There is a Santa Claus but it’s an idea, it’s not a person. Santa Claus is doing good things for people, just because; and so long as you keep doing that throughout the rest of your life, there will always be a Santa Claus.
Rebecca Watson relating her father’s words in SGU#74 (My Skepchick Santa playlist)
Fostering hope and wonder in children is important. It’s hard to understate how important this is in the early mental development of a child. Parents need to understand this need that children have. This need to have things be more than just the bare capitalist concretes around us all day and every day. This mindless, soul-crushing consumerism.
It seems odd to start a defense of Santa Claus, one of the most profitable vehicles of consumerism, with a denouncement of the very consumerism that puts Santa Claus front and center for our children each and every year. The need to ask Santa for new stuff to play with.
It may seem odd, but I mean this sincerely. The real magic in the hope and wonder of Santa Claus is provided by parents and their belief in the goals I mentioned above. It’s not the exact gifts that the children ask for that is important to this process, it’s the wonder of things appearing in the house without a visible actor to deliver them.
I’ve lost count of the number of people who have specifically targeted Santa Claus in their personal lives, trumpeting raising children without fostering a belief in imaginary beings. I couldn’t disagree more. Not today, after raising my children the way I have. After my experiences over the last 35 years.
I need a reason to celebrate during these dark, miserable months. If I have to make one up, then that’s what I’ll do. An imaginary being that’s specifically crafted to be seen as imaginary by anyone who doesn’t want to believe is just what the doctor ordered. Just what the doctor ordered to foster wonder in children and curiosity about how the magic happens.
In this household we celebrate the secularized solstice holiday refered to as Christmas on the official US calendar. It’s a non-religious holiday that involves a jolly fat guy who delivers presents dressed in a red suit. We spend the holiday with family and friends, giving gifts and trying to brighten the winter.
Winter in central Texas is a frame of mind more than anything else; it certainly doesn’t have much to do with the weather. Wet and chilly is about as wintery as it usually gets around here. There is no trapped for a month by a blizzard in Central Texas. Power going out and leaving us a hair’s breadth away from being trapped in a state without electricity for months? Sure. Blizzards? Not in my lifetime.
I also spend time reflecting on what the passing of this year means to me and preparing to celebrate the New Year. This time of year always finds me reserved. I can’t tell if it’s seasonal affective disorder or just family trauma that makes me so contemplative, but this attitude manifests for me every year around Christmastime. I have to fight like hell just to get out of bed and do anything for most of the month of December.
This makes playing Santa something that I find quite challenging. I didn’t even want to start doing this, but The Wife and her family talked me into it.
We discussed whether or not to share the myth of Santa Claus with our children long before they were born. I wanted to burst that bubble hard and fast. My history made me hate Santa Claus. Her history made her love him.
My Mother and Father did Christmas to the hilt in the beginning. Large tree, Santa decorations, pictures with Santa, the works.
Once, when we were staying at our grandfather’s house in Sacramento, my sister and I heard a noise in the living room just before we fell asleep on Christmas Eve. It was all a new experience, so we were very excited and on edge. We’d never been to Sacramento before. We’d heard of these near-mystical people, my mother’s parents, for years. We’d never met them before that night.
Marie, my maternal Grandmother, didn’t seem at all like a Wicked Witch of the West, the moniker I had hung on her after hearing my Mother’s stories about her. She did seem a little predatory, though. Maybe that was just childish paranoia from being in a strange place. It’s hard to say for sure. I never did trust her, and that didn’t help with the command to go to bed and get to sleep.
It’s hard to sleep in a strange place. We tossed and turned for what seemed like hours. Then we heard the noise. We looked at each other in a panic. Could it be Santa?
We agreed to go look together, so we crept out of bed and over to the door of the bedroom. Easing the door open we slowly started to creep down the hall towards the living room. We had nearly made it to the living room door before our fear of being discovered and not getting any presents sent us scurrying back down the hallway to fly into bed and under our covers, cowering in fear, where we finally fell back to sleep.
When we awoke the next morning, there were snow footprints on the fireplace hearth. Evidence of the man himself coming down the chimney. It was amazing!
That was the best year. The next to worst year was the year when we were particularly nasty to Mom and Dad and got switches (sticks that your parents beat your butt with, for the uninitiated) in our stockings instead of candy. We bawled our eyes out that year.
Why was that the next to worst year? Because the worst year was the year when we found out that there was no Santa, and suddenly the magic was gone from the holiday. Santa never came to our house again.
Not too long after that, there was the divorce and the hardship of an all too real nature as the family was torn apart, and there was no more talk of silly little things like Santa Claus.
So, no Santa Claus for my children. That’s what I wanted. No hopes and dreams to be dashed to pieces as they grew into adulthood. Just solid, predictable reality from the beginning.
For her part, The Wife never experienced an end to the Santa myth. Even after she knew there was no physical person named Santa Claus that visited her house on Christmas eve, the presents from Santa still showed up. The stockings still were filled, even for Mom and Dad. It wasn’t until I met and married her that there was any magic during the holidays for me, and then there was magic in my life only because of her.
