Lightning? Trees? Power?

Daily Beef

June 17 – I have been without electricity for hours now since that minor thunderstorm last night. Austin Energy can’t tell me when my power will be back on and their outage maps are no longer letting us know where crews are working.

This was a minor storm. The kind of storm that generally knocks out power here for a few minutes. I was expecting the power to go out. I wasn’t expecting to die of heat prostration due to advancing age and health issues because the city utility doesn’t have enough crews to keep the power on in Austin, and so it stays off for nearly a day in the middle of a record breaking heat wave.

This is not the kind of service that a premiere American city has been known for in the past. Even my tiny home town in Kansas with it’s one electric crew could do a better job of keeping the power on than Austin Energy does.


When I say that my home town is in Kansas, that is strictly true and mentioned more to illustrate the point of delay than it is to claim some form of immigrant status. I’m from here as far as I’m concerned. I have two children born here that are old enough to vote (and do vote) I lived somewhere else a lifetime ago. Another place and time when people cared about their neighbors and were willing to pay for services that were a benefit to everyone. A place where I knew the sheriff personally, knew the cable guy personally, knew the electric crew, etcetera. A small town where everyone had to pull together to keep things running.

Which was about the only good thing about the place. I’ve got a decent grocery store down the block here and I didn’t have that there. Mel (the grocer) did try to maintain a decent grocery, but there wasn’t much he could do since there was so little demand. Most of the residents went to the nearest larger city to shop rather than stop in at Mel’s, but he was always there if you were desperate for ingredients for something you were trying to cook right then, as long as it wasn’t something foreign you were trying to cook. However, even Mel’s limited selection wouldn’t do me much good if the unrefrigerated food spoils overnight.


I posted some of this to r/Austin at the time of the outage (since transplanted here to the blog and organized into an article. -ed.) after I did that the first commenter who showed up was certain that a tree had fallen on a line and so the power outage wasn’t Austin Energy’s fault but was in fact the fault of NIMBY’s who convinced the city council to tell Austin Energy to stop trimming the trees. When I disagreed with his assumptions I was told that I was stupid to disagree with his assessment and it was stupid to blame Austin Energy for my power being out. So I blocked him. But I did have thoughts about his conclusions on the subject of why my power was out.

These are assumptions. They are assumptions because: a) they don’t know what knocked the power out to my whole block (probably not a tree limb because the one place with tree limbs over wires in the neighborhood is the place that they didn’t go to fix the outage) and b) statistical probability is not the same thing as certain knowledge.

In my twenty-five years of residence at this address I have seen a transformer struck by lightning two times. The same transformer, struck twice. This is proof that lightning can strike the same place twice. I have seen trees fall over and knock down the wires several times. Because of this I have asked the city to please cut down the encroaching trees while they were there working on the transformers and lines (to my knowledge that work was never done) Of the dozen or so other outages I have not a clue as to why the power was off.

I do know that the SNOVID event was not tree related. I know that the ice storm outage of three days earlier this year was blamed on trees (conveniently) but I’ve yet to see any studies proving this is so. We only have the word of the responsible authority that failed to keep the power on during the ice storm that the fault the power was off for three days was because of fallen trees. I do know that Texas and Austin have not been investing sufficient dollars in upgrading and maintaining the electric grid and that the pat answer of “NIMBY trees” is far too easy to throw out when someone complains about their power being out.

Give me the chainsaw, I’ll cut down the trees. It’s just too easy to fix for it to be the real problem. Lack of leadership is the problem. This is just as demonstrable as the statistics about trees. It’s a problem we can fix if we simply get up off our collective asses and make the change in leadership that’s required.


Someone else objected to my characterization of Austin as a premiere American city (proof that satire can’t be seen in plain text by the average human reader) Austin has never really been premiere. It pretends to be up and coming because of the musical acts and other creative influences that were born here; but the truth is that the creative people identified as having their roots here had to leave Austin and Texas in order to become what we think of them as today.

Austin is progressive and Democratic; but what that really means can only be seen by contrasting Austin with the rest of Texas. When you do that work you realize just how provincial the rest of Texas is; and that does not put Austin in a flattering light. We Austinites have to compromise on a regular basis with the anti-gay, anti-trans, anti-poor and just plain white nationalist representatives from the rest of the state who live here and who make laws here for half the year. Which makes Austin a more problematic living experience than the labels progressive and Democratic should warrant.

