Doublethink Is Stronger Than Orwell Imagined

Holiday Literature

“The moral to be drawn from this dangerous nightmare situation is a simple one: Don’t let it happen. It depends on you.”

George Orwell, quoted in The Ministry of Truth: The Biography of George Orwell’s 1984 by Dorian Lynskey

The problem with every interpretation of 1984 that I have ever seen, is that the creator of whatever form the entertainment took tried too hard to replicate the exact set of scenes and technologies mentioned in the book. Take this movie, for example:

“Nineteen Eighty-Four – Official Trailer” – 1984 Novel on Amazon

It’s frightening, sure. Great actors, great sets. As good as the effort is, it isn’t really as horrifying as the book itself is in my head. I’m not sure that you can reach the personalized level of horror that George Orwell gets to in the book without actually reading the book again for the first time.

Even on second reading, the horror isn’t really there. You know it. It’s like an old friend, which is horrifying in itself. That, I think, is the true insight that Orwell comes to with this work.

Like Winston sipping Victory Gin and contemplating the disgusting things that were done to him and that he and Julia did together in plotting the downfall of the state; only then to find himself cheering for the meaningless victory being broadcast on the television, fully knowing how pointless everything was and at the same time valuing the pointlessness of it. Double-think is very soothing when the bullet is already coming for you.

Take that plane trip. Light those fuses. Pollute the air and your bodies and the world with the trash that will be rotting the minute it leaves your hand. Enjoy yourselves while you can. The bullet is already on it’s way for you, too, as horrifying as that thought is.

1984 will always be an essential book, regardless of changes in ideologies, for its portrayal of one person struggling to hold on to what is real and valuable. “Sanity is not statistical,” Winston thinks one night as he slips off to sleep. Truth, it turns out, is the most fragile thing in the world. The central drama of politics is the one inside your skull.

George Packer, The Atlantic, July 2019

Afterword

I remembered wanting to write something about the book and the efforts to interpret it for other forms of entertainment when I gathered these quotes originally. I couldn’t put it into words when I hit publish previously, so I left them as naked quotes.

I have now come up with words that describe what it was I wanted to say. The urgency that comes across in the movies isn’t frenetic enough. Winston and Julia believe they are changing the world with their little trysts. They know it in an immediate and sensate form. It is a false knowledge. They are amusing themselves to death, just as the rest of the world is doing today.

We live in the world George Orwell wrote about, and we don’t even see it occurring around us right now. We think it’s a story about a particular year in another world, when it’s about us and the way we think every minute of every day right here and right now. It’s a horror novel, and most people don’t even understand that’s what it is.

This isn’t a postscript because there wasn’t a literal script for this article until I wrote it today (moving it up to it’s new publish date from the date I published the quotes, June 13, 2019) but it’s a fitting script for today, July 4th, 2024. As the explosions go off around me in celebration of the Declaration of Independence in 1776, a significant portion of us are plotting to replace that declaration and it’s subsequent authorizing document, the Constitution, with some new form of government that is really more a mirror of the government we threw off. Double-think is alive and well in the world.

Enjoy that oily gin, Winston. I think I’ll have a sip of my XO Kelt in honor of the United States that was. The bullet is coming for both of us, whether we acknowledge it or not.

The blind, blatant disregard for truth is offered without even the sugar-façade of sweetness of temper or equableness or entertainment—offered not with a sheen of condescending consensus but in an ancient tone of rage, vanity, and vengeance. Trump is pure raging authoritarian id.

newyorker

Featured image from: https://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/orwells-1984-and-trumps-america

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top