Is Meniere’s Really That Bad?

Daily Beef Disability Meniere's

Someone posted to the Meniere’s subreddit, bitching about their lazy sister and her vain attempts to hold down a job. How she whines incessantly about being dizzy and unable to even get out of bed. “Is it really that bad?” They asked. They have since deleted their post on the subreddit, as so many people seem to do, making my words written to them in reply just another shout into the wind, another curse lost in the void.

The mid-western work ethic, this belief that “you have to be a working member of society or you are a burden” goes down a very dark road. This is eugenics, and it leads directly to the final solution and the Nazi gas chambers. There is no other course that these beliefs can take. We either have to be free to be as productive or as contributive as we are able to be, or we have to be put down as burdens because we are the Unnütze Esser. There is no other recourse if the “ethic” is to be followed.

Fuck that. This response to him and to all the others who might ask “is it really that bad?” deserves to be seen by everyone who dares to think that we just need to push harder and get to work. Get off our lazy asses. If you don’t want your loved one to take their own life in desperation because of your pressure to conform to unreasonable norms then read on, because it really is that bad and it can be even worse than this.


I have relatives that I recognize in you, in your description of your sibling. I will try not to take my hatred of them and their attitudes out on you. You at least have the presence of mind to ask a question about the invisible illness afflicting your sister.

First off, it isn’t a disease. They call it a disease but it’s not well enough understood for it to qualify as a disease under current medical standards. What is happening is (if the diagnosis is correct and her assumed etiology is similar to mine. Meniere’s has no etiology, no cause. All causes are assumed when it comes to this “disease”) your sister’s vestibular system is being consumed by some facet of her immune system, and it’s happening very slowly. So slowly that for days and even weeks at a time, she’ll appear completely normal. This is a lie.

Inside, her ears will be ringing constantly, a maddening symptom that is called tinnitus. It follows you around like a nagging relative that is constantly whispering in your ear; unless they are outright shouting (hyperacusis) making it impossible to hear any other sound without pain.

She will shut herself in her room and hide from other people because being near other people is to be judged as lesser and damaged and flawed. It is the curse of everyone who suffers from a disability. No one even attempts to understand, so why bother to try to relate to them?

The affected ear will also feel as if she’s on a plane ascending at incredible speed, the pressure in the ear so intense that it seems impossible that it hasn’t burst already, and yet it goes on and on and on forever. Never stopping. Not until the vertigo starts.

When the vertigo is active she will look like she’s smashed out of her gourd. Vomiting. Near convulsive. Unable to do even the simplest of tasks without help. She will likely pass out after a few hours of this, from the pain and exertion that goes into just trying to make the world hold still.

After the vertigo will come the brain fog. Wandering in a maze of strangely familiar places and faces with no direct grasp of where you are and who they are, not without struggling to make the connection. Struggling for meaning, for solidity in a world suddenly redefined in a subtle way that she can’t quite grasp no matter how hard she tries.

The hearing starts to go last. With each vertigo attack another section of hearing, another portion of her sense of balance, of presence in the world, is lost. It all has to be relearned, retrained, with vestibular therapy and time. Time that she will only have if she manages to find her triggers and effective treatments that will stop the vertigo and the degradation of her vestibular system. The hearing may come back for a while; but eventually, with enough vertigo attacks, deafness will start to set in and hearing assistance will be required.

The cruelest thing of all is that it won’t kill you. I’ve lived with it for forty years. It robbed me of my career in architecture, the only thing I ever wanted to do more than raise children. It kept me from being the best parent possible for my children as well. They have to see their father as a cripple, incapable of providing for them beyond simply being able to do small chores around the house.

I almost never drive anymore. A moment’s inattentiveness can wreck our only vehicle and send us to the hospital, concentration being one of the first casualties of brain fog. Never mind that I might have a vertigo spell while driving and swerve into oncoming traffic without even knowing I’m doing it. Driving is a major contributor to stress loads and stress is a trigger for most Meniereians, so I don’t drive unless I have to. Unless I’m forced to. I’m sure your sister feels the same way.

Vincent Van Gogh maimed himself and then killed himself because of the inescapable symptoms and the judgements of his society. He was one of us. A fellow traveler. So many of us take our own lives that the only rule for the Meniere’s subreddit is “no suicide posts.” It’s too dangerous a topic to even bring up except to tell others not to go through with their plans. Life is worth living if you can find that connection that keeps you here. The connection that makes living better than dying.

My wife and children are that connection for me. They’re why I get out of bed each morning instead of staying there wallowing in my depression. If you really care about your sister you will try to be part of that connection. Try to be the reason she feels she needs to get out of bed after a truly crushing round of symptoms. Help her find other connections, other reasons to go on living. Depression is the real killer for us, not the symptoms themselves. They just drive us to do the things that isolate us, make us feel unloved and unlovable.

A study conducted in 2000 concluded:

“Meniere’s disease patients are among the most severely impaired non-hospitalized patients studied thus far … Patients describe impairment in travel, ambulation, work and other major social roles as well as trouble learning, remembering and thinking clearly.”

newswise.com

Very few of my vertigo attacks didn’t include my begging everyone in earshot to please kill me.  The sensations are intolerable, and yet you have to tolerate them. You cannot escape them. Had someone offered me an easy way to end it all while in a vertiginous state, I would have readily taken them up on it. That is how bad Meniere’s is.

The wife commented, after reading my response, that the thing to do is to help your sister find a quality of life through getting her disability if that’s what she needs. She shouldn’t be expected to waste/risk her life doing thankless jobs like driving for Doordash in the vain hope of working enough to keep a roof over her head. It’s pointless. Get her disability so that she can get medical coverage and treatment through Medicare. Then her hopes for a better future might be realizable.

The Begging Block

Writing is work. A lot of work. Maintaining a blog takes a lot of time and energy. I don’t have ads on the blog because I fucking hate advertising and I never received anything worth mentioning from Google ads during the decade I let them place ads on my blog (ditto for the Amazon affiliate program, which is why those links are now slowly going away) This means that if I want to defray the costs of maintaining this blog, it has to come from my readers. If you are reading this and if you can afford to throw me a buck, I’m counting on you to click one of the links below and send me a few of them. The Wife, the children and I thank you. Especially the children, who have grown tired of cold gruel.

Postscript

One of the responses that I’ve gotten since turning this into an article was that they had required brain surgery and months of physical therapy in relearning how to walk (this is common among those people who have to have surgery to stop the vertigo. They are mercifully a small percentage of overall sufferers) and so it was definitely that bad for them. This condition, disease, syndrome, whatever, is no joke. It’s serious, debilitating and virtually unknown outside of the circles of people who suffer from it.

I’m going to be getting surgery to shut off my bad ear:

2024/07/dead-ear-doldrums

So, yes. It really is that bad. Stop minimizing the invisible illnesses of others.

2015/02/treating-menieres-its-symptoms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top