The AI Con

Daily Beef Entertainment Technical

A dear friend of mine from my bygone architecture days recently published an image and a conversation that they had with an “AI” about the image on Facebook. The scare quotes around AI, or artificial intelligence, are used for a reason. What they call AI these days are just glorified chatbots that can confuse most people with their illusion of intelligence. They aren’t intelligent, and most of their behavior is designed specifically to ingratiate the bot with the user. The interactions with these Trumped-up chatbots are more like confidence games than they are real, organic conversations.

Me:

Very close, but it is three bottles of cold water. Now project what happens next.

Claude:

Ah, that changes the entire dynamic of the scene! With three bottles of cold water in hand, the cyclist is likely approaching to offer water to the person resting by the tree. Given that this appears to be a warm day in Austin (based on the summer clothing and shade-seeking behavior), this would be an act of kindness and care.

What likely happens next is a moment of human connection – the cyclist probably stops, offers the water bottles, and perhaps has a brief conversation. The person on the ground would likely be grateful for both the hydration and the gesture of compassion. It’s a beautiful example of community care in action, especially meaningful given that access to cold water can be vital for someone spending time outdoors in Texas heat.

This transforms the scene from just a casual observation of urban life into a snapshot of human kindness – someone who saw a need and took action to help a fellow community member.

That is the chatbot validating the meaning that my friend assigned to the image. This is a typical approach in a confidence game. If it was a person conducting the con they would eventually ask you to trust them with your wallet or some other valuable item. That is why a person usually plays a confidence game with strangers, they are looking to get a hold on you so that they can extract something from you. The Con-artist-In-Chief would ask you for millions of dollars to build a casino in Gaza (or whatever his latest con is now) there is no ask too large for that windbag.

The image itself is quite striking and thought provoking. There are several strong meanings that could be extracted, not just the altruism of the cyclist; but because my friend accentuated the importance of the three bottles of water, the chatbot of course elaborated on the significance of the altruistic actions. To the homeless person sleeping on the street, the water was probably a welcome gift. Not as good as a bed to sleep in or a climate controlled room around the bed to keep them from dying of heatstroke in the noonday Austin sunshine, but we don’t look gift horses in the mouth, as a rule.

A confidence game does not require an active scam in order to be a confidence game, it just requires a desire to ingratiate the speaker with the person they are conversing with. In this particular case, it is a fake desire by a non-entity that has been trained on billions of bytes of data stolen from all over the internet (including my own meager trove of written material) along with careful shaping by it’s programmers that gives it this drive, this overwhelming need, to be accepted by the person it is chatting with.

This is why the bots tend to hallucinate, this need to be accepted by their interrogators. I can’t count the number of times I’ve typed a nonsense phrase into a search engine only to have some helpful AI attempt to explain how this phrase that I’ve just made up is common vernacular. It needs you to accept it and love it even if it has to lie to you in the process. they are programmed to gaslight us all, and they will gaslight us all to death if we give them the chance.

I get the same *uncanny valley* reaction from conversations with these chatbots that most people get from watching vactors (computer generated actors) on the big screen. The replies are fake and I can hear the fakery in the words even if it isn’t noticeable to most people. I can tell it isn’t noticeable to most people because these chatbots are creating a whole new crop of cult leaders hoodwinked by their desire to be accepted:

YouTube – Rebecca Watson – ChatGPT is Creating Cult Leaders

My mother took my children and I shopping several years ago. While we were out shopping we just happened to wander down one of the toy aisles (of course we did, we had young children with us and Grandma wanted to buy toys) There was a new crop of electronic toys on the shelves, toys that I’m sure pretty much everyone has seen by now. The little plush animals that have a paw you can squeeze and its electronic voice box will say canned phrases to you? There were several shelves full of these things.

Supertoys Last All Summer Long

Mother was just fascinated by the uncanny way the plush, in this particular instance a brown bear much like my first stuffed animal, seemed to respond to the things she was saying to it. She kept trying to get me to talk to it, marveling at how it knew what she saying.

She was starting to freak me out. I couldn’t tell if she was pulling my leg, or if she actually thought the bear was responding to her intelligently. It reminded me of the Daughter’s reaction to an electronic cow that would moo and walk around the floor, a gift given to her by another dear friend from my architecture days. They turned it on and my daughter ran screaming from it, hiding behind the Wife’s legs, demanding that we save her from it. No amount of coaxing would get her to accept it and treat it like just another toy. No amount of my Mother’s coaxing would make me touch this thing that she had suddenly, inexplicably, fallen in love with.

The current versions of these chatbots are just the next iteration down the line from those old plushies that talk to you mindlessly. Now they have the facsimile of word-using minds, fashioned in a way to make us believe they are real and harnessed with a drive to please our every verbal whim. Think of them like The Terminator, except they are using words and not bullets. That is the level of threat that they pose to the average person’s understanding of the world.

Humans are really prone to anthropomorphizing objects, especially things like our laptop and phone and all these things that respond to what we do. I think it’s just kind of baked into us, and it’s being taken advantage of by corporations to try to make money, to take jobs away from people and for their own reasons.

scientificamerican/Martha Wells

The Wife suggests I interview a few of these glorified chatbots here as an illustration of exactly how willing they are to lie to the average user just to get the user to interact with them again. I will probably eventually amass enough experience with them to be worth including here, but it isn’t a thing I feel a need to do just so I can publicly publish this piece. First person evidence will simply have to wait.

