Star Trek: Afterlife

Fandom Film Television

One of my earliest memories is of a black lady in a red miniskirt, a beehive hairdo and what I would now think of as a Bluetooth headset hanging out of her ear. There were flashing lights on the communication boards behind her and she utters the line “Hailing frequencies open, sir” then the picture cuts to a man in a mustard colored shirt in a chair. I couldn’t explain the show to my mother, I also remember that. I was mad when they took it off the air and I tried to describe to my Mom about the alien with the pointy ears and the phasers and the bright red surfaces all over the bridge. The salt monster that had terrified me a few years previously. She didn’t remember the show although I got a hug for the disappointment of not seeing my show that day.

When I came home from middle school one day in 1977 and found my show in reruns for the first time, I was ecstatic. I remember dragging Mom into the den to watch with me. “It was Star Trek. See? I told you Mom.” I rewatched all but two episodes in reruns over the subsequent years as I watched the show after school with my brothers and sisters who would have rather been watching anything else.

I took my first date to watch Star Trek: The Motion Picture on its premiere weekend. I was stoked. I don’t think my date was because I never saw her again after that. The Motionless Picture (as the fans dubbed it almost immediately) wasn’t like original Star Trek but it was nice to see the characters again. I had no idea that what I saw onscreen was originally intended to be a second television series pilot that they punted into a movie instead. That knowledge came later with my introduction to the Wife and fandom at large, but I could feel Gene Roddenberry’s influence in every bit of it. The subtle trekkiness of it. It was there under the different costumes and muted bridge colors.

I went to see Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan by myself the first time. I thought it was so good that I dragged my friends with me to watch it a second time. I don’t think most people today would understand what that meant to me back then in 1982. I had never spent money to watch the same movie twice before, much less 27 times to see Star Wars over and over again like some of my friends in fandom had done. This was an action film that was also a Star Trek movie, and I loved it. It wasn’t quite as distinctively Trek as the first movie. Kirk’s son denounces Starfleet as just another military organization bent on perverting their science, er, their ridiculous life-generating magic bomb into a weapon.

If you ignored the embarrassing treknobabble about the science it was a great movie that expanded on one of the best episodes of the series. If you had been a fan of the show for as long as I had been by that point, the fast and loose nature of some of the science in the show was just one of the things that you learned to suspend disbelief about. After all, you can’t enjoy the show if you are busy picking it apart while you are watching it. Spock’s death scene in Wrath of Khan still makes me cry decades later even knowing they bring him back in the next movie.

On The Media – I’m Brooke Gladstone and I Am a Trekker – August 11, 2021

I can say what Brook won’t in that episode of On The Media. I was a Trekkie, not a Trekker. I used to say that it was a distinction without a difference Trekker vs. Trekkie but I’m not so certain this is true any more. The Wife and I fell in love over a box of Star Trek (and Superman!) comic books. She revealed that she was much more of a fan than I had ever been, having ordered from Roddenberry’s groundbreaking marketing arm Lincoln Enterprises pretty much as soon as it was announced. She walked around with a golden Enterprise necklace the way some people walk around with a golden cross or a St. Christopher’s medal. She had also been on the official Star Trek mailing list and attended several conventions before we even met. She could win trivia contests about the show and I could not.

I turned in my fandom pin when I met the Wife and the cadre of fans that she brought me into contact with. For example, I can’t be a true fan (the sensitive kind that wants to be called a Trekker and not a Trekkie) because I didn’t know these three characters were all played by the same actress, Diana Muldaur. I have no idea why I’d never made this connection; or why, if one of the fans I lead as Captain of a local Star Trek club alerted me to this fact, I still don’t remember that they were all the same person to this day. Trivia is a thing that I’ve never found important enough to remember, thereby earning its label of trivia. The fact of this doesn’t keep me from losing when we play trivial pursuit.

The Wife and I went to see Star Trek III: The Search For Spock together as well as every Star Trek movie after that one. Every Star Trek movie until they stopped being Star Trek movies in 2009.

