I’ve just completed playthroughs of both of the Horizon games. I played the first game Horizon: Zero Dawn several years ago on our Playstation 4 system. I was put off by the plastic-y looking child Aloy, who is the eyes that we see all of the Horizon world through. That was the one thing that I remembered about the first game most clearly, the fact that I had to push to make myself keep playing even though her face made my skin crawl. Once you get out of the introduction of the game, the plastic-y feel is limited only to the dialog scenes where you have to interact with other characters. None of the character interactions feel natural or fluid in the first game except those with Sylens (for some reason) A chaotic neutral character if there ever was one and Aloy’s guide through the latter half of the first game. This is easy to understand if you know how games are put together in the first place.
This game, like a lot of the more popular games these days, tries to be a movie or a real experience that you might have out in the world. Each one of them succeeds or fails on varying metrics, but I try not to be too harsh a critic given the heroic effort on the part of at least a thousand people that goes into making any one game. Horizon is one of the better games that I’ve played over the last few years. I was glad of the chance to have experienced the world of the game once I had finished it, and I looked forward to the new installments that might follow it.
When the Wife gifted us with a Playstation 5 last Christmas that came with Horizon: Forbidden West bundled with it, I was ecstatic. I was busy playing World of Warcraft: Dragonflight by that point in time. When May rolled around and Blizzard decided that we needed to talk to moles for the next six months, I remembered I had games I really wanted to play just gathering dust next to the Playstation 5 that we were only using to watch Netflix on. Time to properly utilize that investment.
Sequels are always problematic. Always problematic. Every time I watch a sequel movie or play a sequel game I’m unimpressed with something. The reason why this is true for me, I suspect, is that my headcanon is better than the writers or game developers storytelling ability. I had developed a theory about the Horizon world based on the stalactites and stalagmites all over the ancient ruins in the first game. A theory that the ancient world was perhaps millions of years (not just a thousand years) in the past. This would allow for the development of the sedimentary features visible all over the game while you are playing it.
I had formed several theories about who the people were that might have destroyed Gaia (an AI that our protagonist Aloy is related to in some mysterious way which is revealed in the first game) while I was playing and replaying HZD. Their alien culture and why they might want to end the processes that had finally begun restoring humanity to the planet. How they related to the space debris that created the blue light in the areas of HZD that introduced the Banuk tribe, before the Frozen Wilds DLC expansion of the game.
They were too Machiavellian by half (at least) these fantasies that I had spun out in my head about who and what did this or that to the world. After Ted Faro’s final act, revealed at the end of the first game. How the next story might progress from the known end point of the previous game. My headcanon fantasies were there though and there’s no getting around the fact that I had grand expectations for the next game if it ever saw the light of day.
The ancient world is now established to have been just a thousand years in the past; and the story develops along the lines that it does in the second game after that early confirmation of number of years passed since the fall of our world and the rise of the new one. The one thing revealed by Aloy’s interrogation of Hades (a subroutine of Gaia and the main antagonist for the first game) right before the introduction of the antagonists for HFW (about two hours into regular gameplay) the revelation that Hades had been purposefully deployed four times before the interference that released him the fifth time, was the one thing that I knew had to be true for the time lapse to have been even the thousand years that the first game conjectured.
If you’ve played HZD and watched all the way to the end, then you know that Sylens captures a copy of Hades. The developers even went to the extreme level of detail to put the Horus that is visible in the background of the cookie at the end of HZD overhead in HFW when you start on the trail of Hades and Sylens. Nearly every significant feature of HFW is mentioned in HZD in some passing fashion, if not realized along the exact same lines as the hints might suggest in HZD. It’s all there, like it or not. I know this because I had to go back and play the game again just to make sure that the story in HFW wasn’t some unexpected tangential exposition on ideas I’d never noticed before. It’s all there and my confusion was my headcanon getting in the way of just enjoying the game I was playing.
