The garage was canted over at an angle, it’s walls tipped over to a perilous degree. It would look like a fun house building in a theme park if it had been painted anytime in the last thirty years, which it hadn’t. The house next door looked every bit as ramshackled as the garage. There couldn’t be anyone living there, surely?
There was a single pane of glass in the garage door, among the line of empty gap-toothed openings next to it, so I picked up a rock, contemplating the pleasing sound of shattering glass.
“We’ll get in trouble,” my friend said.
“It’s an abandoned building,” I said. “No one’s going to care.”
“You think so?” He was still querulous at the prospect of doing property damage.
“Come on, it’ll be fun,” I said.
So we pelted the door with rocks from the road until we managed to hit the pane of glass, which shattered with exactly the kind of sound that I thought it would make.
It was glorious. Until…
The old lady came belting out of the front door of the house that I would have sworn was abandoned, waving a stick at us and screaming like a banshee. My friend and I, terrified of her as much as at being caught doing a thing that we knew was wrong, ran away as fast as we could and didn’t go home until late in the evening for fear of leading the old lady to our houses where she could confront our parents with what we had done.
When I finally did go home, there was a policeman standing on our porch talking to my father. It was a small town, so of course the old lady knew who our parents were. I was informed that if I wanted to avoid criminal charges I was going to have to replace the window, which meant that I would have to go to work for my father to earn the money necessary to buy the window pane and have it installed.
Which I did. Not only did I work to earn the money back for her one window, we bought four window panes to replace the other broken ones that children had broken in the months before. If I remember correctly the carpenter even straightened the walls up and made the garage look like it wasn’t going to fall down; but they still didn’t paint it, which is what it really needed.
I was a criminal. I was caught. I made retribution. The injured person was made whole and better than she had been before. This is because I wasn’t shot for trespassing and damaging property.
Someone had their car broken into in a Dallas parking lot recently. More than one person has had this happen recently in Dallas, I’m sure. The victim was cynical about the Dallas police force ever doing anything to find the missing items from his car. Probably rightly cynical, who knows? A stolen briefcase isn’t going to be high on the Dallas police radar. They have real problems to deal with and not enough hands to get the real work done. Stolen property is pretty low-down on the importance list.
The conversation about the outrage of having someone steal shit out of your car turned to shooting criminals in a very short order, as these things do in the here and now. In Texas the property laws favor the property owners to a ridiculous level. At night, even in a public parking lot, you can shoot someone who is breaking into your car. On your property you can shoot people if you feel even vaguely threatened.
I know, because I’ve been following these stories for a long time.
“That’s OK. Property’s not worth killing someone over, OK?” the operator said. “Don’t go out of the house. Don’t be shooting nobody.”
archive.org/www.dallasnews.com
At about the same time in history, there was a guy in Austin that was shot while standing in someone’s yard. While it was surmised later that he had been burglarizing the homeowners vehicle, we only have the word of the homeowner that this was the case. Dead man in front yard, homeowner no-billed. Over and over again, this situation occurs. It is an endless repetition. Property owners taking the law into their own hands and turning themselves into murderers in the process.
I can’t find that particular news story when I search for it these days (here are four other cases from the right time period) because there has been so much shooting going on lately that there isn’t any way to find a particular incident from fifteen years ago that didn’t get national attention. It was only reported in the Austin American-Statesman or the Austin Chronicle and their archives aren’t easy to access and search.
My original take in the Joe Horn case amounted to don’t burglarize homes. While my discomfort with that position has grown since that time, I see no other logical or emotional position to take. Stay off other people’s property unless invited. It’s pretty simple. In Texas you will likely get shot if you don’t follow those rules and it’s even possible to get shot if you do follow them.
Life is not black and white. Good and bad. Crime and justice. Life is full of grey encounters that only look black and white from the outside. I’m reminded of several grey encounters in my front yard over the thirty years I’ve lived at this address.
Encounters like the time I had guests over to watch a movie and someone had gone through all the unlocked vehicles in the driveway while we were sitting scant feet away next to a window looking out on the location where the cars were parked. The thieves are lucky that none of us looked over our shoulders out the window while they were engaged in their criminal activity. Everything but the loose cash in the cars was eventually recovered, but the violation of our personal space lingered and festered. We never leave doors or cars unlocked anymore, but that still doesn’t stop people from walking off with stuff that isn’t tied down.