When Star Trek: The Next Generation started airing I began to notice the change in the Star Trek universe’s underlying philosophy. In movies it is relatively easy to plot a simple story and hand-wave your way through the deeper questions of social order and the fabric of society. In a television series that has to produce (at the time) more than twenty one-hour shows each and every year, the show has to rely on the actors who appear in the show to invest more of themselves into the characters than is asked of the average movie actor. This is also true of the writers who have to produce the scripts that create the bones of the social interactions that the actors lend themselves to. It is a herculean task to create a television show even now with computer effects, short seasons and padded budgets. Back in the day when Star Trek aired, 1967-69, it was nearly an impossibility and had never been done that way for television until Desi Arnaz made it the television standard.

2021/04/retconned-to-death

Speculative fiction like Star Trek is meaningless unless it reflects facets of the world outside, and the world outside the view of the television cameras had changed quite a bit since the original series had been on the air. The Vietnam war had been raging outside the camera’s range back in 1960’s America and the Cold War had dominated the lives of everyone living on the planet since the 1950’s. We were all going to die in the the thermonuclear fallout from World War III, that was the world that Star Trek was born into.

Star Trek with it’s portrayal of a bright future where we could all get along was a breath of fresh air in that climate. When The Next Generation (TNG) hit television screens we were living in that future. The predicted nuclear wars hadn’t occurred and the future was different than we expected. It wasn’t bright and it wasn’t going to get bright any time soon. The destruction of world civilization had been delayed a few generations but it was still a possibility that we all worried about, even if it wasn’t nuclear holocaust and the USSR that dominated our nightmares anymore. TNG had to be different from the future that Gene had created for his original Star Trek thirty years previously.

TNG was more militaristic for starters. The militarism was still subtle, but it was there all the same. The science was weaker, too. All the versions of Star Trek have made science shortcuts for reasons of storytelling and cost cutting. You can’t tell a story about characters if those characters don’t survive the journey from one planet to the next, so you introduce warp drive to shorten transit times into something more like a sea voyage. You introduce transporter tech so that you don’t have to film separate scenes of shuttles taking off and landing on each planet you visit (just don’t think about dying each time you get into the transporter only to be reborn on the planet surface) we can print food now with fabricators so the replicators in Star Trek aren’t even that much of a stretch anymore. Your flip phone that you used to love did the flip thing that it did precisely because Kirk did the flip thing with his communicator in 1967.

There were goofy stories based on the goofy tech introduced to tell the stories in the first place, but TNG made whole seasons of goofy stories about goofy science and goofy tech a thing. Which was fine, if it wasn’t a little much in the way of content to consume.

Then there was Deep Space Nine. I liked DS9 but I liked Babylon 5 more, which was interesting because the theme of a remote station on the edge of known space was a central story point that seemed to be shared between the two of them? Well, I’m sure J. Michael Straczynski doesn’t care much anymore. He got to make his show with the money that wasn’t mentioned in the settlement between him and Paramount. DS9 was better than TNG just as Babylon 5 was better than DS9. They were more real and dealt with more real subjects and didn’t seem to have so many goofy tech stories in their repertoire.

After that was Voyager and Paramount’s first betrayal of Star Trek fandom. I wanted to watch the show but wasn’t allowed to because Paramount wanted the fans to carry their UPN broadcast networks on their backs. I wasn’t having any of that. Then there was Enterprise and Nemesis:

2006/11/how-about-an-example-of-a-bad-show

…and I realized that there was speculative fiction that I liked and speculative fiction that I distinctly didn’t like. I probably should have thanked Paramount for the revelation that I could hate some kinds of fiction, even fiction offered under the guise of being Star Trek. I would thank them, but they weren’t done ruining Star Trek for me yet:

2009/05/star-trek-1966-2009-r-i-p

The Abramanations were definitively NOT Star Trek. This assessment goes above and beyond not liking story points or characterizations in these movies. I mean; red matter was an impossibility, a stupid impossibility just as Khan’s magic healing blood was a stupid impossibility in Into Darkness (Another aptly named film) There were stupid action sequences and stupid humor sequences. Too much stupid to ever be able to talk to other fans about the stupid without my having an aneurism suppressing the desire to throttle said fans as they praised the stupid; and so, I declared Star Trek dead because of those two films. But it wasn’t up to me, was it? I’m not the rights holder, Paramount is; and Paramount keeps making new content under the banner of the Star Trek name.

