Liberal Monetary Policy

Daily Beef Economics Politics Trumpismo

It’s eight in the morning. I’m sitting alone in the waiting room trying desperately to avoid boredom and/or vertigo. My bilateral Meniere’s seems to have cropped up again in my good ear, and I’m just there to get a fresh audiology test so I can figure out if I need another steroid shot in the ear to get it to stabilize again.

Doctor’s appointments are such a pain early in the morning. I generally prefer afternoon appointments so that I have time to get my head on right before having to deal with other humans. When your health goes South, you go to the doctor when they have free time on short notice.

As I’m sitting there trying not to get bored and/or anxiety my way into another vertigo attack, an old white guy who looks pretty much just like me wanders in to get checked in for his appointment. He’s boisterous and off-putting and I remind myself to be a little quieter the next time I come in to check in. Don’t be like the people who resemble you. It’s a never-ending struggle.

I’m trying not to listen to him as they go through the check-in procedure when he quips to the receptionist, right out of the blue “Inflation? Has anyone explained that yet?” probably objecting to the copay he’s expected to fork over. He’s clearly expecting a laugh, but he didn’t get one. Perhaps a slight smile from the receptionist. It’s usually safe to smile and look appreciative of your nutty-assed patients until they turn away.

After he got his ubiquitous check-in iPad, the same kind that seems to proliferate in all the doctor’s offices these days, he came over and sat in the seat next to me. Still trying to avoid the boredom and to distract myself, I decided to play along with his question to the receptionist.

I catch his eye and ask “Inflation?” and he nods in recognition. You overheard that. Hard not to.

“Demand exceeds supply.” I figured I’d at least get some acknowledgement for properly defining the word. It’s supposed to be a humorous moment, much like his earlier misfire with the receptionist.

“Naw. Liberals have flooded the markets with too much money.” Oh. He’s one of those, a certified member of the FOX news zombie army and I’ve made the mistake of starting a conversation with him. Now what do I do? Can I just smile at him politely and humor him like the receptionist did? I don’t think that will work for me.

If it was true, that the inflation was caused by pumping too much money into the system (never mind that Trump pumped a lot more money into the system than the liberals ever did) what this means is that there is more money chasing fewer goods. This backs up my bald definition of the cause of inflation. It’s not true that this is the cause of the inflation beyond the observation that poor people who generally had to do without necessities finally had enough to buy things during the brief period that COVID funds were available to them.

This doesn’t mean that there is too much money, this means that there was too little money in the hands of the poor prior to COVID. The real question that this revealed fact raises is what are the poor doing now without their COVID windfalls? Obviously this means they’re going back to doing without as they did before. How much of that explains the reduction in inflation? Does their heightened suffering justify the easing of the pressure on my pocketbook?

I can’t let that stand. It’s just another thought-ending conservative talking point. It doesn’t prove anything and simply masks an underlying flaw in the system itself.

“The COVID pandemic supply snarls are only just now getting worked out.” Which is a true observation as far as it goes. Businesses are leaving their prices higher because they can, because no government agency is demanding they stop scalping their customers. We’ve only just now figured out that the businesses are scalping consumers, but it is a factor in the prices remaining high.

“You really believe that?” He seemed incredulous of this known and repeatedly confirmed fact that I had apparently exposed him too, like a fresh dog turd in the middle of the doctor’s waiting room. Then he added “Don’t get me started.” with more than a little heat.

Hey, that’s my tagline, I thought to myself. “It’s true. The supply lines are just now getting back on schedule. I read and listen to economists all the time. This was what was causing the inflation.” I was attempting to feign patience and probably failing at the task. I could have added, “It’s much worse in the rest of the world, you should be thanking Joe Biden for keeping it from being worse.” but I didn’t want to push my luck.

“You must be one of those Keynesians.” He said it like it was an accusation.

I heard myself say “Keynes was a genius.” And marveled at how much my opinions had changed in twenty years. “He was born way ahead of his time.”

He snorted in derision, and the atmosphere grew noticeably colder in the waiting room. Luckily we were the only ones there or it might have been an even more uncomfortable situation.

I had outed myself as a certified fanboy of John Maynard Keynes. I am a nerd. I think the text that cemented my fanboy credentials was Lords of Finance: The Bankers Who Broke the World. Lord Keynes was instrumental in his advocacy of changing the world economy off of the gold standard, which had so horribly failed to right the economic state of the world following World War One. Not only did the Gold Standard not lead the way into economic recovery, but it seemed to make things increasingly worse with no end in sight.

I was contemplating the proper Socratic question to pose to my newly discovered economic opponent. I knew him to be one of the converts of the Chicago School of economic thought, whether he knew this about himself or not. How to phrase the question? I puzzled on it for a few minutes, trying to think how to put it succinctly.

“You disagree with John Maynard Keynes? If the Gold Standard and the ideals of hard money are true, the opposite of Keynesian proposals, then answer this question. The United States was swimming in gold reserves paid to it for the weapons it produced in World War One. Why were Americans starving while crops rotted in the field when they were the wealthiest people on the planet? Europe had no gold left and so imposed austerity on its people in order to bring their gold reserves back. How could they get their gold back if American’s didn’t have the money to buy goods from them?”

Fortunately or unfortunately, the nurse called my name just as I was about to lay out the question, and so I never got to see how he would have reacted to the challenge of his beloved conservative talking points. Modern monetary theory (MMT) can answer the questions that the Chicago School glosses over and has no real answers for. We’ve been down the road that these neo-classicists want to take. We know where it goes.

2019/02/the-delusion-of-money

It’s time to try something different, and MMT can point the direction towards a saner economic standard than expecting the working poor to suffer in the name of keeping prices low. The first thing we have to do is learn that money is a made-up thing, like Jacob Goldstein says. (that’s another great book, just FYI) and realize that we don’t know what money is yet. I doubt we’ll figure it out in my lifetime.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top