Natural and Organic

Economics Science

What is the naturalistic fallacy, sometimes known as the is-ought problem? It is the fallacy that if something is a certain way in nature, that’s the way it ought to be. It is widely beloved of anti-vaxxers, organic food advocates, and natural childbirth advocates among others.

skepticalob.com

Natural and organic are such over-broad terms, when applied to items found on store shelves, That the label itself becomes almost meaningless. Natural and organic can both be poisonous. Natural and organic can both be man-made. There is no purpose behind putting natural and organic labels on items for sale beyond the desire of the marketing team to sell whatever it is they are peddling at a higher price point.

I refuse to pay extra for food that is labeled natural or organic, and that is because there is no thing called natural. There is no test which can be conducted to determine if a thing is natural or not. There are no standards by which something can be deemed to be natural. Something either exists, or it doesn’t, naturally. Slapping a label on the thing that makes the claim that it is natural does not make it more real than the identical thing next to it which doesn’t have the label.  It is a meaningless category, a label which does nothing but sell food at a higher markup.

Herzig said that what people who consistently eat organic foods are purchasing is the emotional satisfaction of knowing they’re taking steps to improve themselves and the environment.

“Is it actually better for you?” she said. “I’d go with no.”

latimes.com

There is no thing called Organic. There are Organic standards which organic food growers are supposed to comply with in order to put the label on their products, but those standards aren’t what most people assume they are. Organic foods are treated with chemicals. The chemicals they use are approved organic chemicals. Organic foods are sprayed with organic approved pesticides, which are generally harsher and less effective than the non-organic approved pesticides. Organic is a meaningless label which the average person perceives means something that the label does not communicate.

These two labels as they pertain to foodstuffs are set out to create a false grouping of foods which are in no discernible way different from other foods which don’t have that label.  Foods which can be shown to be altered, because some person altered them to our mutual benefit. Make no mistake, we have altered all of our foods over the course of the last several thousand years. None of them are natural in the way that the average person thinks of natural, as in found in nature.

AsapSCIENCE – This Is NOT NATURAL – Jul 15, 2015

Postscript

I wrote the bones of this at the same time that I wrote this other article:

2015/05/tiptoeing-through-gender-issues

The Wife convinced me that I needed to separate the two subjects, that I was being overly general when I approached the subject of gender issues as being an issue of false categorization. In hindsight I think she was correct, even though I felt like I was making a huge concession in cutting this portion of the article out for reasons of sensitivity. Human is human. There are no categories of human that should be cleaved off in order to treat those humans differently than the others. There shouldn’t be a grouping called trans. I’m not even convinced there is a grouping that constitutes man or woman that incorporates all the people who want to be in those groups.

She was right because the subject of the natural fallacy is both more general and more specific than gender issues are, and placing the natural fallacy into that specific framework would distract from the fact that the concept of natural is a fiction that we need to shed ourselves of. In the meantime I went on to publish several other posts on the subject,

2017/09/fear-mongering-in-the-anti-gmo-age-we-live-in

…but I never called out the thing that was most important. The fallacy of believing anything to be natural. This article fixes that oversight.

Now let’s talk some more about organic. You can’t ruin an organic crop by overspraying pesticides.

The Salt – Pesticide Drift Threatens Organic Farms – July 31, 2015

If by ruin you mean protect with fewer, less harsh chemicals; then yeah, they’re ruined. In the context of the audio program, they propagated the lie that organic crops are not sprayed with pesticides and that consequently spraying them with commercial pesticides destroyed them. This is not the case.

It is true that they cannot be sold as organic foods because the pesticides sprayed were not among the (more dangerous, used more often) list of organically approved pesticides, but the food is every bit as edible as it was before being sprayed.

It is true that you can kill grapes with a broadleaf herbicide or if someone has some kind of chemical sensitivity that precludes herbicide treatment of their foods then they can’t eat that food (I have to wonder how anyone that sensitive manages to still be breathing even ten years after developing said allergy. Ever heard of PFAS in the drinking water?) So yeah, okay, you got me there.

Outside of those special pleadings, though? You got any evidence for me? No? Of course not.

The problem here isn’t the one the story purports to be about. The difference in value at market is the only damage rendered; and that value is mostly based on people who falsely believe that organic food is better for you.

facebook

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top