Gore Won and Lost. Blame the Electoral College.

History Politics

Just in case you think this election season is bad so far. Remember when hanging chads were a thing?

On the Media – What Bush v. Gore Revealed About Contested Elections – May 17, 2024

Everyone talks about the Florida totals because of the bullshit that is the Electoral College that picks our president for us. Here’s the more important number: 543,895. That’s the number of votes that Gore won the popular vote by; and if he had won we wouldn’t have invaded Iraq, might have avoided 9-11 and certainly wouldn’t have elected Donald Trump. We’d be farther along in combatting climate change and we wouldn’t have lost two million people to COVID and might possibly have avoided the plague altogether.

THAT is what allowing “the wisdom of the people” to select our presidents for us would have done, instead of the history that we did experience. It’s as plain as day to anyone versed in that history. The wisdom of the people/crowd is a thing that the founders didn’t even know existed, so how could they have understood that direct election of the president was essential for the smooth running of our government?

The election system in the US needs a major overhaul, and I don’t expect that these chuckleheads in charge of our government today are capable of doing the job that needs doing; largely because they don’t even know that it’s a problem.

The primary system and its reliance on parties to provide the structure for our elections is the first major hurdle to clear. If we don’t fix the system so that the two best candidates in any race from any party are the only names on a general ballot, then we will be fighting math (and game theory) just trying to get a government that works for us.

Fiasco: Bush v Gore: Homestead

However, the reason why this all played out in Florida, Cuban Americans punishing the Clinton administration for the Elián González fiasco, is a hallmark of stupid American political movements (also? Fiasco being behind a paywall is itself a fiasco) or the environmental movement voting for Ralph Nader because Al Gore just wasn’t green enough to suit them?

Because these (and other) groups threw Florida back into contention they enabled W. to persecute a war against Iraq and Afghanistan and cost the lives of a million people. This is what is wrong with casting protest votes in the general election. It gets people killed and gets bad policies enacted. Protest votes are for the primaries, not the general election.

If I were to translate the 2000 race into the 2024 race, Joe Biden didn’t take away your right to abortion, Donald Trump did. Joe Biden didn’t cause inflation, Donald Trump’s tariffs and pandemic fiasco did that, too. American policy regarding Israel goes all the way back to Truman; which, contrary to popular belief, was before Joe Biden was even in office. Withholding votes from Biden in November is just going to make things worse than they are now, if you can even imagine what that might be like. This malaise around the name of Joe Biden is no different than the malaise that surrounded Al Gore. It is as meritless and as pointless and every bit as self-destructive as those feelings were 24 years ago.

If Americans want more predictable, functional governance, the way to get this is to remove the parties from control of the primary process and mandate that only two candidates emerge to compete in the general election.

This will allow for more candidates with wider ranging views to appear on the ballot earlier so that all sides can be heard during an election. Eliminating the electoral college removes the possibility of a candidate winning the presidency without the majority of Americans voting for them. Requiring everyone to vote eliminates the excluding of minorities from the polls as a political strategy.

All of these changes make for better governance, so I’m sure most Americans will be opposed to them. Americans will always do the right thing, only after they have tried everything else. (It doesn’t matter who made that quote before me, it remains consistently true across history) I encourage my fellow Americans to prove me wrong. Do the right thing the first time, just this once.

Florida Was Tied, Presidentially

The margin of victory being less than the margin of error is the democratic definition of a tie. The people who cared about democracy should have argued that Florida’s presidential vote was inconclusive (I made this argument in 2000) this means there was no winner. The only fair recourse was to either conduct a runoff election and hope for a better outcome with only two names on the ballot (another important step) or withhold Florida’s Electoral College votes because there was no decision made.

No victory was possible with those ballot results, and both sides should have known this at the start. If some kind of rational contingency like a runoff or a abstention vote is not possible then you’re going to get what happened in Florida in 2000, or even worse outcomes that include violence and death, every single time that the votes are tied like this.

The laws setting out how this is all done should have been crafted a century ago. When the powers that be saw the mess that occurred in Florida after Bush v. Gore, they should have been drafted in all fifty states the next year. The Constitution should have been amended to make allowance for these provisions as well as getting rid of the Electoral College, which for all intents and purposes is a failed institution.

What happened in 2000 was the next to worst possible outcome. The SCOTUS stepping in to allow Florida to wash their hands of the tie vote and declare victory for George Bush when there was no victory for either of the candidates in the vote as originally tallied; and a full recount, which might have at least created the semblance of victory for someone, was never embarked upon because of them.