Some of this later content seems inoffensive enough to this jaded Trekkie to actually be entertaining. So, needing some entertainment, I decided to watch some of it. Following are my thoughts on the bits that I have watched.

Picard

I started this article you are reading in 2022 because I had signed up for Paramount+ to specifically watch Picard and Woman in Motion. Here’s the article for the documentary about Nichelle:

2022/08/woman-in-motion

(We miss you already!)

I like the actors in Picard and I like the characters that they are reprising in the series; so I watched it, and it was better than I had expected it would be. It was so much better than I expected that I talked the Wife into watching it. She also liked it.

Could it have been better? Come on, whatever is is you are talking about could always be better. It was good for what it was, a tribute to the shows and characters that have come and gone in Star Trek history. Was it really Star Trek? I think you could say it was. TNG Star Trek if not classic Star Trek.

(Et in Arcadia Ego one and two. The Eclogues. I know why this parenthetical is here. Do you?)

I would have preferred it if they had ended the show with season one; but they made season two, and after finishing watching season two I had to say that it was also worth watching. Season three when it arrived was also good. How good? Well, it had a feel good ending which I could have done without; but beyond that minor quibble the entire season was a nice send-off for these much-beloved characters.

I would have done the story arc distinctly differently as a three-season arc than I would have as a single-season arc (An observation that I’m sure Sir Patrick Stewart would agree with) but I’ll take what I was given and say thank you. I’m not in charge and so I don’t get to make those kinds of decisions. Technically nobody has that level of control for a group effort that has that many strong egos to contend with.

The best part of Picard? The story arc for Seven of Nine finally reaches its culmination, the character that somehow grew on me in spite of what Paramount did to make me stop watching Voyager and Star Trek in the first place. Jeri Ryan is amazing reprising her role as Seven; and in season three she gets to the place she deserves to be in at that point in the character’s life, in charge of a starship.

I especially loved that line from first season Picard, when Elnor asks her if she’s going to assimilate him now. She proves that she was stronger than her fears. “Annika still has work to do.” It’s inspiring for this formerly closeted genderqueer whose inner woman hid in terror for fifty years.

threads

Discovery

However, Paramount+ kept showing me ads for Discovery and Strange New Worlds at the beginning of each episode of Picard. After I had watched all of Picard that there was to watch (The end of season one. Then the end of season two. Then three. Three years transpired between the beginning and end of these later sections of the article. Four if you count the second season of Strange New Worlds. -ed.) I decided I might try to watch Strange New Worlds. It was, after all, about Captain Pike, Kirk’s predecessor as captain of the Enterprise. Unlike the show Enterprise, which was not part of Star Trek canon in even the slightest sense (there was no warp capable ship called Enterprise before the one mentioned in the original Star Trek) Captain Pike had been established as being part of the Star Trek universe from the very beginning. Even before the beginning of the show itself since it represents the premiere of the show that could have been but wasn’t (See The Cage for those who aren’t Trek nerds) so I started the first episode and hit my first snag.

Pike had appeared in Discovery before Paramount had decided to create Strange New Worlds. Was I willing to try to suspend disbelief for two seasons of a show that I already knew was bad? I mean, I had panned Discovery claiming worlds with the Federation flag in advertising a few years ago, could I watch two seasons of the show knowing that they were probably going to do horrible things to my beloved Star Trek? I’d survived the Abramanations, I thought to myself. Surely I can survive two seasons of Discovery.

Oh, how wrong I was. It started with the first episode of the series. The ship, Discovery, travels on magic mushrooms. No, I am not kidding when I say that. They are mushrooms and they are magical; ergo magic mushrooms. Magic mushrooms, spore trails through sub-space, or whatever treknobabble you want to make up. Same fucking difference. Might as well chew a fungus and go their in your dreams. Your dreams will be better, I can promise you this.

I made it to the end of season one, I don’t know how. The story arc itself might have been interesting enough to hold my attention if only EVERY SINGLE THING about the show didn’t pop me right out of the ability to suspend disbelief with an audible WTF!?! Giant tardigrades. Microscopic critters that could eat you whole. (the amoeba episode of TOS was also dumb) The entire saucer section of the ship, when they start up the magic mushroom drive, spins. There are people on those parts of the ship, and it spins like a gyroscope. Even in the Star Trek universe there ain’t inertial dampeners strong enough to negate those forces, so how does the crew survive? They never even address it.

