It is primary season again here in Texas and across most of the United States. I will be voting in the Democratic primary this year. I voted in the Republican primary in several past elections. The reason why I as a card-carrying libertarian voted in the primary elections for Republicans rather than participate in the convention for Libertarian party candidates is because of the weirdness that is the Texas primaries and Texas politics in general.
Primaries themselves are weird, being originally just how the major parties selected candidates that will represent the parties on the general election ballot. They were considered private affairs and still are private affairs in most countries that practice liberal democracy as a method for crafting governmental leadership. Primaries were only for party members when they were first organized. At some point the parties started expecting the government to help foot the bill for carrying out these primary elections; and over time the various state governments have imposed rules about how primaries are to be run as a response to these attempts to externalize the costs of keeping the government by and for you, the participating party member. Since they were no longer private affairs they were became publicly regulated elections similar to the general election.
However, the nature of how these selection processes evolved means that there are different rules in all fifty states. Texas and its myriad counties and cities tried to hide elections from the public, making voting a confusing and arcane process of knowing where and when to vote in what election for what portion of the complex governmental system that evolved in Texas. There were different voting days for different levels of government in many counties and cities, and some of those minor election days still persist along with the common belief that not all residents/citizens should be provided with access to the ballot and the election systems.
In Texas the two major parties run their primaries on public ballots with government assistance. The minor parties have so far opted for convention primaries because they are cheaper and don’t require arguing with the state
Texas calls what it does for the primary election an open primary. There really isn’t an animal called open primary. What they mean by open is that it there is no membership in a party required to vote in that party’s primary, which would be a closed primary.
No matter what you call it, the primary system is still broken. It’s broken everywhere but it is especially broken in Texas. It’s broken because it doesn’t do the thing that a primary should do; cull the number of names on the general ballot down to two names and only two names. This step is important because of math.
Game Theory has long established that plurality voting, winner takes all general elections between more than two candidates, yields the least favorable electoral outcomes. Game Theory essentially predicted that we would have the least favorite candidates in competition with each other at the end of the 2016 election. Does anyone doubt that Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump did not together represent the least favorite candidates in competition?
There are a lot of ways to game a race with more than two names on a ballot and the general election is too important to be left to gamesmanship. When it comes to primary voting there should be only one primary with all the candidates running for that office on that ballot. You can try to stop the gamesmanship on that ballot with ranked choice voting or a series of ballots eliminating the lowest vote tallies or whatever; but in the end there should only be two names advanced to the general election so as to make it a clear up or down vote on the two candidates being offered for whatever office.
We have absolutely failed to alter the primary system in the US as I described in the above article; and it’s even gotten worse in Texas as the unhinged who adhere to Trumpismo attempt to force him back into the Presidency, contrary to the opinions of a clear majority of Americans. That are actively moving backwards in time socially in an attempt to create the theocracy that these nutty evangelicals have been trying to create ever since they put Reagan in office.
This can’t be allowed to continue. We have to get out and take back our country and our state from these religious zealots. We have to do the work that Indivisible has been agitating for for almost a decade now, starting with not voting in the Republican primary in the hopes of moderating the crazy. Let the wingnuts win in the Republican primary but make sure that the best Democrats win in the Democratic primary, because that’s the person we want to win at this point. Not the lessor of two evils, but someone who will listen to us and do the right thing for the country and the state, not the thing that gets them reelected in the next election. That’s our immediate requirement in order to survive this election season. Nothing else will suffice.
Texas Primary Insanity
The language on the party ballots in Texas primaries is under the control of the state party organizations. That is why the language is different on the two primary ballots. This is also one of the serious problems with the way Texas runs its elections. Parties have far too much control over the crafting of candidates and ballots that end up setting trends in the way Texas governs and the goals that Texas government pursues.
I was cold called (2022) for a pollster who wanted to test the waters for getting casinos opened in Texas. We are still in the middle of a pandemic, and these corporate fraudsters are still trying to whittle a few more dollars out of an unsuspecting public with the help of bought and paid for Texas Republican leadership. It’s proof that they live in a different reality than the one that is occurring right outside our doors. The ballot language just drives home the point.
Republicans expect to win and they will do anything to win. They’ll make the subtext text, and baldly state their fear of the brown-skinned invader, as if the brown-skinned were not here before the Republican’s pale white-assed ancestors brought their slaves here and tried to make this a White people’s state. The language on the ballot is xenophobic and anarchist and I really don’t see how Texas survives the next decade with the idiots that ballot language like that will empower.
It is time to move past the Great White Hope in Texas. It is time for the real majority in Texas, the Tejanos, to step forward and claim what is rightly theirs. It is time for a change, starting with a change of the faces in power in Texas and that means voting for candidates that don’t already hold office. I’ve been doing that for thirty years. I’ve been waiting for the rest of you to catch up. It’s now or never. The Republicans are openly declaring war on the brown skinned. Will you let them be rounded up and herded out of the state, or will you stand up and defend them? The choice is yours.
