It’s a Mystery: Part 2

Film Literature Television

Don’t make people into heroes, John. Heroes don’t exist, and if they did I wouldn’t be one of them.

Sherlock – The Great Game

I started reading Sherlock Holmes stories when I was a child, after I had started and then finished reading most of the of The Hardy boys mysteries. It’s a given that I was always going to start my reading journey with mysteries. There was no way I could avoid this fate. I was and still am terminally curious, unable to leave an unknown unknown once I have stumbled across a gap in my knowledge.

This compulsion shows up in the kinds of children’s books I had been drawn to (What Spot?) and the fact that I still go on multi-hour walks into areas I’ve never explored before. It also shows up in the kinds of television that I’m attracted to. I’m sure I was watching Ironside at about the time I started in on my mystery reading adventure. Ironside was the latest in a series of “police” procedurals that my mother and father went through on a regular basis.

In the not to distant future would be the Rockford Files and Quincy M.E. and then on to a dozen other detective shows (including Simon & Simon) but back in the days of the beginning of my reading journey it was Dragnet and other cop shows on the one hand and Perry Mason followed by Ironside on the other hand.

That is, when you weren’t watching that newfangled thing called a sitcom, but we aren’t talking about those shows here.

As I said, I had finished reading the first real thing that I had set out to read, the Hardy Boys, so I began reading other things, starting with other things that looked and read like mysteries. Asimov’s robot mysteries, Tom Swift stories (my first exposure to science or speculative fiction) and finally, Sherlock Holmes. It’s quite likely I read a large portion of Sir Arthur Canon Doyle’s work on Holmes in the Leoti library, although I don’t remember ever encountering the character of Holmes’ brother Mycroft prior to watching the movies with Tony Stark, err, Robert Downey, Jr. playing the role of Sherlock Holmes.

I wasn’t impressed with RDJ’s portrayal of Holmes or the movies themselves. I was no more impressed with them than I had been any of number of times previously when I had encountered attempts to make television out of the Holmes stories. I’ve sampled a lot of these adaptations over the years and most of them are slavish projections of the stories directly onto the screen; which produces dry, barely watchable narratives.

A book really can’t be directly translated into video. If what you produce amounts to the text of the book presented in a visual medium, what you are creating is not good television. Why create a video portion of the program at all? The individual reader with even a modicum of imagination will be able to run rings around anything you can do visually while simply executing the text of the story in a visual medium. An audiobook is cheaper. Just get the audiobook and set your imagination free.

Sherlock Holmes: The Definitive Collection

(I’ve fallen asleep listening to this volume on repeat for months now. Never gets old.)

Not that the Ironman Holmes movies were in any way slavish reproductions of any of the texts in question. No, their problems lied in different directions than adhering too strictly to the words of Conan Doyle. They might actually have been more watchable if they had been more like ANY of the stories in question. As they were I was more annoyed by everything that wasn’t an over-the-top action sequence that reminded me of League of Extraordinary Gentlemen more than I was intrigued by their similarity to anything written by Conan Doyle, ever.

What it takes to make a Holmes story more interesting in a video format is to produce something like Columbo or Monk or some other detective story that blends the structure of a Holmes story into a modern day television narrative. Sherlock, like those other loose adaptations of the stories, hits that narrative spot for me. Reverent and at the same time a mashup of who knows how many Holmes stories, all at the same time. Brilliantly acted and generally entertaining, each show keeps me guessing until the end exactly how the story is going to wrap up.

The storyline for Moriarty is a prime example of how the characters and stories from the books are blended into interesting new arcs that seem like they are recognizable but are somehow, if not actually better, then are at least novel new interpretations that hold your attention.

Martin Freeman‘s portrayal of John Watson is spot on. The two of them, Benedict and Freeman, filling the roles of the characters so easily that the vaguely homoerotic male relationship that has always been present in their stories ends up being the subject of a repeated joke across the episodes “sorry we couldn’t get you two a shared room” and has, of courses, spawned unfounded rumors of a love affair between the two actors on the internet.

Benedict Cumberbatch can be forgiven for starring in Star Trek: Into Darkness solely on the strength of his portrayal of Holmes in the few episodes of Sherlock that do exist (13, to be exact. Was the final episode number count purposeful?) The problem with Sherlock is there’s not enough of it. Maybe we’ll get more? Who knows?

I have plenty of things I could say about Steven Moffatt in general, especially when it comes to Doctor Who, not a lot of it good. His style of writing seems to fit Sherlock quite well

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top