Beware the Woo: Meniett

Meniere's

There is no evidence, from five included studies, to show that positive pressure therapy is effective for the symptoms of Ménière’s disease. There is some moderate quality evidence, from two studies, that hearing levels are worse in patients who use this therapy. The positive pressure therapy device itself is minimally invasive. However, in order to use it, a tympanostomy tube (grommet) needs to be inserted, with the associated risks. These include the risks of anaesthesia, the general risks of any surgery and the specific risks of otorrhoea and tympanosclerosis associated with the insertion of a tympanostomy tube. Notwithstanding these comments, no complications or adverse effects were noted in any of the included studies.

Positive pressure therapy for Ménière’s disease or syndrome

The devices that use grommets in the ear to allow air to be pushed into the space behind the eardrum and down the eustachian tube (the Meniett is one of these) are mostly ineffective at combatting symptoms of Meniere’s, that is what these studies conclude.

If I were to hazard a guess as to why these devices might work for some sufferers; I would say that this is because the sufferer probably has eustachian tube issues that are alleviated by the pressure device. This means that they probably need surgery to repair the eustachian tube dysfunction more than they need a machine to blow air into their middle ears.

The ear pressure from Meniere’s (cochlear/endolymphatic hydrops) symptoms stems from excessive fluid pressure in the cochlea of the inner ear. No amount of external air pressure in the space next to the cochlea (the middle ear) should have any effect on fluid pressure within the canals themselves. It is possible that enriching the area with oxygen might have a positive effect, but then only if the flesh of the middle ear can directly absorb the oxygen and transmit it to the inner ear. The basic conceptualization of this device is flawed, and no amount of marketing will save it from it’s flaws.

A valsalva maneuver will do more to get oxygen and relieve pressure in the inner ear then this device will:

…And the valsalva maneuver itself is of questionable value from a statistical treatment perspective.

A CPAP machine will also pressurize the air in the head, including behind the ear drum. I frequently feel better with my CPAP on than I do when it is off, but then I have breathing problems which are made better with the CPAP. Improving air quality in the head and body has benefits that go way beyond the concerns of the vestibularly challenged, but this doesn’t mean that pumping fresh air into your middle ear is going to do anything good for you.

I balked at getting anything permanent done to my body if I could just take a medication or some other non-invasive treatment that would head off the major symptom of Meniere’s, the vertigo. I was offered grommets for my left ear many, many times over the years. I never accepted the offer because I wasn’t convinced that equalizing the pressure between outer and middle ear would do anything for me. Clearly there are many people with similar beliefs about getting permanent stuff done in an attempt to alter a temporary state of being.

People post all kinds of questionable treatments on every forum that I am a part of. I tend to push back over-hard on these subjects; but their points are generally well-founded. They find relief from these treatments. If something makes you stop stressing out about the next attack, that in itself is enough to warrant using whatever that thing is, whether the thing does what it claims or not.

If your triggers are like the vast majority of sufferers, then just experiencing the stress of contemplating the next vertigo episode can bring on the vertigo. Whatever you can do at that moment to ease the stress is worth more than a dozen different controlled trials that anyone can point to. The key is to have a reassuring routine to fall back on so that you won’t have to worry about that next attack.

Every time I leave the house these days, I check to make sure I have my emergency meds with me. Just having the meds on me reduces the stress of worrying about the next attack. “No worries, I’ll enjoy the day one way or the other.” The mere presence of the tin of pills is enough to keep the major symptoms away on the good days. On the bad days I take the drugs and it’s still a good day because I may be blitzed but at least I’m not spinning.

If you read back through the archives on any of the forums you will run across quite a few people who have opted for surgery. A minority of sufferers, but a significant percentage of them. I’m now a member of that group:

2024/07/dead-ear-doldrums

The symptoms got bad enough that having the inner ear removed and replaced with a cochlear implant was a step up from letting nature continue take its course. I still have problems, but now I have different problems. Some people still experience vertigo after having the exact same surgery that I had. However, none of the feedback that I’ve ever read on any forum has related a positive life improvement from using the Meniett device. Not it or any of it’s competitor devices have ever produced enough of an effect that someone was willing to express their gratitude for the devices being in their lives.

I meant to write about the Meniett device a long, long time ago. I didn’t because I wasn’t clear on what it did or why that might help someone. I didn’t understand what Meniere’s was, then. Since that time, a decade ago and more, many copycats of the Meniett have surfaced (it’s an apparently lucrative con to run) including this simple squeeze bulb attached to an earplug. None of these copycats are any more useful than the original Meniett was. Cheaper, but just as useless at changing the fluid pressure in the inner ear. They simply can’t do the job required.

Featured image: dizziness-and-balance.com/placebo/Meniq

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top