She was born on a beautiful June day; June eighth, nineteen forty-one. I know it was a beautiful day because my mother was a beautiful person. No day that saw her begin could possibly be any other kind of day.
She was born Barbara Ann but her family called her Barbie. She hated her middle name because of the Beach Boys song. Many of her friends later in life called her Barb and not Barbie. Barbie was a toy, not a person, by that point in time. As a child and into adulthood though, her immediate family always called her Barbie and Barbie she shall remain for this article.
Barbie enjoyed life. If there is one simple thing that could be said about my mother, that is it. She enjoyed critters and green grass. Like a real life Snow White she would talk to the birds and the squirrels as if they were people; and while they didn’t talk back they reacted to her in ways that were different too. She enjoyed the pranks and jokes she engaged in with her older brother Kenny; who, like their father Randolph, got into trouble frequently because of his sense of humor.
Randy once took apart a neighbor’s wagon and reassembled it on the roof of his barn. The next morning when the neighbor went out to hitch up his team of horses, he was baffled to see his wagon somehow perfectly balanced on the roof. When told of the prank, Randy’s father berated him publicly, and they set to work getting the wagon back off the roof and onto solid ground. But secretly, he congratulated his son for being a chip off the old block. Pranks and japes were in the family blood.
Kenny was a prankster in the same light. He loved to make people laugh. Barbie was dragged along through many of his adventures, “the two of them against the world” as she put it. It was the two of them against the world because of the tragedy that befell the family in 1943.
Barbie’s mother was never the same after Barbie was born. Perhaps the best part of her left and became part of Barbie? No one knows. A few things are known for certain. The Zonges were Christian Scientist while Lucille was alive. Christian Science, founded by Mary Baker Eddy, promoted the wisdom of Jesus as all-healing. Christian Scientists don’t go to doctors. They pray to cure their ills; and back in the 1940’s, before antibiotics and rigorous scientific testing of medical means and methods, this wasn’t such a bad idea. The president’s own son died of an infection he received from a blister he developed playing tennis on the White House lawn in 1924, decades after Mary Baker Eddy’s creation of Christian Science. Medicine was still in its infancy well into the middle of the 20th century.
Another thing that is known is that Lucille contracted an unknown malady that kept her bedridden and bleeding internally for months. She never recovered even though Randolph went back on his promise to forsake a doctor’s advice and took his wife to the hospital where they performed exploratory surgery to attempt to correct her bleeding problem. This is the event that started Barbie down the path that she tread for the rest of her life; the belief that doctors were killers because they had killed her Mom. She blamed them for not being omniscient, for being all too fallible and human. She never got over this trauma.
This was the first dark cloud in Barbie’s and Kenny’s young lives. They were about to encounter the second dark cloud. Randolph had two small children and a full time job engineering. He simply did not have the time to tend to the needs of his new family all by himself. So he remarried.
Marie Mendler became Marie Zonge in 1945. She was a nice enough woman, if not experienced at raising children at the time. I cannot separate my own impressions of the woman from Barbie’s related narrative of her, from the reality of what her child rearing produced. So my judgment is going to be biased against her in this little biography. I will apologize for this in advance just to save time.
Marie locked Barbie in the closet pretty routinely. Even in her final years Barbie could be as stubborn as the day is long, but this was not a personality trait that Marie was ever going to accept. When Barbie wouldn’t do as she was told, into the closet she would go. There were beatings galore as well. There generally always were beatings back in that time and place, it was the rare exception where children were not beaten for misbehaving. However, locking them in a small room all day for minor infractions was not a thing that was commonplace.
The Mendlers ran a boarding house that her new step-mother was responsible for managing. Barbie was dragged along to help, which included entertaining an old man on the second floor. The old man was what we would call a pedophile today. A genuine pedophile, not the fake ones that evangelicals see around every corner and in the face of every LGBTQIA+ person they meet. This lecherous old man would abuse her, fondling her, putting his hands under her clothes, sticking his fingers in her, until she would run downstairs to tell her evil stepmother; who promptly sent her back up to him and demanded she stop telling lies.