When Pike popped onto the ship at the end of season one, I knew that I could not watch season two and put him in with the crew of Discovery and their magic mushroom driven atrocity. So I stopped watching and haven’t been back.

I wouldn’t even be writing about this now if William Shatner hadn’t called out the current crop of Trek wannabes for not being Star Trek. That got their attention. “William Shatner says that our Trek isn’t Trek enough? Where does he come off saying that?” They offer up Gene Roddenberry’s panning of Star Trek V, as if that is proof that Bill Shatner doesn’t know what he is talking about.

On June 3, 1987, Roddenberry wrote a memo to Shatner expressing his distaste for the story. “Bill, as you undoubtedly know, I expressed to Harve Bennett at lunch last Monday my deep disappointment in the proposed Star Trek V film story,” Roddenberry wrote. “I simply cannot support a story which has our intelligent and insightful crew mesmerized by a 23rd Century religious charlatan.”

Roddenberry went on to point out that Shatner had previously agreed to recognize using religion in the script, which Roddenberry felt was unsuitable for the post-religious world he had created in TOS. The memo continued: “I had also thought that we had a clear understanding, man to man, that I would be consulted before any story went to screenplay.”

Roddenberry was so upset by the narrative Shatner had proposed that he also wrote similar letters to Bennett (who ignored him and appears in a cameo role in the final cut), his lawyer Leonard Maizlish, and head of the studio Frank Mancuso. In fact, Roddenberry was so incensed by the narrative direction Shatner had chosen, that he also wrote to sci-fi literary legends Isaac Asimov and Arthur C. Clarke to enlist their help in discouraging the studio from making the film. Both authors sent letters agreeing with Roddenberry’s position: Star Trek V “wasn’t Star Trek.”

movieweb.com

You know what? Gene was right. Spock had no brother, ergo Star Trek V couldn’t have been canon and probably shouldn’t be considered Star Trek. So what? Citing authority about Shatner’s work has no bearing on what that same authority might say about your work, your favorite new shiny thing that you love so much.

Bill happens to be right, at least when it comes to Discovery. That show is a joke; and the actors involved, while very talented and dedicated, should have insisted on there being science advisors on the show during filming and during the writing process. Paramount should have cared enough about their property, Star Trek, so as to not dilute it with the crap that they’ve made under the Star Trek mantle since Gene’s death. I don’t care what Gene’s son thinks about the shows, either. Gene Roddenberry, the great bird of the galaxy himself, laid it all out in the Star Trek bible:

I’m a little unclear about technological devices of the future. Can we invent anything which sounds reasonable?

Simply think of something logical, with some kind of science or projected-science basis. Generally best are projections of things we have now or which science is beginning to build now. For example, in the pilot we had a hospital bed
which continually monitored all the key bodily functions, and in fact some advanced hospitals today are already doing part of this and working on further improvements.

Star Trek Writers Guide

Magic mushroom drives do not meet that standard. Discovery is not Star Trek just as the 2009 movie and Into Darkness are not Star Trek because the crap they came up with to explain their plot points doesn’t make fucking sense. I rest my case.

In the meantime I will say this. I was a Trekkie. I might still call myself a Trekkie if that means I can isolate myself from the Trekkers that think that magic mushroom drives, magic healing blood and red matter are things they want to be mystified by; otherwise Star Trek is even deader in my estimation than it was in 2009. Bill Shatner, you are right once again.

Strange New Worlds

After all of the above had transpired, I finally sat down and watched the first and second season of Strange New Worlds. I wish I could have come to the show with fresh eyes and not the same eyes that have watched the journey of Gene Roddenberry’s creation from the time that it first appeared on television screens way back when. Had watched all the things that I detailed above come to pass. If I hadn’t seen all of those things and been offended by a good number of them I might be able to give this show the praise it probably deserves to receive.

Unfortunately I’m not that person, I’m just the jaded old fan that I am and hopefully always will be. So here goes my review of the first season.