While Austin has loosened some of the straight laces that bind the rest of Texas, confine it in the lost cause mythos that binds most of the Old South; with the crushing poverty and hatred for minorities that comes with that legacy; the demands of the mythology that govern this region still must be met.

The mythology? That poor people are poor because of personal failings. Failings that can easily be righted by simply working harder. That minorities must keep to their place. Be respectful and speak English in the presence of white people who are their betters. Like New York City in the sixties, you can go to places in Austin where all you see are people of color, and there you will hear them speak their language, but they will be embarrassed if you appear to notice them, and your presence in their place will be objected to. Unless, of course, you have money to spend.

Austin is only a “premiere American city” in that light, when contrasted with the cities of our past. When contrasted with any other American city as it exists today its claim to be premiere, to be up and coming, is more sales pitch than it is reality.

So when I used ‘premiere’ in that sentence, I was speaking tongue-in-cheek. The ancient wooden power poles dotting the landscape speak more truth about Austin than anything you might read in the media. The taxman and the new immigrant believe wholeheartedly in the delusion of Austin, the creative hub of industry, the beacon of weird, the place to be. The rest of us know a sales pitch when we hear it.


However, the vast majority of commenters objected to my characterization of the storm as minor. Apparently it was much more severe, with softball-sized hail, further North of us. I was sorry to hear that people suffered significant damage in the storm. That makes it a major storm from their perspective.

We had pea-sized hail with some decent wind gusts that knocked down a few limbs. I noticed this while out walking this morning hoping to return to a powered home. Hoping in vain. The approximately one-hour length storm featured a pretty nice electric show that took out the power here; but from the perspective of North Central Austin, still a minor storm.

One of the commenters compared it to an F5 tornado. I’ve seen the aftermath of an F5 myself. They wouldn’t be talking to anyone right after an f5 had torn through their neighborhood. They’d still be digging out. I’ve also been through much more impressive light shows. The lightning strike on the transformer behind the house a decade ago was a major feature of one of the more impressive thunderstorms that I’ve seen in Austin.

Even that pales in comparison to almost any thunderstorm that you could watch from your front porch in Oklahoma or Kansas. With your neighbors. And a beer. They only come in off the porch if it looks like the tornado might actually hit the porch that they’re on. The Wife loves to recount watching the C-5’s being tossed around like toys on the Altus Air Force Base back in the 70’s. The locals told the commander to move those planes before the storm hit. He didn’t believe them when they said the tornadoes could pick those planes up and toss them around. He was wrong. Several million dollars wrong.

So you’ll have to forgive me if I minimalize this storm. I’m sure we’ll all have worse memories of worse storms to look back on in the not too distant future. It’s what climate change has in store for us. It’s why we need to change leadership now, so that we can be better prepared for that future.

Postscript

Twelve hours later the power was restored to our home. Storm damaged equipment (not trees and lines) that blacked out a whole section of the neighborhood were to blame. The dozens of haters who were certain that it was tress were wrong, but none of them seemed to notice this fact.

I was notified that a crew had been assigned to our outage about an hour before the power was turned back on; which probably means they replaced a fuse and flipped a switch. It’s almost criminal that it took half a day for that simple task to be completed, but that is life in a big city with tight budget constraints and large demands.

The electrical repair crews do dangerous work when the repairs are more extensive than that. If I had seen them while they were out doing their repairs I would have offered them drinks and sandwiches even after waiting eleven hours to see them in the first place. Those guys are heroes, they aren’t to blame for the budget constraints that keep them always behind in their repair work.

As one of the other commenters noted, the problem wasn’t who or what was responsible for the outage that was the problem. Outages are to be expected. Everyone knows the power goes out and you just have to deal with it. The problem was waiting half a day to get the power back on. Two hours? Sure. Four hours? Annoying but understandable. Twelve hours? Unacceptable unless the entire grid is on the verge of meltdown and they had to pull the plug on the whole thing.

Seems like we’ve seen that happen too many times lately, from where I’m sitting.

I did discover that the administrator of Austin Energy had quietly retired in March during the course of that free-wheeling thread on Reddit (a Reddit that might well soon cease to exist) a quiet retirement was better treatment than she deserved after the debacle of her time at the helm of the city-owned utility.

June 22 – Suicide squirrels took the power out again briefly. I think that is the most common cause of the power going out in the neighborhood. More common than trees, more common than lightning. Squirrels chewing on the power lines and lighting themselves on fire, shorting the transformer in the process and blowing fuses. The repair crew was assigned immediately and the power was back on within the hour. If only that could be restored as the normal expectation when the power goes out, that would be great.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top