Roundup is Not the Problem

Podcast Science

A recently published study found that glyphosate “may serve as one of the drivers for antibiotic resistance,” and that it may contribute to “the proliferation of plant and animal pathogens.”

Many in the scientific community say that we don’t know enough about the ecological and health effects of glyphosate, and that more research is necessary.

What do you think?

Should the U.S. ban glyphosate? Increase funding to scientific research into its impacts? Why or why not?

Countable

Roundup is not the problem. Being afraid of things we don’t understand is the problem. Roundup is one of the safest herbicides we have, but the word safe applied to things that are designed to kill something, even plants, is deceiving. Compared to other treatments, glyphosate (Roundup) requires fewer, lighter treatments, completely the opposite of what most people think. I wrote at length about Monsanto and Roundup in this post a few years back. Monsanto isn’t evil and neither is Roundup. What is evil is the targeting that environmentalists do in association with their delusions about clean food.

I also find myself repeating this more and more often these days. One study does not a science make. One study is possibly a anomaly. Two studies begins to look like real data. Three studies and you might be onto something. Get back to me when there is as much evidence that Roundup causes cancer as there is evidence (or a lack of evidence) that it is cancer causing. The entire paragraph that the sentence is in on the Countable.com site is fallacious; as in begging the question, the real begging the question not the popular refrain begging the question, which is the opposite of fallacious. But confusing fallacy names aside, there can’t be any of the scary things mentioned associated with the herbicide, because there is no data linking it to the scary things other than popular belief trying to find causes for things that may not even be happening.

Learn and understand, not fear and react. That should be a modern mantra.

Countable.com comment expanded.

Inquiring Minds (ep. 235) Up To Date | Monsanto Cancer Case and Kids Believe Lying Robots

(Reuters: Monsanto ordered to pay $289 million in world’s first Roundup cancer trial it was, in fact, not the glyphosate that was cancer causing. It was an additive to the herbicide.)

Postscript

The Inquiring Minds podcast (Patreon) that talked about Monsanto is almost inaccessible now unless you go to their website directly, scroll down through (at current count) 427 episodes to the one with the right title. Good luck in your search.

Countable ceased to exist and was folded into causes.com, which is pretty dismissible as a site itself. The thing that made Countable a thing was the app on your phone that linked you to the opinions of millions of other people. A website is a thing that isn’t immediate and present. It’s just there on the internet. So much of the stuff that we thought was going to make a difference back at the beginning of all this technology either doesn’t make a difference or makes things worse, not better. As I write this we’re in the middle of an AI bubble, the latest thing to take the internet by storm, like online petitions, blogs and email once did before it. I’m just waiting for the Butlerian Jihad. Only a matter of time now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top