Information Has To Be Free?

Daily Beef Economics Philosophy Podcast

More and more information on the internet is going behind paywalls. This is a troubling development that I have raged against from the beginning. At first I laughed at the few places that put their information in places that it couldn’t be found and then demanded I pay them first. “Information wants to be free!” I would shout over their stupid little walls and then I would go somewhere that the information I wanted was freely available.

Back in 2020 some of the podcasts that I had been listening to started to put their back catalogs behind paywalls. I first noticed this with a little known podcast called A Partially Examined Life. I’m a bit of an amateur philosopher (at least I think of myself this way) and a podcast about philosophy was right up my alley on occasion. I didn’t just binge my way through the whole library like I’ve done with some other podcasts (I’m looking at you Skeptic’s Guide to the Universe & Radiolab) I would savor each episode like a fine wine, enjoying the banter between the hosts on the rare occasions when I was in the mood for it.

Then they started to truncate the episodes to just the first fifteen minutes as a teaser, just to give you a taste of what you could get if only you could afford to pay for the entire episode.

This wasn’t something we tried and abandoned. This is us redacting old content to try to get you to pay for it, and it’s the main way we make money. We will in fact be moving MORE episodes behind the paywall soon. It’s very easy for you to hear all the redacted episodes for a mere $5: https://partiallyexaminedlife.com/membership-options/, or at our Patreon site, you can get some of them for just $1 and more for $3, or purchase them a la carte on our store page for $2 each. Thanks.

If you spring for the PEL Citizen feed, you can listen in the normal way, but yes, if it takes you 3 months to get through 80 episodes or whatever’s there, then that’s $15, which is still a very good deal. I think our providing 100+ episodes for free fulfills our public service mission and is hopefully enough to get anyone really interested in us hooked enough to want to support our activities on an ongoing basis. That said, if the Citizen feed is too pricey for you, I’m happy to scholarship it, like go ahead and sign up and install, cancel after a month, then ping me and I’ll manually reactivate.

Mark Linsenmayer

This reminds me of the scene from Victor/Victoria where Julie Andrews is willing to sell her virtue for a single meatball and then attempts to steal dinner for three (even though only two people were eating) by putting a cockroach into her salad. Poverty is a real thing. People really can’t afford to pay for all the things that are needed to survive. It’s not that I don’t want to pay them for their content, all these different content creators that rightly think they should get paid to work, I simply don’t have the money to pay for all these different things that people expect me to pay for. I can’t work and even if I could find some kind of work it would pay less than the disability that I would have to give up in order to find that work.

It was a misnomer about information wanting to be free back in the days when I would haughtily shout over the silly paywalls that first started springing up. Information doesn’t want anything. People need information to be free if those people are going to be tasked with governing themselves. If the information is not free then the people can’t make informed decisions.

Contrary to what most people think, understanding that you have a philosophy (whether you want to have one or not) and knowing how that philosophy is encoded and manipulated by others is key to knowing when you are correct in your actions or beliefs and knowing when you are being played; which means making discussion about the bones of philosophy entertaining and accessible is one of the most vital things that can be done in this day and age.

A Partially Examined Life had the entertaining part covered. It would be beneficial to the public if they left the information out where it could be accessed by anyone who was curious about the subject rather than demand payment up front. The benefits of better government through an informed public can be felt by everyone just as who to blame for the still evolving Trump hellhole we find ourselves in should be painfully obvious to even the most fervent face-painting Republican. That this isn’t the case can be partially laid at the feet of the way that we have historically financed educational ventures like that the authors of A Partially Examined Life embarked on. They should be compensated for their time. Limiting access to the information is a self-defeating means of being compensated, and it is also worth noting that I wouldn’t be listening to the show in the first place if all I could get were samples, and would have to pay for access to the full podcast. I can get a taste of all kinds of things all over the internet. If I have to choose between eating and entertainment I’m reliably going to pick eating every time. Food for thought.

comment

You don’t think the staff should be paid?

How do they expect us to make informed decisions without access to the information required? Is this a country of equals or a country of the privileged? If you restrict access to information for any reason then you have created a system of privileges and the privileged who will be, by their very nature, better informed and therefore able to make better decisions. There will always be people closer to the information than you are, and that person will be a master over you by way of access.

The important question here is “how can we self-govern without the necessary information?” It is a question that has never been properly answered. In the past the information gap was the basis for castes and classes and inequality. If we ever want to do better than our ancestors we will have to address how information is spread without charging the end-user for it, unless we are going to give those people all the money they need to inform and care for themselves.

reddit

Democracy hinges on a fully informed public; a fact that every paywall hinders. If the individual is expected to pay for every good and service that they use then it becomes essential that the individual be provided with a minimum basic income to cover the costs of these essentials.

Otherwise, democracy and freedom fail when the poor economize themselves out of essential information. Health fails when they economize with that. These truths are being revealed all around us. You simply have to look.

It’s everyone’s responsibility to ensure that everyone near them has what they need. It’s one of the basic tenets of human existence, caring for each other. The surest way to do this is to create a monetary stream that rewards every person in the system with enough funds to meet their minimum basic needs.

Capitalism rewards the greediest. That is its flaw. Socialism fails to inspire the entrepreneurs, the risk takers, that is its flaw. Somewhere between these two opposing philosophies is a system that will work for the majority of people, and that system will include some provision for minimum basic income. Like it or not, that is the future.

reddit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top