Thimerosal was taken out of vaccines as “the precautionary principle.” The precautionary principle, which is exercising an abundance of caution, assumes no harm. We did do harm. Two anti-vaccine groups were created by that episode. Generation Rescue or Moms Against Mercury were created because any reasonable person looking at what the CDC did at that time, which was precipitously taking thimerosal out of vaccines, could reasonably say, “Well, they wouldn’t have done it unless it was harmful,” but it wasn’t harmful.
I think probably the best quote at the time, because it was the most ironic, came from the American Academy of Pediatrics, which stated, “All the evidence to date shows that thimerosal at the level contained in vaccines is safe. To make safe vaccines even safer, we’re going to ask companies to take it out.” If it’s safe, taking it out doesn’t make it safer. All it does is make it perceived to be safer, which is a very different thing.
[We] scared people about vaccines. The sense was, these people don’t know what they’re doing. They’re putting it in, they’re taking it out. If anything, we lessen vaccines uptake because we scared them about this harmless preservative. See, the problem is it’s called ethylmercury. Mercury never sounds good. It’s not like there’s the National Center for the Appreciation of Heavy Metals standing up in defense of mercury.
Paul Offit
I have been referring to RFK Jr. as the Minister of Death for several months now. Ever since he started making vaccines harder to get. Ever since he started talking about Making America Healthy Again; which, if it’s anything like Make America Great Again, means exactly the opposite of what it says.
Therefore the Secretary of Health and Human Services in any other Presidential administration becomes the Minister of Death under Trump. It’s not a question of whether RFK Jr. will be responsible for increased deaths in the US until we regain control of our government; but rather how many millions will he be responsible for killing by the time he faces the consequences of his actions.
RFK Jr. is just a chip off the block of Little Donny Trump. He came to his fraudulent behavior more recently then Trump, hasn’t had to launder his entire families fortune through third parties himself (The Kennedy’s have people who do that work for them. They don’t have to sully their hands directly with that work.) so he’s not as well polished or nuanced in his attempts to siphon cash out of the pockets of pharmaceutical companies while lying to grieving parents about what is wrong with their children and what caused it, but there is no difference between the two of them when it comes to results.
The results will be death. Lots and lots of death, all of it to be laid at their feet in the end.
The Moderna vaccine saved my life:
Moderna, one of the MRNA vaccines that Trump and his Minister of Death can’t run away from fast enough. Life-saving medicine thrown out because they want to pander to the delusional who put them in office.
It is worth noting that the infection I experienced was as light as it was largely because I had gotten all my Moderna COVID boosters by that point. Had I never gotten a vaccine at all before catching COVID, you would probably be reading the post that is scheduled to publish after my death right now instead of reading my daily beef about Trump’s Antivaxxer Minister of Death. That is the benefit of knowing who is spewing bullshit and who isn’t. The benefit of critical thinking.
I think there is a tension between public health and individual rights and freedoms. Public health does consider that you have to care about your neighbor. If you’re just saying, “I want to do what I want to do and the hell with my neighbor,” that is an anti-public health stance. There was one moment, actually, in California in 2014 that signified this to me. There was a measles epidemic that started in Southern California, spread to 25 states, involved a few hundred people. The state senator named Richard Pan, who was a pediatrician by training, actually, wanted to eliminate the philosophical exemption for vaccination in that state, a state that didn’t have a religious exemption.
Therefore, he would have eliminated all non-medical exemptions. It was a fight to do that. Certainly, the anti-vaccine people were up in arms, but there was a little boy, a little seven-year-old boy who spoke at those meetings where the anti-vaccine people were out there screaming. He had to stand on a chair so he could reach the microphone, and he said “I can’t be vaccinated. I depend on you to protect me. Don’t I count?” To me, he was the voice of society.
Paul Offit
I put it this way:
I always thought the libertarians who insisted that there was no society, no public, were lunatics. Saying that is no different than saying there isn’t any air because we can’t see it. This is the basis for contesting that public health is an invasion of their liberty. What they don’t understand is that their liberty is in direct conflict with mine, just as mine is in conflict with my neighbor. It is the nature of human existence to have to take the well-being of our neighbors into account. There is no escaping this fact.