Barbie eventually refused to spend time with the old leacher, repeating the accusation that this pedophile was sticking his hands in her panties and fondling her crotch. Marie’s response to this was to lock her in the closet again, this time for longer than a day. Marie kept Barbie locked in that closet until Barbie agreed to keep quiet about the pedophile and also agreed to go up and tend to all the needs of the old man while her stepmother was working at the boarding house. This horrific arrangement went on for quite some time, she never did tell me exactly how long, or exactly how many men raped her in that boarding house/brothel, but it at least lasted until the old man died. I think that old man was the only creature that Barbie was ever glad to see die.
The two children did survive childhood though; and given the nature of life during WWII, even in the US with its rationing and shortages, that is a creditable achievement for the young family. Marie had a child of her own by Randolph eight years after Barbie was born, a son to carry his name forward. I cannot say nicer things about her than the observations above, because little of nicety remains in the actual history of the family, and her history specifically.
Marie’s behavior towards Lucille’s children caused the two of them to bond more steadfastly than is normal for two siblings of so close an age. They saw themselves as pitted in a struggle against an invader in their family, and they clung to their mother’s religious beliefs as a testament of their love for her. They were forbidden to speak of Lucille in Marie’s hearing. She was their mother now and she never let them forget this fact.
Then there was the fire. When Barbie was in second grade the family’s house burned down. It was pure luck that she was in school when the house caught fire instead of at home with the rest of the family. Randolph had started a side-business to make extra money in the basement of their home and it was this side project that ended up costing them their home.
The x-ray films of the time had silver halide on them, and they were made of durable plastic which had many uses aside from being the film that x-rays could be viewed on. Randolph had developed a process for removing and preserving the silver for resale, and the then-transparent plastic sheets were used to make folders for displaying business proposals, an item for sale in most office supply stores to this day. It was a lucrative side-business, and both of them worked hard at getting the sheets properly cleaned and ready for sale to the company that produced the folders.
On that day in December, 1948, twelve year-old Kenny was home because it was midterms and his group had the day off, waiting for their tests. Marie had brought in a fresh stack of recently cleaned plastic sheets and set them on the table for checking when she accidentally knocked over an ashtray with a lit cigarette in it. Those old films were highly flammable, ethanol being one of the solvents used to remove the silver halide, and these sheets went up like torches. Kenny was briefly trapped in the burning home, and he suffered disfiguring burns that he tried to hide for the rest of his life.
After the fire the family moved from Williamsport, Pennsylvania to Cleveland, Ohio. This was a welcome change for Barbie. Leaving Williamsport meant getting away from the Mendler family boarding house. Away from the memories of being raped and abused and away from the house where their mother had died. When compared to her experiences in Williamsport, Barbie’s experiences in Cleveland seemed as if they were Lumined in white light. She loved Cleveland to her dying day because of the reprieve that the move provided for her.
It was in Cleveland where Kenny’s pranks almost got him into serious trouble, though. He had a life-sized dummy that he would cart around with him and use to scare people, especially around Halloween. He dropped it out of a tree one time and it landed upright in front of a woman carrying two bags of groceries. The woman looked up just in time to see the dummy landing in front of her. She screamed and nearly fainted, hurling her groceries all over the street, sidewalk and lawn.
Kenny was mortified. He jumped down out of the tree, apologizing loudly, picked up all the groceries and put them back in the bags, helped her up while still apologizing, then grabbed his dummy and ran away from the scene while she looked on dumbfounded, still in shock at the scare that she had just endured.
On another occasion his usual prank of propping the dummy up on the front door of a target’s house backfired. He had a rope tied around the boot at the bottom of one of the legs of the dummy, which he would use to pull the dummy away after the occupant of the house had been terrorized by this life-sized figure falling through their doorway when they opened it.
On this particular occasion, the rope got caught on the screen door; and not wanting to abandon his precious dummy, he ran back up on the porch. Apologizing nonstop to the offended homeowner, he bundled up his dummy and ran away, again. The homeowner or a passerby had recognized him though, and he was chastised by the local authorities and instructed not to be caught playing pranks like this anymore.