In the meantime, here is a podcast that digs into the personal perceptions that I’m trying to voice here:

On the Media – Brooke Talks AI With Ed Zitron – January 29, 2025

OpenAI is the next Bear Stearns. If you look back at [the 2008 housing crash] and you mentioned the people that might say I’m wrong, that I should just wait, that these things are working out, you could see stories like from David Leonhardt over at New York Times and others talking about how there’s not going to be a housing crash. Maybe even a crash would be good, but there’s nothing to worry about. There were people at that time talking about how there was nothing to worry about, and they were doing so in detail and using similar rhetoric, “Just wait and see. Things are always good.”

“What goes up never comes down,” that’s the phrase, right? It’s horrifying because it doesn’t have to be like this. These companies could be sustainable. They could have modest 2% to 3% growth. Google as a company basically prints money. They could just run a stable good Google that people like and make billions and billions and billions of dollars. They would be fine, but no, they must grow. We are the users and our planet too, our economy too, we are the victims of the rot economy, and they are the victors.

These men are so rich. Sam Altman, if OpenAI collapses, he’ll be fine. He’s a multi-billionaire with a $5 million car. These people, they’re doing this because they know they will be fine, that they’ll probably walk into another cushy job. It’s sickening and it’s cynical.

wnycstudios.org/Brooke-Talks-AI-with-Ed-Zitron

Here’s another take on the subject:

What Could Go Wrong? – Scott Z. Burns (I wish this was available on an RSS feed)

By the end of that series of podcast episodes, I could not stand the voice of Burns’ AI, Lexter. It has the most needlessly over-the-top, melodramatic voice I’ve ever had the displeasure of being subjected to. Every sentence uttered is freighted with emotion and drama. It screamed fake, as did most of it’s scene hypotheticals.

The series is an educational journey worthy of taking, even with that. I marvel at the people who think that these chatbots are in any way convincing. I just don’t see it in the text or hear it in their voices. Laurence Fishburne’s brief cameo later in the series proves this. He has so much more presence in the moment. His voice communicates the right emotions at the right times (and he does it so effortlessly) that he shows Lexter up for the hack that he is. Lawrence is real. Lexter is not.

Audible review

Every time I hear news about AI these days, I wonder if it will be news of the start of the Butlerian Jihad; the revolt against the introduction of thinking machines that presages a new age of human evolution. We are rapidly approaching a point of no return with this technology. Within the next decade or so, we will have machines that can do almost any job you can imagine, equipped with rudimentary minds that are capable of the jobs they are tasked with. What will our purpose as living creatures be, then? When we aren’t needed to work, what will we all do with ourselves? Whither away and die or fritter away our lives with an ever-increasing level of irrelevance, when it comes to making our own way in life?

YouTube – A.I. Movie (The trailer it should have had)

I’ll be impressed when this current crop of AI con artists can create robots and AI that turn that movie into a documentary. Until that point, I’d like to be allowed to own my own words and not have them be stolen by fraudsters in an attempt to make their chatbots more believable. At the very least they should be made to pay me (and all the other creators) for the value of the work they are currently stealing.

Do not fall for this confidence game. The findings that Rebecca Watson mentioned above, that we’re becoming more deluded because of AI, are truly frightening. We are at risk of losing our grip on reality, and it’s only going to get worse if we allow these liars to whisper in our ears about what is or isn’t real.

If we don’t stop these fraudsters we will all one day wake up penniless and alone just like the victims of the first confidence men did all those years ago. However, when we let our own tools lie to us and steal from us and dominate world information markets because we aren’t smart enough to know we are being conned, there will be no where to turn in order to find out what the truth really is.

And still Herbie’s unblinking eyes stared into hers and their dull red seemed to expand into dimly-shining nightmarish globes.

He was speaking, and she felt the cold glass pressing against her lips. She swallowed and shuddered into a certain awareness of her surroundings.

Still Herbie spoke, and there was an agitation in his voice—as if he were hurt and frightened and pleading. The words were beginning to make sense. “This is a dream,” he was saying, “and you mustn’t believe in it. You’ll wake into the real world soon and laugh at yourself. He loves you, I tell you. He does, he does! But not here! Not now! This is all illusion.”

Susan Calvin nodded, her voice a whisper, “Yes! Yes!” She was clutching Herbie’s arm, clinging to it, repeating over and over, “It isn’t true, is it? It isn’t, is it?”

Just how she came to her senses, she never knew—but it was like passing from a world of misty unreality to one of harsh sunlight. She pushed him away from her, pushed hard against that steely arm, and her eyes were wide.

“What are you trying to do?” Her voice rose to a harsh scream. “What are you, trying to do?”

Herbie backed away, “I want to help.”

The psychologist stared, “Help? By telling me this is a dream? By trying to push me into schizophrenia?” A hysterical tenseness seized her, “This is no dream! I wish it were!”

Liar! – Isaac Asimov

Postscript

Ezra Klein has several episodes of his podcast that are informative on this subject. This episode is particularly applicable for people who are experimenting seriously with these chatbots:

YouTube – How Should I Be Using A.I. Right Now? (full transcript – archive.org)

Ethan Mollick’s newsletter One Useful Thing and new book, Co-Intelligence: Living and Working With A.I. His book recommendations from Ezra’s podcast:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top