To the People of Texas & All Americans in the World:
Fellow citizens & compatriots—I am besieged, by a thousand or more of the Mexicans under Santa Anna—I have sustained a continual Bombardment & cannonade for 24 hours & have not lost a man. The enemy has demanded a surrender at discretion, otherwise, the garrison are to be put to the sword, if the fort is taken—I have answered the demand with a cannon shot, & our flag still waves proudly from the walls. I shall never surrender or retreat. Then, I call on you in the name of Liberty, of patriotism & everything dear to the American character, to come to our aid, with all dispatch—The enemy is receiving reinforcements daily & will no doubt increase to three or four thousand in four or five days. If this call is neglected, I am determined to sustain myself as long as possible & die like a soldier who never forgets what is due to his own honor & that of his country—Victory or Death.
William Barret Travis
Lt. Col. comdt
P.S. The Lord is on our side—When the enemy appeared in sight we had not three bushels of corn—We have since found in deserted houses 80 or 90 bushels & got into the walls 20 or 30 head of Beeves.
Travis’ letter from the Alamo – February the 24, 1836
I was reminded of this impending anniversary last year on Reddit. I really didn’t have that much to say about it on Reddit. There were plenty of others there already who said the same things I might say if I had been there first. I wasn’t there first and so I said very little; but I decided to post what thoughts I might be able to muster on the next anniversary of the event.
I, like most other boys who grew up in the sixties and seventies, was raised on stories of Davy Crockett and William Travis. While I didn’t care much for the epic film that John Wayne financed and starred in, the Disney series about Davy Crocket was a staple for me. I remember that show fondly, which probably explains my giggling enjoyment of this They Might Be Giants tribute to the theme song from that show.
That was the history I had learned. Unfortunately it isn’t the real history of Davy Crockett or the Alamo itself. Those stories are much more complex than we were lead to believe as children.
The true history of the battle of the Alamo is a subject that has slowly been brought to light for me and for the rest of the people who are history obsessed like I am. For the rest of the world the facts as they have been revealed over the last forty years or so of investigation might be a bit of a jarring shock.
Forget the Alamo: The Rise and Fall of an American Myth
The leadership at the Alamo was not clearly established. Most of the men were volunteers who followed either Bowie or Crockett. Travis, the only formally authorized officer of the Texian army present in the Alamo, had about thirty men that answered to him. Bowie had been recruited by Sam Houston to decommission the Alamo and bring the volunteers that were garrisoned there back to him. Bowie disregarded that order. he wasn’t known for taking much note of what was legally required or allowed to him. Crockett and his men were there because they had been promised Texas land in return for their service.
None of these men were selfless actors. Travis essentially managed to start the English speaking part of the conflict by arming a ship and taking a seaside garrison that had impounded his client’s ships due to smuggling and non-payment of taxes owed. The Tejanos were already in conflict with Mexico city at that time for their own reasons, but the English speaking immigrants had not been until Travis pulled his stunt. Jim Bowie was in Texas because he was probably going to be hanged if he had stayed in the United States. Land swindles or slave stealing? Take your pick. Crockett was there because there was land for the taking, as were the men following him.
The volunteers under Davy Crockett decided to follow Travis’ and Bowie’s lead at the Alamo even though they weren’t required to; and like the rest of the garrison they simply failed to escape the area around Bexar (modern San Antonio) before they were surrounded. Once they were surrounded Travis issued his famous letters, hoping that Sam Houston and the rest of the Texian army would show up and rescue them from their blind ignorance of what was coming for them.
Sam Houston had tried to impress on Bowie the importance of bringing the fighting men and their canons back to him. You can decided for yourself why this move was important; whether because luring Santa Anna and his army closer to the borders of the United States would trigger an agreed upon response by the US Army or because drawing him further into Texas would stretch his supply lines to the point of breaking and thus give Houston and his army a greater chance at victory. Bowie, Travis, Crockett and the rest of the garrison were instead wiped out according to the long-standing tradition of the time. The tradition of executing all traitors to the crown, the government of Mexico.
