There are bad SCOTUS cases lately. Tons of them. Moore V. Harper was Trumped up to be one of those really bad cases on every media outlet out there (except for the select few that I rely on, apparently) Kennedy v. Bremerton on the other hand sank without a trace under the onslaught of outrage after outrage that has occurred since Trump took office and then was kicked out of office.
This is a condensed version of some back and forth between me and a few redditors who thought they knew what they were talking about. (I do not exclude myself from the diminutive Moron status here. However, Moore v. Harper was at least decided based on history and precedent. The same cannot be said for Kennedy v. Bremerton) Unsurprisingly, a good number of these comments disappeared down the Reddit moderator hole.
How the end of Roe and the Uvalde school shooting could reshape the race for Texas governor
This election is very likely to be the last election where your vote will truly matter.
A year from now, the Supreme Court will have ruled on a case they already decided to hear, Moore v. Harper. We all now know the Supreme Court is nothing more than another weapon of the Republican Party. They will say that the Constitution gives state legislatures the sole power to decide elections. Republicans have already gerrymandered Texas to ensure people of color don’t have a real voice in the legislature. They have already made it harder for people to vote. Of course they will say that it’s perfectly okay to ignore the will of the voters because the Supreme Court said it is okay. They will just pick their own “winners” of any and all elections going forward.
This is the last chance you have to get everyone you know registered and voting. After next year, their coup will be complete.
Moore v. Harper will only affect votes for the President and Vice President, it can’t change any other vote outcome because none of the other elections are constrained the way that presidential elections are. It’s bad enough if this farcical argument is given teeth by a rigged SCOTUS, but it’s important not to lose sight of the reality here. It’s just the Presidency and Americans are already too centered on the importance of the Presidency.
I’m beginning to understand and agree with the founders that didn’t want there to be a chief executive. The office attracts power that wasn’t given to it, that its holder then ill-uses. Better to not have the office than to tempt fate with a single person vested with power and the expectations of millions who want their beliefs vindicated by their leader.
There are ways out of our predicament, but those ways require us to take back the Red states from the Christianists that run them now and keep them from making inroads in the blue states. This is true whether we need them to select our president for us, or not.
It is more than just the presidential elections. The case is whether a state court can tell the legislature that their gerrymandered maps are unconstitutional.
With the way Republicans have been acting, I now take the worst case scenario and assume that is what they’ll do. There was a literal coup attempt that they are still trying to excuse and justify. There is no morality or shame left in the Republican Party. They will see our country and system of governance destroyed before they give up any amount of power.
Again. The maps can skew outcomes but they can’t change votes. They can’t throw out elections and dictate who will be in their own political bodies. We can be present at counting. We can observe polling places. We can help ensure that votes are counted accurately even when the maps are screwed up. They will lose this election. They will lose it if only the people who don’t want to be ruled by Republicans show up and vote the bastards out.
The media thinks they know what will happen in November. They no more know what will happen than you or I do. There has not been a time in history quite like this one, not at least since 1860, or more likely 1858. I look forward to laughing at these same stupid pundits who will try to explain what happened after it happens in November. If only the people who want an end to this GOP travesty, this GOP treason, get out and vote and not stay home moaning about how they can’t change anything, we might even have the last laugh.
“They can’t throw out elections and dictate who will be in their own political bodies.”
I understand what you are trying to say.
What I am saying is that they will definitely take this victory and expand it to mean exactly this, that the legislatures get to pick the winners. The Constitution does not explicitly say that whoever gets the most votes wins. They will use that, because they are not making their arguments in good faith. They are temporary excuses until they can abuse their power.
I don’t know what the future brings. But looking at their recent patterns, I am very confident in predicting the lowest possible bar for them.
I put the again at the start of that comment for a reason. You don’t understand the arguments being made. The argument is about the presidential race. That’s it. That is the only argument that can be made because, and I say this for the third time, they don’t get to dictate who gets how many votes. They can’t say if they won or lost their own races or any other race that is counted at the city, county or state level. They can try but they will fail. What they can do based on the bullshit argument they are advancing is that the legislature has the right to determine which slate of presidential electors will be sent. That is the sum total of their argument. May they have no luck with it.
…but even if they do have luck, that still isn’t the end of elections as we have known them. It’s just the effect of the slavery-inspired electoral college solution to the presidential election problem. That has a solution, too. Several of them, even.
Even I don’t know the particulars of the case, now that I’ve looked at it. The things that are at stake in the case is the drawing of maps and setting dates and counting time limits, and yes, they want to be able to draw the most egregious maps that they can get away with and not have them questioned. The shortest counting times. At some point they are going to alienate some group or other that will invalidate the calculations that go into whatever maps that they are working under at the time, and then they’ll lose those seats they thought they couldn’t lose. That still doesn’t mean they can change the vote counts in any election. That simply isn’t something they will ever be allowed to do. Kill people they don’t want voting? That’s happened before. Invalidate votes that were legitimate? Also happened before. Declare themselves winners when they lost and have it stick through the next election? That just doesn’t happen.