When they moved from Cleveland, Ohio to Sacramento, California the family made their final transition. Kenny ran away from the now appropriately named Wicked Witch of the West, refusing to go with the family to California. Instead he moved in with friends until he graduated high school. Then he joined the Army and served his two years. Went to college. Got married. Had children. That story is his story. Hopefully I’ll be able to write that story some day.
Barbie, still a minor, had to go to Sacramento with Marie and Randolph and her little brother Randy Jr. She spent her time going to high school and babysitting her little brother while her mother did odd jobs and her father worked a full-time job. Barbie basically became a maid, a nanny and a cook, providing free work to her parents who almost seemed to forget they even had children. When the time came for her to graduate high school, Barbie hatched a plot with her boyfriend Bob.
They eloped. Bob joined the Army much like Kenny had done a few years previously, and the two were stationed in England in the height of the cold war in the early nineteen-sixties. I was born there. Bob, her husband and my father, was very jealous of Barbie. She never told him or anyone else the story of her abuse until the day she told me the story when I was six and expressed my gender confusion to her. She never told Bob why she was distant. She let him believe she didn’t love him and that she was having an affair with someone else, rather than admit to being raped, repeatedly, as a child.
Consequently they divorced about six months after I was born. Six months after that Barbie married her second husband. Jack was never jealous of Barbie, even though she was a certifiably hot babe in her prime. She took after her mother Lucille, who was briefly a fashion model before becoming a wife and a mother. Jack wasn’t jealous because men who take dozens of lovers kind of expect, but don’t think about, their wives taking lovers of their own. That she wasn’t interested in sex frequently was a thing that never seemed to bother him. I’m sure he had more than enough action to keep him busy without having to demand daily access to her body.
Even though he was unfaithful almost from the moment they met and got married, Barbie and Jack stayed married from 1964 until 1976. They had three more children together, as well as miscarriages and abortions that she chafed at having to endure. I don’t believe she ever wanted to have children. Having children was just something that happened. She loved her children, she loved all children the same way she loved all the critters she encountered. I just don’t think that having her own children was any kind of life goal, much less that she wanted having and raising children to be her sole achievement in life.
I think she was happy in our home, even though she and Jack did fight frequently. It was Jack’s multiple lovers throwing their use of her husband in her face that ended up breaking up their marriage. She never forgave him for that transgression, even though she should have known that Jack had a wandering eye. It had been wandering when it found her. Both of them had been married before. Both of them would be married again. Jack’s third marriage lasted until his death. Barbie’s third marriage led to even more pain and suffering.
Billy, her third husband, was possessive and also a philanderer. He beat her and her children repeatedly, although I’m apparently the only one of the family to remember this fact about him. He would come home drunk from bars where he had been kissing on, and doing whatever with, the women he met there. He was a mean drunk, completely the opposite of Jack. Jack woke up with a glass of bourbon and water in the morning and drank bourbon and water until the sun went down. Even so, he rarely had a cross word for anyone aside from Barbie. Billy would crash in through the front door in the evenings, screaming and kicking and pissed about everything in life. Barbie didn’t know what to do with him. She loved him and her love grew more desperate as the years dragged on and he got more and more abusive to her and her children, especially me.
He went missing for a few days in the spring of 1978. Barbie had no idea where he had gone. Then one day he just drove back up the driveway in a car we’d never seen before, demanding his stuff. He was drunk and had a hooker in the passenger seat. Barbie wouldn’t let him get out of the car, which of course led to a screaming match on the driveway. Then the hooker backtalked Barbie.
Barbie walked around to the passenger side of the car, grabbed the woman by the hair, and started slamming her head against the window frame of the car. We children, who had piled out of the house when the screaming started, stood there looking on in amazement. We’d seen her angry before. She’d broken her fair share of rulers as well as dishes in fits of rage when I was a younger child, but I’d never seen her physically assault a person until that day. Never seen her with murder in her eyes before that day.