I have a begrudging respect for Sam Houston that has only grown greater as the facts of the events he was part of have come to light. It is because of Houston’s understanding of how to capitalize on the reality of Travis’s words and the garrison’s destruction that we have the saying “Remember the Alamo” in the first place. He knew how to motivate men and how to turn a defeat into a victory cry.
However, that was then, and this is now:
The white power structure that still dominates the state of Texas is demonstrably terrified of the idea that the Alamo myth is on the verge of being revised and probably deserves to be forgotten. The people who fought and died at the Alamo did so not for freedom, but for the right to own slaves in Texas in defiance of a Mexican law that outlawed slavery. That is what the English-speaking immigrants went to Texas for in the first place; to make money farming cotton with slave labor.
If you owned slaves, you were a tyrant. There is no way around this fact of nature. You were a tyrant who carried the power of life and death in your own personal kingdom. So calling Santa Anna a tyrant and using that as an excuse to overthrow his rule is no different than any other wartime propaganda move in which you accuse your opponents of doing exactly the thing that you are doing.
No matter how much it bothers you, Davy Crockett and his men demonstrably did surrender to a Mexican officer who promised them leniency. They didn’t die fighting. This was an established fact accepted by historians long before the modern era of movie and television myth building demonstrated their effects on the acceptance of that same established history by the average American. The men who surrendered died betrayed by a general who wanted to make an example of the invaders that were trying to take over the Northernmost province of his country. A province that now makes up parts of five US states.
The rest of the nation has moved on from the days when “remember the Alamo” was a battle cry that could move men’s hearts. Texas, unfortunately, has not.
The grounds of the park that has been dedicated around the site of the Misión San Antonio de Valero, the place we know as the Alamo, are currently undergoing a revision into something akin to a theme park and museum that will showcase purported historical objects collected by various individuals over the years. A blatant attempt to codify the myth that we have created around the ideal of the selfless act that never occurred at the battle of the Alamo.
George P. Bush, Greg Abbott and Dan Patrick have all staked their political careers on making sure that Phil Collin’s questionable collection of artifacts have a museum in which to be seen (alamo.org) and to make sure that shouting Remember the Alamo! while wearing a coonskin cap and carrying an AR-15 in downtown San Antonio is a thing that every (white) child aspires to do.
The Tejanos, who were the Texians’ key allies and a number of which fought and died with them at the Alamo, were entirely written out of generations of Texas history written by Anglo writers. This was mirrored very much in the kind of ethnic cleansing that went on after the revolution in which hundreds of Tejanos were pushed out of San Antonio and Victoria and existing towns, their lands taken, laws passed against their ability to marry white women and hold public office.
Bryan Burrough
As an alternative to the blatant attempt to force the false narrative of the battle of the Alamo that Walt Disney, John Wayne and Fess Parker dreamed up as ideas for us to consume in their media; I would love to see the Alamo chapel repurposed as a meeting place. A place for the various racial groups; blacks, Tejanos, the native nations and the white people of this state, a place for them to come together and try to understand their own history. That would be an appropriate use for the blood-soaked ground that the Alamo sits on.
Texas has always been a battleground, a crossroads between disparate human cultures. If you look at the border with Mexico right now it’s clear that we’re still a battleground between groups of people who simply refuse to try to understand each other. We need to embrace our past and move forward. We need to try to understand the people who still want to come here in spite of the naked aggression that we are clearly showing them. That is the only way to find peace.
What’s hard to understand is that the Alamo lies at the beating heart of the Texas creation myth and, thus, is central to the entire concept of what’s called, down here, Texas exceptionalism, which is the idea, dearly held by generations of Texans, that Texas is somehow just a cut above the Delawares and North Dakotas of the world.
Bryan Burrough
Featured image: latinobookreview/forget-the-alamo