I mean, Trumpists could well destroy this country by screwing up elections to the point where we have to go to war with them to stop their bullshit, but that’s going to take more than just this one SCOTUS case to pull off. Put Trump or any other person in the office of the President that is essentially a higher-functioning Trumpist, the next Nixon or DeSantis or whoever, and have them do what Trump tried to do but succeed at it? Okay. Then it would be over, because there would be little left to preserve once we drug the bastard out of office and treated him the way all dictators should be treated.
I do actually understand what you are saying. One of my degrees is in Government. I love this stuff.
So, a while ago, the Supreme Court ruled against the Voting Rights Act saying that the federal government could not interfere in state elections, and only state courts could interfere with state elections.
Well, this case is likely to say that state courts cannot interfere with how the states handle federal elections. Thus, the individual legislatures are the only ones with the power to set rules for federal elections.
In the worst case scenario, Texas could have two separate sets of rules for elections. One set of rules would apply to the state elections, and another set of rules would apply to federal elections. And again, the only body that could make those rules for federal elections is the state legislatures.
So, in the worst case scenario, the legislatures could theoretically unilaterally pick all winners of federal elections and nobody, no court in the land, could step in and stop them.
Now, that doesn’t have to happen. Republicans could do the right thing and listen to the will of the people. I don’t have any faith in them to do that.
That is why I am saying what I am saying. I 100% understand that it can come off as incendiary or that I’m merely scaremongering, but this next election really is vital to the survival of our system of governance.
You are still saying exactly the same thing; which, just FYI, isn’t possible. They don’t do the counting and so can’t dictate winners and losers. You ascribe to them power that they don’t have.
I am 100% behind getting every single eligible voter to the polls. Everyone to the polls, in this election and in every election. This election is perhaps the most important election in our lives, since so many things hang on keeping the Republicans from retaking the house, including the very existence of this country after 2024.
…but I draw the line at saying something that would be the end of this country could well happen. It can’t happen because that would be the end and the end is what I am (and every other living person should be) fighting against. So it can’t happen because we won’t let it happen, one way or the other.
Then the Christianist Walked In
They objected to the phrase “taking back the red states.” I don’t think they understood what makes a christian different from a Christianist. You would think that a group of people who lit their hair on fire over Islamists (versus Muslims) for twenty years would be able to appreciate the difference between the two most important variations in Christendom; namely, those who seek political power through perverting Christianity and those who simply believe in the teachings of Jesus Christ. That same split exists in all religion, in all motivated belief. It is the major problem with religion itself.
Why do you feel the Red states belong to the people in blue states? That’s the exact opposite of representation. Christians have every right to have their views represented as well. Red states have every right to stay red too.
The problem is that the Red states are not actually majority Red/Republican/Christianist. They are just the ones that hold power currently, and they do it through means that are questionable at best. Their religion is not the governing law of our country, nor will it ever be. The vast majority of Americans in any state do not want some other person’s religion being enforced as law; and no one person has a religion that is the same as another person. This is the reason why there is a separation between church and state. Because putting the two together has demonstrated, time and again, that what you get out of that combination is a lot of blood and no justice.
The religion isn’t ruling anything though. It’s an overgeneralization used by those on the left to demonize religious people, specifically Christians who do make up the majority religion in the US, and pretend it’s only because of religion that laws they don’t like are passed.
Christianity has over 33,000 variations so how do you in good faith claim that Christians are ruling through their religion? Which one? It’s a lie that just gets regurgitated constantly to avoid actual discussion and just “otherize” people you disagree with.
Instead of admitting that maybe people don’t agree with you about things like abortion or drugs or other immoral things without it being just due to her religion.
You don’t have to have a religion to believe murder is bad. You don’t need to have religion to believe other things are bad for society too.
For the record Texas is majority red. Majority is dictated by the voting within our districts. Not by the overall popular vote. I know that’s not how you guys want it to work because it works better for your party to only appease those in the large urban centers but that’s not how things are designed to work.
Which sect is the majority of Texas? (this was a trick question.)
Exactly, we don’t know. You can go to just about any town in Texas and find five to ten different christian churches in even the smallest towns. All teaching their own interpretation of the text.
You miss the point. There is no thing called “christianity” so if the Christianists get their way (and they pretty much already have) then one of those flavors of teachings will become the state sanctioned version. Which version will it be?