Then Billy got out of the car and started towards Barbie and I moved just as I had so many times before. Moved to protect my mother. As mad as Barbie was, when she saw me heading for trouble she ordered me to take the children into the house. I didn’t want to go, but I knew I needed to keep them from harm. Billy had kicked me in the stomach in one of his drunken rages when we had lived in Stinnett the previous year. I knew that he presented a credible threat to all of us.
In a desperate bid to save her marriage, she sent me away to live with Jack, thinking that getting me out of the house would allow her the space to prove to Billy that she loved him. I talked Jack into taking responsibility for all of Barbie’s children the next year, the rest of whom were his anyway, but even that extreme measure wasn’t enough to save Barbie and Billy’s doomed union. It ended in divorce just like her two previous marriages, and Barbie would never attempt to marry again. She showed little interest in men at all after that relationship ended, especially after the hysterectomy that had ended any chance of her having any more children.
What was the point in showing interest in men? She never had a wingman. Never had a relationship with anyone who wouldn’t stab her in the back the first chance they got. Business relationships were better, cleaner. A transactional relationship was reliable, dependable. “I have to do this for myself,” she would tell me over and over again. Fiercely independent. That was my mother. An independence that I clearly inherited from her.
Barbie left that tiny little excuse for a town, Rotan, the place where Billy abandoned her, and she moved to Sweetwater to learn a trade. Before she could finish her education Jack sent us all back to live with her again in 1980. We were a pain that he didn’t want to deal with long term. She just stopped what she was doing and started doing something else. We were her children and she was responsible for us. She took two and three jobs at a time and assigned me the same roles that she fulfilled in her last years at home. I did the work grudgingly and took a job myself to help pay for the expenses of the family.
I moved out as soon as I got a job that could pay my rent, eventually ending up in the nearby town of San Angelo, which had the benefit of being a college town. Barbie and the other three siblings moved in with the Wife and I when we finally rented a decent-sized house there. Six months later when we moved out of that house, we helped her sign for her first home since leaving Jack in Leoti. Barbie’s nest went empty in that house, and she went to school and became a nurse while living there.
She wanted to help people. That’s what she deemed herself good at. Helping people. She eventually became a hospice nurse, tending to the end of life needs of several people including the Wicked Witch of the West when her time came. Why she spent the time helping her at all I will never know. I did ask her and she said simply “she raised me. I owed her.” Knowing what I know about how Marie treated her, how Marie treated everyone around her, I think she was completely wrong on that subject.
As each of us left the nest her burden eased, but she was alone. The lone parent eventually surveying her empty nest after the baby of the family moved out. She followed one of my sisters to Albuquerque for a few years. The other sister moved there and Barbie helped them raise their children. Then my brother moved here to Austin and she moved here too, helping him raise his children. Back and forth she would go, from one sibling to the other sibling, to another hospice job, always putting other people before herself, never taking time to care for herself. To sleep enough. To get counseling for her trauma, which kept her from sleeping.
She was late everywhere she went. All her life. It was her passive-aggressive response to being required to go anywhere and do anything that she didn’t want to do. She showed up on time for events that I planned because I took her to them or I knew she would show up on her own because I had her word she would do that. It was a private joke we shared. She’d show up late and look at me with that knowing look. “If this had been something you wanted me to be here for, you would have asked me yourself.”
When I needed something done, I never asked Barbie because she was either going to be busy or exhausted, and I didn’t want to be the cause of her exhaustion. I asked friends to do things that others would have turned to grandparents for, or sent the children to visit the Wife’s parents on the farm. Barbie’s time was Barbie’s when she was staying with us, and that meant that very little of her time was spent tending to my children because someone else would demand that she help them instead.
On the rare occasions when she did show up at our house, hiding out from everyone else, she would generally fall asleep on the couch almost as soon as she sat down. She would sleep on our couch for a few days and then someone would call her asking Grandma to do this or that for their children or some new hospice assignment would come in. Not until the cancer struck her in 2016 did she have a spare moment, or so it seemed. Always and forever it was the needs of other people that took precedent.