The SCOTUS might have had a positive impact on history if they had done the right thing and backed the statistical analysis, declaring that there was no victor in the tie vote in Florida; and that any democratic race that was tied in the same fashion must be treated as a tie requiring a tie-breaking run-off election in order for anyone to be declared a victor in future races. That would have been a positive step and would have underscored the importance of getting well-designed ballots and balloting machines in place before the next election rolled around. It would also have given the election to Gore because without the awarding of the unearned Florida electoral college votes, Gore was still the winner of the election. Gore should have been president by any reasonable measure applied to the election.

The worst possible outcome in 2000 would have been a civil war being declared over the fact that Florida couldn’t admit that they didn’t have electoral college votes to give out that year. An outcome we are likely to see this year as, once again, Republicans attempt to steal the office of President without earning the votes of the majority of Americans, playing the same game they’ve played since Tricky Dick Nixon convinced the White Nationalists to switch parties and vote for Republicans in 1970. They openly bank on not counting all the votes these days. They have abandoned democracy.

The Myth Of 538

I wrote a primer on the subject of the Electoral College a few years ago, when Donald Trump should have been rebuffed by the electors; and the only Republican opponent who didn’t concede, John Kasich, should have been chosen instead if these vaunted guardians of American government couldn’t bring themselves to actually cast ballots for Hillary Clinton. Trump was clearly unfit for office from the start of the election, and his promises to subvert constitutional law should have kept him from even being sworn into office in 2017.

However, the EC proved they were as useless as tits on a boar and blithely voted to cut everyone’s throats by choosing Trump’s name as the person they were going to vote for. (Insanity among the electorate is no more a defense than insanity in the Presidential office is) the 2016 election was the perfect test of the EC, almost as if it were designed for them to prove their worth. When they failed to demonstrate their value and still no one attempted to dismantle the EC, I rewrote the article to generically point out exactly how much better off we would be if the EC simply no longer existed:

2020/10/the-electoral-college-explained

It is painfully obvious to everyone paying attention that we have to do one of the following three things so that the President of the United States will always be elected by the majority of the American people; we either must amend the constitution to remove the EC, legislatively render it toothless in every state legislature in the US, or modify the structure that dictates its size and representation. One of these three things must occur.

Several states have already passed the legislation mandating the popular vote outcome enshrined in the National Popular Vote legislation being introduced across the nation in all fifty US states. We are still several states away from making the EC obsolete from that angle. Removing the EC through amendment, while appealing to my obsessive-compulsive disorderly need for a spotlessly clean rule-generating horizon, is an even longer and harder slog than the passage of legislation in all fifty states.

The easiest solution to this problem is still the one that I think we should do anyway. We should do it because the myth of 538 needs to be shattered. Again, for those who didn’t read the EC article or haven’t looked into why Nate Silver’s prediction analysis group is named 538, the Electoral College seats are composed of one vote or seat for every senator in the Senate, every member of the house that is seated from each of the fifty states, plus the three seats provided for the District of Columbia per Article one Section eight of the US Constitution. We should mandate to the House of Representatives that we want more representation in that body. We want a thousand-seat House.

NPR – Stuck At 435 Representatives? Why The U.S. House Hasn’t Grown With Census Counts – APRIL 20, 2021

Destroying the 435 cap for the House of Representatives does many desirable things aside from make the EC more representative of the population of the various states. While it will make government more expensive by radically increasing the numbers of representatives in Washington DC, it will produce immediate benefits in allowing the power in the United States, the people themselves, to have a more individual voice in Congress.

538 has to go, one way or the other. Pick your weapon of choice and have at it. Because I value democracy, the undeniable wisdom of the crowd, I will always come down on the side of making the legislature more representative of the average American. That it also will return the Presidency to the rightful frame of popular mandate is simply a pleasant side-benefit. I’ll take it.

Gore should have been President, and was cheated of this by the Supreme Court. Hillary Clinton should have been President and was pushed aside by my fellow Americans inability to foresee the failings of their own political systems. Will Americans allow that mass-murdering, traitorous, lech, Donald Trump, to be returned to the White House in a fashion similar to 2016 or will they understand their peril and vote in the right states in the right numbers to prevent that irreversible tragedy? That is the question that came to my mind listening to this series of podcasts.

If we don’t learn from history, then what is the point of remembering it at all?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top