I had a request the other day to elaborate on how I would define inalienable rights without including god as the architect. This is a summation of what I’ve posted before on the subject.
Simply put, You exist. You exist as a individual, capable of sustaining your own life. The requirements for you life to continue can be conceptualized into ‘rights’ that you possess as a living, thinking being. You have the right to continue in your life, since you are capable of sustaining it barring intervention by others. This right is secured by the rational capacity of the individual, linked to the corporeal existence/free will of the individual, which manifests as actions in ‘self defense’.
Your ‘right to life’ leads to corollary rights. Existence is measured in time, and time (spent wisely) yields game/crops/shelter or property. You have a right to (justly acquired) property because your continued existence (your right to life) depends on being able to dispose of your property (the manifestation of productive life) as you see fit. Following this type of chain, you can produce several rights that a person should reasonably expect to be allowed to exercise. Liberty is the corollary right that allowing falls under, since there would be no question of the free exercise of your rights if you did not have others with equal rights to contend with.
Since we all equally exist, we should all have equal rights. The rights are inseparable because they stem from what we are. A prisoner has rights. Not because we allow them; but because his free will enables them. The fact that there are prison breaks is merely proof that the prisoners maintain their rights in spite of the full force of gov’t and the people being intent on denying them the exercise of same. The unjustified killing of a person is therefore a destruction of a value equal to your own, and should be dealt with harshly by those who value the rights they possess.
That’s about as far as I’ve taken it. Much more to be written.
Postscript
This was originally posted on the Objectivist Google group in 2004. When I first started writing a blog I was obsessed with collecting every little thing I ever wrote and placing it somewhere on it as some kind of example of the wide range of thought that I had engaged in previously. I wasn’t just one of those other pretend bloggers doing something that was trendy. I really wanted to write and to think and to express my thoughts.
May years later (2025) and I’m one of the few remaining bloggers out there. Blogging really is a public diary and not some excuse to go around modeling new things for other people to buy from you. Your thoughts, published as they come to you, written where anyone can see them if they know where to look. It’s a special kind of weirdness, actually.
I haven’t updated the page for quite some time, but if you go to Emergent Principles of Human Nature you will discover that my mental obsession with this topic did produce some fruit. Fruit of questionable value probably, but something at least. There will probably be more in the future, too.