This all means that the stalagtite/stalagmite looking growths that give the ancient areas so much atmosphere in the game are therefore probably not sedimentary, they are more like the rusticles hanging all over the Titanic in its watery grave, a byproduct of the metal weathering process. If they are still supposed to be sedimentary then the features the programmers put in for atmospheric effect are jarringly out of place because a thousand years simply isn’t long enough for them to form. If you formed any ideas about the world of the first game or movie in the series you are choosing to consume (and who doesn’t do that?) then you are likely to be disappointed in the expression of the actual developed story when you are experiencing it.
The world you experience as you consume the new content will be hauntingly familiar and real, just like the puppet-like appearance of the child Aloy in the introduction of HZD. It’s off-putting and uncomfortable (for me anyway) but if you push through the hesitancy and just try to get into the role you have to play, it’s a perfectly enjoyable and playable game and even still an engrossing story. It’s worth the time investment just to know how the story progresses, and the game mechanics are as challenging as you want to make them.
Which is one of the things I like most about HFW. Adjustable game difficulty. Being locked into a difficulty level after your initial playthrough in HZD was a deal breaker for me continuing to play beyond my first playthrough. Ultra-hard is too much difficulty for someone who gets lost going to his own bathroom because his internal mapping processes are so poor. Learning the map alone requires me to play through every game once in easy mode; otherwise the map boss (or the elevator boss, etcetera. These deadly game bosses are everywhere for the disabled) the map kills me as frequently as the antagonists in the game do, and I give up in frustration long before the game is over just trying to find my way to a goal; much less enjoy a good fight while getting where I want to go.
Being locked into a particular difficulty mode explains why I didn’t do a replay in game+ after my first playthrough of HZD all those years ago (I might have remembered it better if I had) Playing through a second time on hard mode several years later, the map still kills me as often as the MOBs do. I stuck with it right up until the frost and fire bears of HZD:Frozen Wilds. I went straight into story mode then because I wasn’t in game+ mode. I just want to finish the content and experience the story. Even in story mode it takes ten arrow strikes to kill those ridiculous bears (I’m pretty sure they’re toned down in HFW when you run across them because they don’t seem as deadly. They only killed me two times and I didn’t have to turn the difficulty down just to get through the fight at all) Sometimes I have to turn down the difficulty just so I can get through a particular fight, if the map I’m fighting on gets me killed as often as the fight mechanics do.
I did manage a speed run on Ultra-hard through HZD with my final playthrough. I skipped Frozen Wilds since it isn’t required to unlock the extras that come from finishing the game in game+ mode. I won’t be attempting a full play through of HZD in any mode above normal difficulty if I’m locked into it (not if FULL includes Frozen Wilds. Those bears. Ugg!) I much prefer game+ on HFW which allows me to adjust the difficulty to my comfort level at the moment. Which varies. A lot.
I’m New. What Should I Do First?
Play HZD first if you can. That’s my suggestion. In HFW, once you get out of the hour-long introduction that gives you some of the back story of HZD (not all of it and you’ll be left with a lot of questions about this world) You are sent to Chainscrape, which is at the bottom of a crazy chain/cable car system. You can’t get back up the wall (I have tried many times) and do anything meaningful. The game just resets you if you go beyond the game perimeters (Not as amusing as being sucked into a water vortex in Red Dead Redemption 2) If you are like me you are a tireless explorer, and you will soon discover that you need special tools to fully explore any area of the game. This means doing the main quests up to a particular point in the game. You should try to open up all the map before investing yourself in exploring at any great length, this will save you time and energy. Once you know who the Quen are in the game you can pretty much relax and start exploring.
Story-wise it helps the narrative if you do the three subroutine quests in level order, while doing as many of the rebel camps as it takes to trigger the final “Sons of Prometheus” battle, which should be done before “The Wings of the Ten” quest. Otherwise you have to put the narrative in the correct order yourself (the NPCs say things that will pull you out of the story) I wish I had burned through the main quests and completed the game and saved all the extra stuff for game+ play. You won’t have all the tools to finish stuff until near the end anyway and saving the collection quests for the replay makes sense from that perspective.
Saving the exploration for after at least completing “The Wings of the Ten” quest makes sense for reasons that are clear to anyone who has played through the game already. If I say more than that I will definitely be giving away spoilers.
