A friend of mine on Facebook asked the question (because everyone was asking the question at the time or because he was working on a story about time travelers? You decide) whether, if you could time travel, would you go back in time and kill Hitler as a child so as to avert World War Two? One of the things I said in response was that there have been dozens of stories done on this subject already.
From The Twilight Zone to Doctor Who, the specific story of killing Hitler has been done to death. I don’t know how many shows or books have been written on that specific subject, I just know that this is a common puzzler in literary circles, kind of like Niven’s legendary Man of Steel, Woman of Kleenex; as my friend aptly replied at the time “This is how good stories are told. Asking questions.”
I wasn’t trying to dampen the discussion, though. Don’t get me wrong. It’s just that I’d formed my own conclusions on this specific subject already, having thought about it previously. I’m a time travel story connoisseur, after a fashion. I love these kinds of stories; I just think that the subject of killing Hitler has already been visited a thousand times already. You’re really going to have to work to get a fresh angle on it.
Killing Hitler as a child makes you the criminal, because he hasn’t done anything yet. There is a basic REBT experiment where you ask yourself if a historical event should have happened; like the Nazis and WWII. The answer is; yes it should have happened, because it did happen. Killing Hitler as a child means you killed an innocent child, and what was WWII goes on to occur anyway, because the forces at play would have lead to the conflict with or without him.
World War II was inevitable as soon as the treaty of Versailles was signed. Everyone who understood the politics involved understood that Germany would be unable to meet the demands contained in the treaty. The butterfly flaps its wings and the war starts. The seeds of chaos are sown everywhere, all the time.
If you look back from today you see what Hitler did and think “I could stop all that.” From the perspective of then-is-now, you will be arrested for killing a child and most likely tried, because that is all he is then. A child. If you tell the people who stop you that you are a time traveler, you will most likely be subjected to what was considered psychological treatment at the time. I say no thanks on that score. So it’s either don’t make the trip or don’t get caught on the trip.
If you aren’t caught after killing Hitler (and I’m not certain what turn of the century Austria was like) then WWII still occurs. The holocaust probably still occurs because anti-Semitism was rampant then. The forces at play were bigger than any one man.
The real time traveling head scratchers come about from changing things that happened at pivotal moments in the distant past. Like, what happens if you cure Alexander the Great of the illness that kills him in the middle of his conquest of of the old world on the one hand; or maybe kill him as a child on the other. All of history changes if you change his life.
An even larger impact would be to render Genghis Khan impotent since he fathered more descendants than any other historical figure has. You don’t even have to kill him. His men won’t follow him any longer. You stop the slaughter but wipe out half of modern humanity.
Or maybe go back to the time in history right before the historical Eve and stop the human population from collapsing to the point where every modern human person can be traced back to this one woman. There’s no telling what might be altered by simply changing the gene pool that far back in time.
My point was, with all of these examples; is that there’s a lot of things in human history we’d like to change, but changing any of them changes who we are now. It’s a have a cake and eat it too scenario. There can’t be two cakes because there is just one cake. One life experienced one second at a time until the experience stops.
So, while I love time travel stories, I don’t think I’d time travel if I had a choice. If I don’t have a choice about traveling or not, then I set up posts at the beginning and end of the universe as we know it and I keep a dead man’s switch at the end times. If something happens to stop me from being able to get to the end of the universe to set up that dead man’s switch, then I know that something has been changed that ceases the constant ability to monitor and maintain the One True Timestream (whatever that is) and then it becomes my job, my employers job, whatever, to find and fix whatever was changed so that time flows as it is supposed to flow.
The little shit that makes up everything that is important in an individual’s life is immaterial in a scope that is that large. Which is the ultimate problem with time travel, the irrelevance of the actions of anyone beyond the sphere of the people who knew them or are directly descended from them. In the end, as long as the next generation succeeds as this one did, the little shit is irrelevant. Some of us were born Morlocks and some of us were born Eloi. That we existed at all is all that matters. Without existence there are no questions and without questions there are no stories.
Postscript
Stonekettle was working a personal version of the trolley problem, I think, based on some of the later comments down thread from mine, the ones I used to draw up these time travel observations. I’ve talked about the trolley problem a few times on the blog before and since. I could throw the lever but not push the fat man, when it comes to the trolley problem.
I find it interesting that this question was asked right before Trump burst on the scene, altering American politics the way that he did. The way that he has done since 2015. There’s a time travel puzzler. What would have happened had someone in authority actually prosecuted Donald Trump, or his father, or his grandfather, for their crimes before the election of 2016? They were all engaged in criminal behavior, the kind of behavior that would have gotten a lesser person jailed in an instant. Because they were real estate barons they got away with it.
“Who will build the housing if you jail all the land developers?” I hear Rudy Giuliani and dozens of other mayors and governor types asking. The next guy that thinks he can make a buck more than the last guy, that’s who. The real puzzle, again, is what would the world have looked like in 2016 without Donald Trump running for office? I imagine Stonekettle has written that story somewhere.
Featured image: The Butterfly Effect demonstration image from Wikipedia.
