Existence Exists

Philosophy Religion Skepticism Television

When I scrolled through the (purposefully nameless) forum on Facebook earlier today I noticed this image. It offended me at the time but I recognized it as an accurate quotation from Star Trek (the Only Trek) and so I “scrolled on by” as I have taken to doing these days. Its pointless to kick up a fuss about piddling bullshit on even the worlds largest collection of active living humans, which is Facebook. I thought to myself at the time though, “this isn’t going to end well.”

Sure enough, the comment thread under it was shortly locked. The tyrannically controlled forums that the internet has fostered has no room for deep discussions of philosophy or ethics, the kinds of things that Gene Roddenberry desperately thought we needed to discuss when he created most of the television that he did.

…and then someone created another thread lamenting how the comments under the meme image had to be locked. The first comment that I read on that thread proved that this thread was also shortly doomed to be either locked or deleted, but I felt the need to clarify the thinking of the writer of that comment. The important point that I wanted to clarify was his statement that there obviously had to be a creator god.

There is no obvious existence of god. There is only the presumption that there is a creator for all of existence. The philosophical expression of this problem is that existence exists or A=A. If existence didn’t exist there would be no one to ask “Why?” in the first place. It is the only tolerable tautology or self-referential argument that I’ve ever encountered, because there is no counter-argument aside from there being a creator/god, which leads to the “turtles all the way down” illusion for which to justify existence.

As a freethinker I couldn’t care less if you harbor a secret belief in all-powerful creator beings. Your belief doesn’t affect me so long as you don’t attempt to make me believe the way you do. This is a stance that both Gene Roddenberry and I share, a willingness to use the myth of the creator being for the purpose of furthering storytelling (Ko-Fi) while not actually believing in any gods ourselves. It is too useful a concept to simply leave laying there when trying to tell a story that involves science so advanced that it is indistinguishable from magic.

Some people took in that thread umbrage to the fact that I called their creator being a myth. Allow me elaborate on that statement. If you pray to a creator god (as about half of the population of the earth does) you are engaging in a myth. When I used the word myth I was speaking off-handedly of the kinds of stories one might tell about gods. Prayer-answering gods. I’m sorry if that offends you, but it remains a truthful observation in any case.

If you were a Spinozan (like Albert Einstein) I would bow to the internal logic that those beliefs represent and have to concede that I overstepped my jurisdiction in using that particular word. That god isn’t a myth, but those kinds of gods also aren’t very useful in storytelling.

This observation that the unmoved-mover, the universe-as-god, can’t be proven to exist or not exist doesn’t change the fact that there are no gods listening to and answering prayers. That particular kind of god is a myth. The universe existing as it does negates the possibility of prayer-answering gods.

In that particular Star Trek episode Gene was required by the powers that be of the time to face-save by putting in “we find the one to be quite adequate.” when, if he had been free to say what he really thought or believed, he might well have used the mantra of many who came before him “no gods, no masters.”

This particular quote is a lot like many of the other cringe-worthy moments in the series where the censors would require that language be softened or that accommodations be made for the consumers and advertisers of the time. I, for one, am glad to be free of their mind control.

facebook – The thread (and eventually the entire forum, probably) was deleted.

Postscript

I copied the text from this article and posted it to another Facebook forum, this one I will name. It was called Atheism United. Right before I did that I got involved in a little bit of a disagreement with a moderator there that I had crossed previously. He is an antitheist. Proudly antitheist. The problem with antitheists is that they generally have an internalized belief system set up around the idea of gods that rules out the possibility that theists can be completely logical and still believe in god.

This article with it’s nuanced explanation of why theists can be rational on the subject of god (but generally aren’t) was a step too far and they banned me from the group for daring to suggest that you can believe in god without engaging in magical thinking. So Atheism United is a little bit misnamed. So is their moderation team which is ironically named the “Rational Response Squad” that banned my personal profile for simply asking why my page had suddenly been banned from the group. Clearly there are atheists and then there are atheists and I’m not a member of whichever group they accept as atheists. I’m also pretty sure I’m better off. It’s amazing how many of the atheist groups I seem to get kicked out of for not being enough of an atheist to suit them.

One thought on “Existence Exists”

  1. Existence Exists. The point of God or gods is faith in something stronger than yourself; and, well, acknowledging the strength of those stronger than myself, people and things that are trying to make me do something I don’t want to do, has never worked. I will not back down from bullies. All things more powerful than you have the ability to be bullies or protectors but which is it? Such is the eternal debate. Our brains are hard wired towards this belief in the external forces of the universe for reasons we can not yet understand.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top