The cancer stopped her cold. She came back to Austin from tending to the needs of one of my sisters and their children, emaciated and wizened beyond her years. It was clear she was ill; but she was, in fact, dying. It was stage four Transitive Cell Carcinoma the doctors said. She, of course, denied she had cancer.
Cancer was the ultimate insult. She had eaten healthy and exercised regularly. Led her Silver Sneakers exercise group every week. She prayed to Jesus just like she was supposed to do to keep things like cancer at bay. When I reiterated that the doctors said they were certain it was cancer, she hauled out her reliable old mantra “Doctors don’t know anything.” This was why she had become a nurse, so that she could save people from doctors. The trauma of her mother dying was still fresh in her mind, seventy years later.
“I have a parasite.” She insisted.
The naturopaths that she was going to instead of medical doctors made her drink turpentine, which killed her kidneys. “It was just a drop in a glass of water,” she said. Poison is poison, and weakened organs fail at the slightest provocation. She had surrounded herself with quacks and fraudsters over the years that she had been escaping a doctor’s supervision. They were convincing her to rely on applied kinesiology, teaching her how to engage in the fraud herself. Deluding herself with the illusion of science.
She refused the Keytruda treatment that the doctors were offering. They all said “It’s what she wants,” my siblings and her treating doctors, but that was not what she wanted when I was with her. What she wanted then was to hope, and medical care offered her that hope. I made her see that hope in spite of decades of indoctrination and additional years of misinformation and willful ignorance on her part. I made her see because I was the only one in the family more stubborn than she was.
When I resigned myself to the inevitability of her looming death, I did what a good daughter/son would do. What her only lifelong confidant would do. I sat vigil with her in shifts with my other siblings until she died one morning while I was shifting her position on the bed we had been administering her hospice care on. As I was holding her close to move her, I heard that thing they call the death rattle in her throat. Even in my bad ear, there was no mistaking that sound.
Did my hugging her kill her? Did I kill her? If my embrace was enough to ease her pain, send her into sweet oblivion and end her suffering, I would have held her in my arms for weeks. For as long as it took. Cancer killed her. I would never have harmed a hair on her head. I needed her to live.
Any interference I would have engaged in would have been to get her cancer treated so that she would live. Make her live longer so that she could help me unlock the sealed doors in my head. As the only other person who knew what was behind those doors, I needed her help to re-open them. Because she died I had to find a way to open those doors for myself even though I had lost the keys to them. That is my trauma though, not Barbie’s.
Barbie is gone; and now, with the emotional separation completed, hopefully her trauma will go with her and leave me to deal with my own trauma. I miss you Mommy, but I think I will be alright now. Goodbye Barbie.
Barbara Ann Polk 1941-2018

Her obituary as it appeared in the paper and online follows:
Barbara Ann Polk left this earth on February 9th, 2018 to be with the angels, while in the company of her family. Born June 8, 1941 in Williamsport, Pennsylvania, she was her mother’s youngest child and her father’s second child. Barbara moved many times in her life, Sacramento, CA; Leoti, KS; Sweetwater, TX; San Angelo, TX; Albuquerque, NM; and Buda/Austin, TX. She graduated from Angelo State University in 1992 with an RN and worked as a nurse and hospice care supervisor for many years. She was preceded in death by her mother – Lucille R. Lavo Zonge, her father Randolph Daniel Zonge Sr., her stepmother, Marie Mendler Zonge, and her brother Kenneth L. Zonge. She is survived by her brother, Randolph Daniel Zonge, Jr.; her children: Ray Anthony Steele, Jonnette Ann Kraft, Dawn Marie Wostal, John Russell Steele and her seven grandchildren and her three great-grandchildren. The family will have a private memorial service for her in the fall. She requested that in lieu of flowers, donations be made to World Vision. (www.worldvision.org)
There are several other articles on the blog that I wrote for my mother over the last year of her life while I was with her. Articles that I’ve written about my feelings for her and about her and the things that remind me of her. They are collected under the simple blog tag mom.
I encourage you to also read those posts.