Encounters like the time that I threatened a trespasser with a baseball bat, a trespasser that turned out to be suffering form a mental illness and so didn’t understand the threats that I was making. She clearly didn’t understand because she came back an hour later to ring the doorbell again. Because of our complaints about her she was shifted to a different halfway house, somewhere that is too far for her to come all the way back over here to bother the children at the school across the street or bother the adults along our street who don’t want to have to answer the doorbell ten times a day just because she wants someone to talk to.
What she needed is care and proper treatment, not verbal abuse by someone with a baseball bat; or being shot, an occurrence which will probably happen sometime in her future if she continues wandering up on other people’s property ten times a day.
Or the time I heard something in my front yard and opened the door to find two boys, one of which had broken a window that faced on the driveway and had his arm up to the shoulder inside of my house rummaging around for something to steal. I was so flabbergasted by the sight that I didn’t even think to say anything for a few beats.
If I had been an armaphile that never goes anywhere without their fetish equipment, I would have shot both of them on my driveway right then and there and been perfectly justified in doing so. I would have been praised and feted by other armaphiles for standing my ground and defending my property; but in my heart I would know I was a murderer, just as Joe Horn knows that about himself. I would carry that guilt to the end of my days.
What I did instead was yell incredulously “What the fuck do you think you’re doing!?!”
They somehow hadn’t heard the door open. The one with his arm in the house yanked it back out again, probably tearing a slice all the way down his arm in the process. Then they both bolted across the slippery yard, one of them face-planting and getting back up on his feet and running again without missing a beat. By the time my crippled old ass made it to the corner of the fence the two hoodlums were well out of sight.
I can laugh at it now, but I was furious at the time. The cop that showed up after I called them tried to get me to say that they had been black or Hispanic boys, but I had no idea about their appearance aside from sneakers, jeans and t-shirts, tans and straight black hair. I knew what their backsides looked like and that was about it. They were poor and desperate and hoping to find something to sell inside that window.
There’s nothing worth selling anywhere in the house. I know this because I would sell it myself if there was anything to sell. I can’t afford to lose anything and yet I am still happy that I didn’t think to arm myself before going out on my porch. The baseball bat encounter still haunts me. It didn’t help the situation that I had a weapon with me; and using the weapon on her wouldn’t have made any more impression on her than my verbal threats did. She had been beaten enough before I ever met her. Nothing I did short of killing her was ever going to make an impression in the time I had to devote to the issue.
Desperate people do desperate things. We can kill poor people and homeless people all day, every day for the rest of our lives and we will never be free of the press of desperate people if we don’t address the underlying problems that create poor and desperate people in our midst. Wanting these people to die quietly and out of sight is not a viable option to the problems that confront us, and dying quietly and out of sight is what we are asking these people to do right now.
Housing is unaffordable for a vast swath of the US population. I barely manage to keep the lights on and the roof over our heads, and I’m only able to do that by scrimping on food, clothing and maintenance costs. Homelessness is the future for everyone who is not independently wealthy if we do not alter our trajectory by modifying our economic system.
Being homeless is to be expendable. You have no address for subsistence checks to be sent to. You have no collateral with which to pay for emergency expenditures. You live by what you can beg, borrow or steal and you will do all of those things in that order as your needs grow more desperate. These people are not teenagers breaking windows on a lark, they are hungry with no place to go and they are just looking for a way to get from today to tomorrow.
If you don’t want to shoot people, if you don’t want to become a murderer like Joe Horn and thousands of others are today, the living victims of their own justifiable homicides, then you are going to have to get behind changes in the system that will make poverty and homelessness a thing that we read about in history books and not a thing that we see on our city streets. It really is that simple.
When I think back to that childhood experience with vandalism and restitution, I thank my lucky stars that I lived in a small town where everyone knew each other. That the little old lady only had a stick to threaten us with and not a gun to end our lives with. We were just screwing around, not understanding the repercussions of our actions. The cost of our actions was spelled out to us over the following months as we worked off our debt and were thanked by the little old lady for making it possible for her to fix her garage, a lesson that we were only able to learn because we lived through it and weren’t shot for our transgression.
Imagine the lessons we could teach the poor and the homeless if we simply admitted that we knew them and knew of their plight? Knew them as fellow human beings and not treated them like vermin that were only good for slaughtering. Imagine what that might be like.
