Repulsors

Daily Beef Entertainment Skepticism Technical

This subject has come up on the Skeptic’s Guide to the Universe a number of times. Steve will harp on about the need for Iron Man to have fuel tanks:

Where does he keep the fuel in that suit?

I get it. They’re skeptics, obsessed with debunking mythology and magical thinking. They are also massive consumers of science fiction content, and the proof of this is that they have another channel for this subject (Alpha Quadrant 6) a channel in which they talk gushingly about a lot of other science fiction that they are fans of.

The fact of the matter is that Iron Man doesn’t need fuel for his weapons/propulsion units. Those are (as I’m sure the skeptics know) repulsors that are energy driven. Repulsors are essentially the exact same thing as a reactionless drive, which is a fantasy device that explains away the need for fuel. This goes way back in the comic books and it’s definitely not some big mystery that needs to be explained. Tony Stark invents them as part of creating the suit for the first time. It’s right there in the comic series if you go back and look.

Th being a thing in Iron Mans lore does fly in the face of science like nearly every power that Marvel’s mutants and any other superhero have. It ain’t the way reality works; but if you are going to try and enjoy the fantasy you have to just try and go along with the narrative.

Which is my point here. If you aren’t going to talk about magic mushroom drives being a thing on Discovery, stop watching the show because Paramount is definitely doing too many mushrooms. This is a much bigger problem than Iron Man not having tanks to store his reaction mass in. That would be the least of your problems if you are watching or reading any other kind of soft science fiction.

A little critical analysis of what you spend your time on might be in order rather than trying to make other people’s fantasies conform to the real world in some measurable way. In looking over the feed for Alpha Quadrant 6 I see that they haven’t produced any new content for it in quite some time, so maybe they’ve acknowledged this to themselves if not to the listeners of their other podcasts.

In any case, please stop bitching about Iron Man not having tanks in his suit. There isn’t room for that any more than there is room for house keys in the spandex that most of the superheroes wear. It’s fantasy. Stop worrying about it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top