A Letter to My Mother on Her Death Day
I’ve missed you since you’ve been gone, even though I doubt that you would miss me if our roles were reversed. I’m not saying you didn’t love me, I know you did. You said the words to me many times. What I’m saying is that you never acknowledged my needs beyond the requirements of basic survival; and since I would be dead if our roles were reversed, the most you would probably feel about my absence would be relief for not having that duty to deal with anymore.
You never remembered my birthday although you called me on the Wicked Witch of the West’s last birthday, the day after mine, just to get me to wish the old bitch a happy birthday (may she rot in her grave) even though neither she nor you ever could remember to call me on my birthday or even send a card.
It is the little things that are remembered, Mom. The little things like coming by and seeing grandchildren just to see them, not because you are required to babysit them. I never made that demand of you because the only time I did see you was when you were escaping from my siblings and their children’s demands, when you were tired and strung out and just needed some quiet time to sit on the couch and talk. I cherished those moments of honesty from you. They were quite rare and deserved to be cherished. Your grandchildren have almost no memory of you though, and that is a shame.
I don’t believe you ever wanted to have children. You certainly didn’t know what to do with me when I was born. It’s a good thing that there was a nanny there to help you because I really do wonder if I would have survived without her. To this day I feel embraced by the sound of Spanish spoken by a female voice because of that nanny. The loving attention that made the deepest mark on me in my most formative months was from a surrogate, not from my mother.
I remember the look on your face when you described what I was like as a baby. The constant crying, the inexplicable illnesses. The look of hopelessness that I saw there while you talked about what it was like said it all to me. This wasn’t what you wanted out of life. You wanted to take it all back but couldn’t now that you had children.
I’m writing this letter to you right now because my childhood memories are finally starting to come back to me. They are torturing me in my sleep. Some of them seem cloudy but others are crystal clear, even though I can’t remember the specifics of the things that occurred.
I remember one thing very clearly. I told you I was a girl. I told you I was a girl because I wanted to give birth to and nurture my own children, not play sports and compete with other boys. You insisted that I was a boy. Obviously, I am physically male, but that doesn’t change what is in my head. When I refused to give up this fantasy after who knows how long, you told me about your abuse at the hands of the old man in the boarding house. Told me about being locked in the closet by your step-mother until you stopped lying about the man and agreed to go keep him quiet.
After you had abused me with your stories of abuse, scared me into agreeing to try to be a good boy for you, you made me promise never to tell anyone these secrets of yours and mine. I kept your secret for so long that I forgot that it was your secret and it became my secret. My secret tied up with my conviction that I was not a boy but a girl, in spite of what my sex said I was.
I remember when I told your other children, my half-siblings, about the evil person your stepmother was. Told them that your mom locked you in the closet. You looked so betrayed then. Betrayed, like it was my fault I knew this fact and could tell them about it. I had repressed the other parts, the traumatic parts that you also repressed, repressed so well no one could see the scars on you, but I remembered the closet story itself.
Your reactions seemed so odd at the time. I remember this clearly. You laughed far too loudly. I should have known then, should have remembered then, remembered the full story and that I wasn’t supposed to tell anyone any part of it. I remember just as clearly you saying that “I should never have told you these things.”
That’s probably the truest thing you’d ever said to me in my life. You should never have told me these things. You shouldn’t have traumatized me with your trauma.
You shouldn’t have told my sister about your childhood trauma just to motivate her into letting you die. You told her the story that had haunted my dreams for fifty years just to get her to stop trying to make you take chemotherapy. You abused her as you abused me with your trauma.
At least she was an adult, Mom.
That’s two wrongs committed using the same trauma that you should have gotten help with long, long ago. Long before you ever thought about having children. Now I’m stuck here writing this letter because you aren’t here for me to say these things to anymore. You had cancer Mom. It’s not a sin to have it and to treat it.
You and dad forbade me to play with baby dolls anymore and you punished me for putting on feminine clothes, playing with your makeup and jewelry, playing dress-up. To this day I find pretense unpleasant because of the beatings that you and he gave me for these attempts to be more feminine.