…this is what happens when you start encoding your unsupported, unsupportable beliefs into law. Things like prayer in school. Things like outlawing abortion. Bad things happen because of the things that you did and didn’t understand the consequences for. There will be a thousand different prayers before every school day, during every school day, taking up every minute of every school day. There will be dead women because of overturning Roe. This chaos is on the backs of people who say “why can’t I do this?”
(Texas is not majority red; Texas is majority christian. This is a subtle but important difference that everyone should take note of. The largest single sect of the chrisitian faith represented in Texas is probably Catholic since the majority of Hispanics are Catholic. Are you ready to be converted to Catholicism? If not then I wouldn’t be so keen on making religion a part of government.)
No you missed the point by trying to peg the laws people want passed to a religion that has 33,000 different variations and interpretations. You want to use the term “Christian” so demonize people and make your point then claim there is no such thing when it’s pointed out how flawed your over generalized demonization is.
Freedom is chaotic when you care about controlling others. My choice to abort or own a firearm shouldn’t be any of your business. Maybe if you guys stopped advocating for having control over others then others wouldn’t try to have control over you. You can’t just love it when it’s your brand of authoritarianism.
It’s interesting you condemn prayer in school, a personal choice, with aborting a unborn child though. Both should be personal choices but you only want to regulate one.
There is no choice when the authority leads the prayer. I’m not the one missing the point, but then I’m also not the one pretending there is no problem here. Trumpists will institute one Christianity, and through their institution they will create a new version of papistry. This is, after all, what they’ve been angling for since Jesus and his contemporaries first pronounced that the end was nigh more than two thousand years ago. It’s just never been possible for humanity to bring about the end of the world before now.
Personally I’d rather avoid their christian Armageddon, their Dominionist dreams. I’d rather that the world, human civilization, went on. With or without them, that is their choice.
Nobody can force people to pray and nowhere have I seen that as policy. A teacher on a football field after the game is over praying isn’t forcing anyone to pray. It absolutely isn’t a problem and the SC agreed. I know the media tried to spin it as being more than it is but there was nothing there.
Again wild generalizations about a diverse religion that borders on discriminatory hate speech. I know it’s trendy to badmouth religious people but this is just ridiculous. If someone said this type of thing about the Jews there would be outrage but because it’s Christianity it’s for some reason okay.
Trumpists are already targeting Jews, Muslims, etc. Look to your left. Look to your right. See who you are defending.
The coach you are talking about demanded the players pray with him. It was a requirement which is why he was fired and why non-believers at the school objected. The real story is there if you simply take the time to find it.
There will be mandatory religious indoctrination, just as there was in the fifties, the fifties that no one living remembers. That is what Christianists, now Trumpists, have been working towards since they established the Moral Majority and forced their religion into the political stage.
Like calling someone a fascist, it’s not a personal attack if that person is a fascist. It’s not a prejudicial attack if the group in question is actually doing what they are accused of doing. Christianists want their religion as law just as Islamists want Sharia law. They are both a corruption of what secular government should strive for. This isn’t some conspiracy fantasy, this is what they’ve been saying themselves for more than fifty years.
That’s not what the filed lawsuit and testimony said which is why you don’t believe what people say outside of the risk of perjury. It’s why you don’t trust what Gulliani said if it wasn’t under oath. The coach didn’t force anyone to pray.
Again who is they? You keep trying to label a whole religion with your conspiracy theory. You are spreading hate speech to demonize people based on their religion.
You are factually wrong about the ruling.
https://apnews.com/article/fact-check-supreme-court-coach-prayer-schools-602630743738
No, I’m not factually wrong. Here’s a VOX article on the subject:
In the real case that was actually before the Supreme Court, Coach Kennedy incorporated “motivational” prayers into his coaching. Eventually, these prayers matured into public, after-game sessions, where both Kennedy’s players and players on the other team would kneel around Kennedy as he held up helmets from both teams and led students in prayer.
In this picture, from the school district’s Supreme Court brief, coach Joseph Kennedy holds one of his prayer sessions for public school students. Bremerton School District
After games, Kennedy would also walk out to the 50-yard line, where he would kneel and pray in front of students and spectators. Initially, he did so alone, but after a few games students started to join him — eventually, a majority of his players did so. One parent complained to the school district that his son “felt compelled to participate,” despite being an atheist, because the student feared “he wouldn’t get to play as much if he didn’t participate.”
When the Bremerton school district learned of Kennedy’s behavior, it told him to knock it off — though it did offer to accommodate Kennedy if he wanted to pray when he wasn’t surrounded by students and spectators. And Kennedy did end some of his most extravagant behavior, such as the prayer sessions where he held up the helmets while surrounded by kneeling students.
vox.com
There is a lot of misrepresentation about the case, yes. Am I misrepresenting it? No. Who are they? You’ve never heard of the Moral Majority? I find that hard to believe. They are the people being served by these rulings. Not you, not your flavor of the christian faith, unless it happens to agree with whatever doctrine they impose once they gain power at the head of the next zealot that comes to power with their support.