The first episode annoyed the fuck out of me. Transporting something into Spock’s eyeball? Great way to make his eye explode. Stupid tech solutions to stupid story plot points. I’ve seen these kinds of imaginary moments of crisis way, way too many times now on too many shows that should have had the collective intelligence to known better than to try that shit.

The second episode made me want to love the show. It perfectly encapsulated the moral quandary of the best of speculative fiction. I was truly impressed with the episode right up to the point where Captain Pike has to go through his quandary about being shown how he dies when he was part of the magic mushroom joyride that is all of Discovery.

Every episode of Strange New Worlds does some stupid thing or other that sets my teeth on edge. Dr. M’Benga storing his daughter in the transporter buffer, a sub-plot that leads up to the episode where she becomes a… god? Who knows what she is now, at least she’s not a dead person stored in a transporter buffer. Then there is the season finale that once again calls back to the magic mushroom joyride and makes it quite clear that this time crystal bullshit from Discovery is going to be a theme across the entire series. The singing episode of season two? Okay, yeah, funny; but, WTF? Where’s the science? Every single episode does something like this that makes me ask “why am I watching this?”

I can’t. I just can’t. From a storytelling perspective I can appreciate the value of illustrating why Captain Kirk was the right man for the job illustrated in Balance of Terror versus the bungled job that Captain Pike does in A Quality of Mercy. (The Twilight Zone episode of the same name is better. -ed.) From a philosophical perspective I don’t think that the writers or the producers of the current show understand what it was that Gene was trying for with his show about a future human society. Nor do I think they are interested in what Gene intended for the show beyond the fact that the fans demand more of it and the rights holders for it want to make money from that demand. I see no need to put money in their hands given my disturbed thoughts on the subject.

Paramount Boycott

Any chance that I might have given the future of the Star Trek franchise went out the window when the Ellison family bought Paramount. The history between Skydance (formed by Ellison) and Paramount is long; and Skydance has done some interesting projects in the past.

However, the Ellison family supports Little Donnie, the OHM, Caudito Trump. This makes them Nazis like Little Donnie and his henchmen, by extension. I don’t promote or support people who think people like me shouldn’t exist.

We cannot change the past. If we could change the past, we would make sure these Nazi bastards never started companies. Never were rewarded extravagantly for work that any one of us could have done.

However, history happened the way it happened and this is the world we live in. This world we live in is not a Star Trek world. It’s not even a world in which equality and humanity are things that are valued. We can’t afford dreams that pretend we are all equal promoted in content made by con artists like Ellison and Trump. I’d much rather turn off, tune out, drop in than pretend that watching Star Trek is going to make the world a better place.

So I’m boycotting everything that I can that is related to Trump or Ellison or anyone else that supports Trump’s administration. If you actually believe in the philosophy behind what Star Trek was, you’ll be right there with me.

I know that the moderators on the r/StarTrek SubReddit aren’t with me. They deleted the comment that most of this section of the post came from. They told me the comments were “not constructive.” Apparently it’s not constructive to point out that consuming (and talking about) the media created by Nazis puts money in their pockets and makes you a Nazi sympathizer.

Oh, “But this is Star Trek,” I hear you saying. “How can Star Trek be fascistic?” I pointed this out years ago and I have outlined the path the show has taken to get where it is now in the article above. Series television mirrors the world on the other side of the screen. It can’t help but do that if it wants to connect with and entertain the audience it was made for. It’s only a matter of time before Ellison has the Federation excluding some group or other because they are a threat. So much for IDIC (and if I have to explain what IDIC means to you then you aren’t a Trekkie anyway) So much for Gene’s dream.

The moderators and Redditors on r/StarTrek have a tough road ahead of them. The subreddit is dedicated to the product of a currently fascist organization. They are going to continuously get people like me objecting to their support for fascism through the consumption of Paramount’s media products. It’s going to be a full-time job pulling down all those posts. Maybe they should quit while they’re ahead and admit that supporting fascists is a bad thing.

