Parking Design

Architecture Technical

The subject came up of why someone would park so poorly in a particular parking lot. It really doesn’t matter much which one it was. Someone parked their car square in the center of four straight-in parking spaces. I’m sure everyone has seen something like this. “Why are people so rude?” they ask.

Several people piled on the guy accusing them of being an idiot. They aren’t an idiot. They know where the lines are and they didn’t park in them. Now, why would this be?

It’s not idiocy. They’re counting on the courtesy of others to keep them away from their car, using other people’s behavior to keep the damage to their car to a minimum. They count on you to not break the rules. To not block them in on purpose. To not accidentally drag a sharp object across their shiny, new finish. You were trained not to act that way. By parents and driver’s Ed teachers. By however many numbers of years of parking in a particular fashion. Habit forms. You are trained. Try parking across the lines some time and try to pretend that you don’t care.

I wish you luck. Unless you are like that guy, you probably can’t do it.

It is a badly designed lot though, and I can say this as someone who used to design parking lots for a living. Straight-in parking is almost as bad as parallel parking from a design perspective. It requires a full 90° turn into what is usually a too-narrow parking space, with a pretty narrow driving aisle behind it. It’s a nerve-wracking task until you get the hang of it, but parking can and does lead to most of the damage that a car will see in a lifetime.

The “back-in” parking that the city of Austin is adopting is probably the easiest to master, the problem is that most drivers haven’t been trained to do that all their lives. Angle parking would have been a godsend for this location but the designers chose poorly. Angle parking would have kept the guy from covering four spaces. At most he would cover two because it’s pointless to cross the middle line in angle parking. Doing that just makes it harder to pull back out of the lot.

Why do parking lots suck as bad as they do though? This particular lot was in front of an HEB, so I will use them as an example, but this is true of most retail locations in a shopping center.

It’s all down to site management, generally. HEB doesn’t usually own the parking lot and they don’t always own the building, either. They can ask the site owner/manager to modify the parking lots, but they will probably have to pay for that themselves if the owner agrees to the modifications.

I don’t know HEB’s corporate design structure (that would be a sweet gig) but they probably have either a design group in house or an outside contractor. Whoever that is, they develop and sign off on site layouts.

In most corporate arrangements like that, the designer doesn’t even go to the site. I used to design Bookstop locations for their outside contractor. We had one guy who might go to a location (featured or anchor stores had more design depth in them) and your ability to visualize the layouts were entirely dependent on that guy’s ability to take the right photographs of the location and be able to describe it to you.

You can work for several days trying to get a feel for a site and lay things out according to your intuition only to have someone over you (corporate side or in-house. Two masters, at least) insist on another layout or cost- saving measures.

There are also minimum parking requirements (why most parking lots are so cramped) that factor into design. It can get quite tedious after a while. Some people just push pencils, even in design jobs.

I daresay that HEB and most other parking lots suck because of all of those factors; but mostly cost and parking requirements. I personally would love to get an inside look at how their corporate structure is set up. Processes like that are fascinating to me.

Reddit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top