The AP article ignores what actually happened, just like Gorsuch (who proves why he shouldn’t be on the court) ignored what actually happened. Gorsuch repeated the lie that was told by the coach, not the actual stated case in the brief before the court. Consequently the decision doesn’t present the clear case that AP and Gorsuch want to pretend is there. There are now grounds for prayer to be conducted in every school, lead by authorities at the front of the class.
Anyone who does not concede this fact simply wants to ignore the gorilla in the room. That is what the coach was doing, and that is what Gorsuch has said was okay. Repeating the lie does not make it truth.
From the dissent:
The Court now charts a different path, yet again paying almost exclusive attention to the Free Exercise Clause’s protection for individual religious exercise while giving short shrift to the Establishment Clause’s prohibition on state establishment of religion. … To the degree the Court portrays petitioner Joseph Kennedy’s prayers as private and quiet, it misconstrues the facts. The record reveals that Kennedy had a longstanding practice of conducting demonstrative prayers on the 50-yard line of the football field. Kennedy consistently invited others to join his prayers and for years led student athletes in prayer at the same time and location. The Court ignores this history. The Court also ignores the severe disruption to school events caused by Kennedy’s conduct, viewing it as irrelevant because the Bremerton School District (District)stated that it was suspending Kennedy to avoid it being viewed as endorsing religion. Under the Court’s analysis, presumably this would be a different case if the District had cited Kennedy’s repeated disruptions of school programming and violations of school policy regarding public access to the field as grounds for suspending him. As the District did not articulate those grounds, the Court assesses only the District’s Establishment Clause concerns. It errs by assessing them divorced from the context and history of Kennedy’s prayer practice.
Today’s decision goes beyond merely misreading the record. The Court overrules Lemon v. Kurtzman, 403 U. S. 602(1971), and calls into question decades of subsequent precedents that it deems “offshoot[s]” of that decision. Ante, at22. In the process, the Court rejects longstanding concerns surrounding government endorsement of religion and replaces the standard for reviewing such questions with anew “history and tradition” test. In addition, while the Court reaffirms that the Establishment Clause prohibits the government from coercing participation in religious exercise, it applies a nearly toothless version of the coercion analysis, failing to acknowledge the unique pressures faced by students when participating in school-sponsored activities. This decision does a disservice to schools and the young citizens they serve, as well as to our Nation’s longstanding commitment to the separation of church and state. I respectfully dissent.
supremecourt.gov
It tells me that the AP has gotten lazy because it took the word of a rigged court over the facts in evidence. Facts cited by the dissent and available to everyone including the majority of the court that informed the AP and also ignored the facts. The problem with believers is that they think everything is a belief. Facts don’t require belief. Facts are facts.
I’m just going to say this here and now because it’s a 50/50 chance whether you’ll be able to see even this within the next 24 hours. No one is reading this deep into the thread besides you and me and whatever mods are sent here to find out what you and I are still talking about. So this is just for you.
It is the very fact that you not only do not care that he is indoctrinating children into his faith and it is the near-certain fact that you probably think this indoctrination is desirable that makes us mortal enemies, never to be allowed to see eye to eye on pretty much any subject. Children’s minds are the future and I will do whatever it takes to make sure that the children of the future are not indoctrinated into a medieval personality cult just so that people like you can feel vindicated in your false beliefs.
Yes, false beliefs, which can be demonstrated to you if you only open your eyes. You won’t open your eyes, though. This was the lesson learned when evolution was demonstrated to be true. When gays were shown to be perfectly fine average citizens and when black people turned out to be just more average people (Just like the Jews and the Chinese and the Irish and the Germans, etcetera, etcetera, ad nauseum) because the people who believed things contrary to these truths crafted a society and a government that made sure that the desired outcomes occurred. That blacks were poor and that gays were outcast (like the Jews, the Muslims, etcetera, etcetera and again, ad nauseum) These are the hallmarks of false belief, a belief that I assume you still carry to this day because you are busy pretending that this coach isn’t doing what he is doing.
So I will see your ideals overthrown and trodden into the dust, because that is the only way that you will ever learn of the falsity of your beliefs. On that day I will accept your apology for the bullshit you spewed in this thread, but not one day before that.
Remember this day. This is the day, the thread, the set of SCOTUS decisions that lit the average American’s hair on fire and set them on the path to destroy you and people like you because you put those people on the SCOTUS to do the things they are now doing. YOU did this. Revel in what comes next, if you can.
Good day, sir.