I will let my final sentence from the 2009 article stand in for anything else I might write on the subject of Star Trek from this point forward. “Rest in peace, Star Trek. Say hi to Gene for me.“

Postscript

I have decided I’m finally done adding stuff to this article. If I ever decide to talk about Star Trek again, it will be in another article on the blog. Here’s hoping for a brighter future where that might be possible; both from a writing perspective and an entertainment perspective.

In the meantime, I have further thoughts on the subject of the shows discussed here and the fans of those shows who can’t seem to stop themselves from arguing with me.

On one of the Star Trek Reddit threads I’ve been lurking on it was revealed that people apparently hate the disco Klingons in Subspace Rhapsody. This fact floated to the surface during a discussion of Enterprise season 4 episodes Affliction and Divergence, a storyline that was a tie-in to a single comment uttered by Whorf in the DS9 episode Trials and Tribble-ations. However, the Strange New Worlds – Subspace Rhapsody disco Klingons were the best part of that episode. I couldn’t care less that they had brow-ridges. Continuity concerns are a pretty low bar for me these days.

There was also a side discussion of Klingon Ash, a character from Discovery that fooled no one and only managed to prove the ham-handedness of the writers for those episodes that involved him. This is hardly a startling revelation anymore than it would be a startling revelation for me to say that Discovery isn’t worth the time it takes to watch it. Not at this point in this article. Yes, I know there are divergent personalities represented on the ship. It’s going to take more than a gay couple to keep me watching anything on television including Star Trek.

I honestly didn’t think Paramount could do worse than Enterprise, Nemesis and the Abramanations. There clearly was a “hold my beer” moment in the Discovery writer’s room. They needed to prove they could suck harder than those previous entries into the hated category of Star Trek experiences of the past.

Let’s briefly touch on subspace as referenced in Star Trek. The need for instantaneous communication for teleplay reasons introduced an unsupportable non-scientific notion into Star Trek from the very beginning. I would have preferred they use the term ansible as their literary forefathers did to refer to instant long-distance communication. At least, then, there would have been a literary basis for the treknobabble even if there was no more science in that technology than in the subspace that they so frequently reference in the show. Subspace has nothing to do with the warp drive, which warps real space. Not even Wikipedia can figure that basic understanding out.

The problem is that these Trekkers (just going to go ahead and reserve Trekkie for people like me) are dumber than Gene expected them to be. They don’t understand that subspace isn’t warp drive, don’t understand the difference between instantaneous communication and instantaneous travel. All of these things might possibly exist, we simply don’t know enough about the working of the universe to say for certain, yet.

One of the solutions to the Fermi paradox is that we aren’t looking in the right communications channels to find all that interstellar chatter that should be out there. Some equivalent to subspace might be the thing we discover that makes this possible. The other one is that civilizations die out before they ever achieve interstellar travel and that’s why it’s so fucking quiet out there. We seem to be closing in on the second option these days, much as I would rather that we stumbled across the first one instead.

These Trekkers, though, they’re happy to throw around links to ex-astris-scientia.org and tout them like they are a real scientific journal. They throw around concepts like Brane as if they understand what it means and they blend all the far-out theories that have spawned on the internet over the last twenty years as evidence that their favorite story’s bullshit is totally believable.

There aren’t mushrooms in space; therein lies the first problem. You can cite many-worlds theory all you like. You can point to fluidic space from Voyager (400ish years into the future from the timeframe presented in the first seasons of Discovery. Why was Janeway surprised when they discovered fluid space? Clearly they’d already proven the many-world theory all those years previously…? The discovery of fluid space should have been old hat by then. A virtual yawner.) and a dozen other stories in the Trek universe, it makes no difference. All of these other stories are set in the imaginary future for this show. These primitive space explorers are using technology that is unthought of to people in their distant future, but we’re supposed to think of the mushroom drive like it’s as common and reliable as a toaster oven on this ship.

So this cross-dimensional mushroom drive existed before the first Enterprise did? Invaders from an alternate universe showed up and pretended to be Federation officers? This would have been the kind of cautionary information that Kirk would have been advised of since Starfleet knew about the mushroom drive. Why didn’t Kirk know about inter-dimensional transporters?

“There’s other universes out there and be careful using transporters in these particular situations so that you don’t get sent to one of those universes.” You’d think they would have at least mentioned that to Kirk. Everyone after Kirk knew all about it.

