact, be providing useful information.
The OP had cited a study that lead him to take this supplement. I haven’t done an exhaustive search of the study of phytochemicals just to see if Phytoprofen wasn’t included in any of the many studies of this subject that have been published over the years. However, a cursory look over the data that is available doesn’t provide any solid links between a well-formed study and this particular blend of chemicals. I’d still love to be given a link to that data if it even exists.
Lacking that kind of data I would just drink ginger tea because it’s much cheaper. The other two herbs are Frankincense (Boswellia) and a derivative of Tumeric (Curcumin) I’m pretty sure I can add these things into my diet without spending $38 to get 40 capsules.
It was when I made the above observation that the user who promoted this supplement on r/Meneiere’s gave away their more than casual level of knowledge on this subject. They asserted that “You would have to eat a huge amount turmeric to get that dosage of curcumin.“ Yes. I’m sure that is true, but why do you know this? You know this because you know how much work went into making this supplement. You either work for them or you are being paid by them to promote it. That is the most likely explanation.
The third and final warning light is now blinking madly, and I am no longer taking the user seriously. This probably came across in the text of my replies.
For the record, Curcumin is poorly absorbed according to the wiki article. It’s not likely to be the thing doing whatever the users of this product think is being done. What is most likely going on is known as the placebo effect and that’s probably also why there are no reputable studies that demonstrate the effectiveness of this product.
The Begging Block
Writing is work. A lot of work. Maintaining a blog takes a lot of time and energy. I don’t have ads on the blog because I fucking hate advertising and I never received anything worth mentioning from Google ads during the decade I let them place ads on my blog (ditto for the Amazon affiliate program, which is why those links are now slowly going away) This means that if I want to defray the costs of maintaining this blog, it has to come from my readers. If you are reading this and if you can afford to throw me a buck, I’m counting on you to click one of the links below and send me a few of them. The Wife, the children and I thank you. Especially the children, who have grown tired of cold gruel.
While I respect and welcome skepticism, I don’t appreciate your condescension. If I want that, I can go talk to one of my doctors or someone at work who doesn’t understand MD. Please, in the future, when you see my posts, keep scrolling. I don’t need or want your input.
For the record, I am still symptom-free after resuming the supplement. I have never had my symptoms diminish once dizziness starts until an attack is over. Your experience is not the experience of everyone. You should probably remember that.
u/dowbrewer
This is not my experience talking; or rather, not my experience with Meniere’s talking. My Mother was a Christian Scientist. She didn’t believe in doctors and she died denying doctors knew anything. While she was alive, she plied me with every single snake oil she could get her hands on. She learned applied kinesiology from another snake oil salesman and used that to prove that the snake oil would work. It never did, because it was all bullshit.
She would have had me take this supplement too if it had been around while she was alive. Now that she’s dead, I listen to my doctors. If I don’t like what they say, I find another doctor. I only take the supplements they recommend, and none of them are recommending this. The reason why they aren’t recommending it is visible on the Wikipedia page that I linked previously.
As I say here frequently, if you can afford to spend money on things that aren’t proven, that’s your business. If you don’t have two nickels to rub together, I’m here for you. Don’t waste your money on things that can’t be proven to work. This supplement cannot be proven to work and I dare say the study that the Reddit user cited is flawed like most supplement studies are flawed. That’s how they make the study say things that aren’t true.
What they read as condescension is actually just skepticism; a healthy skepticism that I maintain for a reason, as I just outlined. No, I don’t need to take Phytoprofen and I’m not sure anybody else does, either. Sugar pills are also cheaper than this supplement and will probably work just about as well.