I remember the glowing stories you told about your brother and the antics he would get up to on Halloween. The fakery that terrified bystanders that was so amusing to him. To your father, who was also a cut-up and a prankster. How was their fakery different than my desire to pretend to be a woman? What was so bad about the things that I wanted when compared to the things that they did? Why couldn’t I be a princess or a ballerina for Halloween? Why was that so bad?
Is it any wonder that I hid myself away in books, that I only found myself in them, and in games, where I could at least pretend to be something other than the loathsome man you told me I had to be? That’s what it all amounted to in my young brain. Let me spell it out:
- I was going to become a man whether I liked it or not.
- Men were despicable rapists who abused children.
That is what it meant, this secret of yours that you forced on me. You have no idea what a weight it is off my mind now, to know that the secret that I’ve carried all my life was your secret, not mine.
I’ve never made a big deal out of not wanting to conform to standards of manliness. (did you know pink used to be the color for boys? It was) I threw away all the fake standards that were forced on me. I stayed home and raised my children even though my working peers told me I was nuts to do it.
You told me I was nuts to want to stay home, even though you respected the fact I was willing to do it. I’ve done endless battle trying to break the molds that society wanted to force people into, so my not being a man isn’t a problem for me. It was a problem for you.
Had I not been a short, nearsighted asthmatic with dysgraphia I might have at least succeeded in my early attempts to conform, to pretend to be a man, but that wouldn’t have done me any favors in the long run. I would have been even more in the closet than I am now, hopelessly trying to connect the dots between lost desires and current successes, if I had had any success following that course.
Denied those successes I’m simply the person that I am now, whatever I can make that mean for myself with the time I have left. I can embroider on what I’ve defined for myself now. Do it better because I know things about myself and you that I should have known, that you should have known, for decades now. I will redefine what I hear in my head when I hear RAnthony, the name I’ve chosen for myself.
I know now why you clung to your mother’s religion, the religion that told you it was a sin to have cancer. It was the only rock you had left. After your Mom died. After Kenny left you for the Army. After I was born and was such a disappointment. After your marriages fell apart three times and you had to work so hard just to feed your children. The beliefs behind Christian Science were the only thing you could rely on then because you were never willing to go see the counselors you sent me to.
Duty was all you had left. Duty to your children. Duty to your beliefs. You got into medical practice by becoming a nurse. That was your way of subverting the system, of putting yourself in a place to save people from doctors when you couldn’t save your own mother from them. You clung to your mysticism and practiced kinesiology and naturopathy while wearing the mantle of a health professional, all along convinced that you knew the true path. The way to health.
It must have been a crushing blow to be told that you had cancer. It was proof that you didn’t know what you thought you knew all your life. That the mechanics of life were beyond the control of right thinking and right living, the way that you defined it. Now it all makes sense to me.
“I know I have a parasite, I can feel it moving!” was one of the last things you ever said to me. Listen Mother; cancer was that parasite and it killed you because that was what you wanted it to do. You would rather be dead than admit that you had been wrong all your life.
Well, you got what you wanted. You made us kill you with the hospice procedures that you knew and practiced yourself. You consented to the hospice treatment so what we did wasn’t murder; but that fact does not make me feel like any less of a murderer than if you had admitted that you wanted to die, to my face, like I DEMANDED that you do before I would help you get your wish. Your wish to die that you never admitted to, to the detriment of everyone around you who loved you.
No, Hospice is not murder. Hospice is being humane, easing the passing of those who are going to die soon anyway. People who have a terminal diagnosis like stage three cancer and renal failure. People like you. Those people will die without treatment and it is just basic decency to allow them to pass quietly in their sleep instead of being tormented with the demands of thirst and hunger when neither of those things will keep the person alive much longer anyway. I tell myself these bald facts every time that I remember that last night with you. It doesn’t change how I feel, though.
I helped with the hospice care, just like you knew that I would. I did my duty, just the way you taught me to. I sat by your side for two weeks following the directions of the hospice nurse to the letter. I was faithful to the end; but I’m telling you now, that was the end. My duty to you ended that night. It ended with the last breath that you took, that morning in my arms. I’m done now. Time to live my own life, without you.

Featured image: Barbara Ann (Barbi) Zonge, age 3
