A wheelchair bound person expressed their support of the Domain on Reddit a few days ago. I get it. Nearness of things is a selling point. Still, it’s a half-step backwards from what we had in the 1970’s:
What the Domain lacks most is that it is not a mall. If it was a mall, a climate controlled self-contained marketplace with attached residential, then I would not only be it’s biggest fan but I would live there too.
It’s dangerous to be outside in Texas in the summer, just like it’s dangerous to be outside in Northern states during the winter. This is why malls took off all those years ago, because they were a place to go walk around without either frying or freezing to death.
We don’t have that option anymore, and we never had the option to rent living space at the mall on a large scale, the one thing that might have saved them in the end. The one thing that keeps the Domain going, a built-in clientele for all of the shops that are also there.
This was the saving grace of the Dobie Center here in Austin, an indoor mall topped by a 24 story residence hall. It has a built-in clientele that keeps the shops afloat. It has been reconfigured again and again to keep up with the times, which is what the malls that have failed didn’t do. They didn’t add attached condominiums. They didn’t see the death of the department stores and find different anchors to take their place. They didn’t do maintenance and so the people paying top dollar went elsewhere.
This was evident years before the malls closed. Water features that were abandoned and covered over. Air conditioning systems that failed. Plumbing that failed. When the anchor stores were attracted to come out to the new-fangled power centers with their lower overheads, that was the end of the malls surrounded by parking lots. They moved out to the power centers that were surrounded by parking lots. Then the department stores themselves dried up and blew away along with the power centers.
The problem with the Dobie was and is the size of the place. It wasn’t big enough to offer a decent variety of shops. I’ve never seen the kind of thing that I envision done properly with an indoor mall. Highland Mall would have been a perfect place to try this experiment, but ACC bought it and turned it into something else entirely. No attached housing. No shopping anymore, either.
The Domain is just a larger power center. It is the kind of thing we’ve seen attempted and failed before. The original Hancock Center was just another version of the Domain, a version with a sea of parking and no built-in clientele. An open air shopping center that is impossible to navigate in the summer months. The Domain is a half-step backwards from what we had with enclosed malls. Why don’t we try a full step forward instead?
Malls are the future, enclosed arcologies are the future. It’s the only way the human race will survive in the long term. We’ll make the surface of the Earth as uninhabitable as the surface of Venus before we’ll give up our conveniences. I have faith in human nature. Collectively we are as dumb as yeast killing itself with its own waste in a wine barrel. Unless we put the things the average person wants within easy reaching distance without driving, we are as doomed as the yeast are.

