She has an illusion, and you have reality. May you find your way as pleasant.
The Keeper – Star Trek, The Cage
“Why was Talos IV declared off-limits with an unprecedented death penalty punishment? Why was Vina left to the Talosians and not instead brought aboard the Enterprise and healed? Why doesn’t this ending make sense to me?” That was the essence of the question that I read in the Facebook post.
Okay. Technically The Cage was a separate Star Trek show, the pilot for a different show than the one we ended up with. Who knows if there would have been a ban on going back to Talos IV if the original pilot was allowed to become the foundation of the original show? Only Gene Roddenberry knows and he doesn’t say how that separate canon might have progressed.
The Menagerie is the version that is actually part of the show that we got. In that version of the story, the ban is a just a device to make the errand that Spock is on seem to be more fraught than it really was, and the ban was rescinded to allow the completion of the errand anyway. It’s a McGuffin. Make up your own explanation for why that is, it’s as valid as mine would be.
In The Menagerie we see that Pike is also disfigured and he has to be taken back to Talos IV in order to complete his life in happiness, making the parting comment by the Talosians extremely ironic (Gene did love ironic endings) even a hundred years into that universes future, in The Next Generation series, they still haven’t found treatments for blindness or paralysis that didn’t require technological appliances.
This highlights the problem with trying to make sense of 1960’s or even 1980’s television through the eyes of someone in 2025. The problem is perspective and context. In the context of the sixties they had barely started with what we now accept as modern medicine. Penicillin had only been in use for about twenty years by that point. Gene had no idea that medical advances would move as fast as they have.
Which is why, in the later Next Generation movies, Geordi La Forge has implanted eyes instead of a visor. it made sense that we had progressed that far in a few hundred years. Even that doesn’t quite fit in with what we know about medicine and gene manipulation now. By that time a simple injection of genetic material will probably be all that is required to heal blindness, deafness and paralysis. It’s really hard to say how far medicine will advance, or even if it will advance at all into the post-apocalyptic future that seems to loom on our 2025 horizon.
The show is a part of the context of it’s time. It can’t escape that context anymore than Shakespeare can escape the 1600’s; and as a fan of the show it pays benefits to understand that context before attempting to criticize the show for it’s failings.
facebook – Featured image was part of several episodes of Star Trek.