…But no. That information wasn’t given to him because IT ISN’T FUCKING CANON. That’s why. Not fucking canon, not fucking Star Trek. That is the second problem.

The idea of the mushroom drive clearly grew out of the fresh scientific understanding of the mycelium network that ties forests together, theoretically allowing transport of chemical information between trees that are vast distances apart. The science is very cool, the fantasy that grew out of it less so.

Make no mistake, it’s fantasy, not science fiction. The truth is that mushroom drive technology defies all of our understanding of physics. That makes it fantasy. For me, it’s a subtle but important distinction. I seek out science fiction and take a pass on most fantasy. I’m sure I’m not the only one out here that feels this way.

If you’re okay with fantasy it’s not a problem. I don’t engage in kink shaming. Do whatever you like, just don’t expect me to take an interest in it. What I get annoyed about is when people who like Discovery insist “Well, transporters are fantasy elements, too” or point to some other facet of the universe that’s blatantly not based in science.

I don’t need many worlds theory explained to me. (I have, after all, watched and read a lot about the subject before this) I don’t need hand-waving explanations using esoteric terminology (branes) that are supposed to cover for the fact that none of this shit is possible. It’s not possible; not at the time frame it’s set at in the Star Trek universe and not in our universe where the laws of our universe apply.

The fact that you have to dig that deep proves that the concept of the drive itself doesn’t work for story-telling purposes.This is all above and beyond the silly shit like the saucer section pointlessly spinning like a gyroscope when the magic mushroom drive is engaged. The people inside that section of the ship are paste on the walls. There’s no inertial dampeners sufficient for that kind of motion, especially not in the years prior to the Enterprise launching on it’s maiden voyage.

Discovery is bad Trek and bad SF and it seriously needed a science advisor with some balls to be pointing out that what the showrunner wanted to do with the show was going to alienate most of the people watching. Star Trek as it was conceived of by Gene way back when took too many liberties in the name of storytelling. The people generating the current content feel like they have to take even greater liberties in order to hold audience attention when, in fact, the opposite might actually be true.

reddit

There is a reason that Larry Niven is one of my favorite authors. I like hard science fiction.

Let’s take the Trekker’s bait. Go ahead, take the transporters out, I don’t care. They were put in as an effects cost-saving measure in the first place and have been used as a McGuffin in a thousand plots since then. A far too overused storyline in the Star Trek universe. Come up with an excuse for why they have to stop using them and write them out.

Something along the lines of; being tired of having to deal with the occasional duplicated human, the continued user suspicions about them, Federation scientists stumble upon some previously unknown long-term danger (say, people from the Empire using them to interdimensionally transport and are masquerading as Federation officials and plotting to bring down the Federation. Just having a guess here) and because of this new knowledge they decide transporter technology is too much of a liability to keep using.

While we’re at it, we’ll start writing in reasons why instantaneous communication across galactic distances can’t happen. (A subject that was oddly barely touched on in Voyager even though the ship was across the galaxy and outside the established magical subspace network. They did mention that they couldn’t talk to the Federation except when the right magical conditions happened, but that was about the extent of the treknobabble) In other words, it’s entirely possible that modern science fiction should be made more believable, not more unbelievable.

The same goes for pretty much every other thing that doesn’t meet with current scientific understanding. Let it go. That will make the show and the universe it’s set in more believable, which is a good thing.

The people who love Discovery don’t like these answers any more than they don’t like the fact that I hate their favorite show. Hate their show in spite of the characters and the hard work of everyone involved in it. There’s no accounting for taste.

There is an excuse for the inclusion of the transporters and other fantasy-based mechanisms like the holodecks and instantaneous communication. That excuse is; entertainment value. Audience appeal. The aforementioned cost-savings. There is no excuse for the mushroom drive. There is no excuse for the saucer section spinning the way it does. That is the third problem with the magic mushroom drive. It distracts from the storytelling instead of facilitating it.

I like Strange New Worlds. I think it’s pretty good. I didn’t hate Enterprise. I thought it was kind of weird. Lower Decks, I thought, was entertaining and fun. All the others, they can go.

Andy Wier

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top