We stayed with her parents one Christmas early in our relationship, before we even admitted to them that we were sleeping together, let alone married. We slept in separate rooms.
Her parents had been born a generation before my parents. They grew up during the Great Depression. Bunk (her father) had shot and cleaned game and sold it to local families in order to help put himself through college. Her mother, Christine, was the most militant housekeeper I had ever met, as well as being a business teacher, a mother and an excellent cook. It was all a new experience for me.
This included a Christmas morning ritual featuring paper bags that had mysteriously appeared on the fireplace mantle during the night. Paper bags filled with apples, nuts and oranges. “Where did the bags come from?” I asked. Santa, I was told.
Okay. Santa it was then.
“Didn’t you have Santa when you were young?” Christine asked me.
“When I was a child, sure.” I said. “I haven’t heard the name Santa Claus in years now.”
“Oh, that’s too bad.” She said, sadly.
Christmas dinner was a spread of food that could feed an army. Most importantly (for me) it featured the most amazing home-made pecan pie on the face of the planet for dessert. When they sent us home they gave us two bags of frozen beef to bring home with us, as they did every year that we went to visit them on their farm. One of the benefits of marrying into a family of cattle ranchers.
That was Christmas with The Wife’s family. Every year, without fail. Paper bags filled with fruit and nuts and candy for everyone and presents for the children when they arrived on the scene. It was beautiful. I was hooked.
They presented an argument that I couldn’t defeat. That there was something good in nurturing a sense of wonder in the children. That the children were going to have hopes and dreams whether we fed them the Santa myth or not. They were going to be exposed to it whether we wanted them to be exposed or not, and so why not let them believe for as long as they wanted to believe?
We set the story this way; Santa Claus isn’t a person beyond the iconic representation of the spirit that anyone can briefly inhabit. Santa Claus is instead the charitable spirit that lives inside all of us. That the giving (and receiving) doesn’t have to end at all. It doesn’t have to be limited to just Christmas Day. It can be all-year ’round if we and they wanted it to be. We just had to be dedicated to fostering the sharing of the myth. The children could decide what they wanted to believe, and we would give them the tools to figure out the truth when it was time.
We would say Santa Claus comes to our house without lying because we believed in the spirit ourselves. We could do it without accepting the pageantry that surrounds the Santa Claus myth. The different people in Santa suits. The silly ideas about how he gets into the house in the first place. Most of all, no need to indulge in the consumerist drive to buy! Buy! Buy! The children told us what they wanted for Christmas, or they wrote what they wanted down for Santa to find on Christmas day. Sometimes they got what they wanted, sometimes they didn’t. Even Santa is not made of money, a fact that we were careful to advise them of.
Let them watch the shows, buy into the lore, do the whole thing if they wanted. If they asked us “is Santa real?” We had a simple non-committal answer to give them. The answer itself was a clue to the puzzle, but they had to want to solve the puzzle in order to find the truth.
Santa Claus is the Spirit of Giving, an anonymous benefactor who gives out of the kindness of his heart and doesn’t seek to be recognized for his charity. He leaves presents that are from no one, and fills stockings for the people sleeping under our roof, no matter the age. His is a kindly old soul that doesn’t get recognized enough these days.
Our children are both out of college now. They have both figured out that spirit meant exactly what we intended it to mean, a giving feeling that comes from within themselves. I know that they have figured it out because gifts appear under the tree or in the stockings that The Wife and I have never seen before. Santa Claus lives on in my house and still visits every year on Christmas Eve; and I, for one, am grateful that he still shows up. We all need reasons to hope for better times these days.
You think I’m crazy, right?
The Wiki entry on Santa Claus clearly says he’s based on St. Nicholas. St. Nicholas gave his gifts personally. He was a real person and he is really, very dead now. Or maybe he’s the mythological figure, Father Christmas, and that as a mythological figure he never really existed at all. That’s what you think, right? Something like that?
It’s all fine by me, I love a good story. Red Ranger Came Calling is an excellent story about Santa Claus, and it’s just about as true as any of the rest of the stories are, including the Wiki page on St. Nicholas.
You just go right on believing whatever suits you. I’m happy for you. Move along now.
I know Santa will visit this house on Christmas Eve, no matter what anybody else believes or insists on telling me about. It is a game that we are playing, the same game that it has always been. A game shared by adults and children down through the years whether they knew it or not. It can be a fun game or a hurtful one, but it is a game all the same. I recognize the thought patterns around the rituals we practice while playing the game.
As an inveterate gamer myself, this game is one I’ve come to enjoy now that I finally understand it. It can be a valuable teaching tool when used correctly and it can be a crushing blow to hopes and dreams when used incorrectly. So play the game wisely, always with the knowledge that a game should be fun. If it isn’t fun and you have a choice, why play at all?
Version published in 2016 – Featured image: infobae.com/la-magia-de-papa-noel


I’m biased and don’t care. I still love this story. It’s been 35 years in the making.